Here’s the thing: The Pirates could be good and still finish fourth in the NL Central. That is their predicament.
They’re intriguing. I’ll say that much.
The first guy to get the ball, Thursday in Cincinnati, will be rising star Jameson Taillon. The last guy to get the ball, on many days, will be All-Star closer Felipe Vazquez. The pitching could be formidable, and for all the legitimate questions about the lineup, every position player outside of shortstop Erik Gonzalez has produced at least one good season. So it’s in there.
But here’s the other thing: In addition to competing in the brutal NL Central, the Pirates face a persistent opponent called apathy. Fan apathy. The team lost a million paying customers over the past three years, and the buzz factor at the moment … well, let’s just say it’s not exactly baseball Mardis Gras around here.
Anger remains, and anger is good. Anger means people still care. Most of it is centered around the Pirates setting sail on 2019 with no major additions and a payroll smaller than Jose Altuve. But as the above number would suggest — a million fewer fans — much of the anger has melted into apathy. And apathy is a professional sports team’s worst enemy.
The Pirates need something dramatic to happen in order to reverse the trend. They need to win big. They must get off to a good start and thrust themselves into the divisional race.
Read More
They need Josh Bell to recapture his rookie form and then some. They need Gregory Polanco to get healthy fast, never slide again, and turn flashes of greatness into something more than that at age 27. They need Jung Ho Kang to hit at least 25 home runs. They need Corey Dickerson to do everything he did last season. They need Francisco Cervelli to stay on the field. They need Joe Musgrove to harness his immense potential and Trevor Williams to produce a sequel and Chris Archer to pull an A.J. Burnett. They need a major surprise or two.
Last year’s trade deadline proved the fan base is not yet beyond resuscitation. The shocking addition of Archer brought life. Then August happened.
September was great. The Pirates rebounded to produce just their fourth winning season in 26 years. But was it real? Was it a launching pad into this season or an illusion, like so many Septembers across baseball history?
The Pirates could radically alter their profile by making a successful pitch to free-agent starter Dallas Keuchel. That would be dramatic. Can you imagine? They could suddenly stake a claim to the scariest rotation in baseball.
OK, now wake up. It was just a pipe dream. First, Keuchel would have to opt for a one-year deal. Second, the Pirates would have to part with precedent and spend huge money on a starting pitcher.
You’ll have to settle for Jordan Lyles and whatever comes next if he doesn’t pan out.
In the meantime, look around.
The Chicago Cubs might have been the most maligned 95-win team in baseball history. They’re betting on internal improvement from the likes of Yu Darvish, Kris Bryant and Kyle Schwarber. They are better than the Pirates and still have a payroll more than three times as large.
The St. Louis Cardinals finished ahead of the Pirates for the 19th consecutive season and added an elite hitter in Paul Goldschmidt, then signed him to the largest contract in franchise history ($130 million over five years), a contract worth more than twice as much as the largest ever doled out by the Pirates (Jason Kendall, $60 million).
The defending division-champion Milwaukee Brewers might not get a repeat performance from Christian Yelich, but they added a major piece in catcher Yasmani Grandal. He is sort of the catching equivalent of what Keuchel could be, having signed a one-year, $18.25 million deal.
The Brewers are the definition of “all in.” They went last year where so many teams won’t go, spending big money on a 30-something free agent in Lorenzo Cain. He responded with an All-Star season.
Even the Reds are interesting. How could they not be with Yasiel Puig on board?
Where does all that leave the Pirates?
Flirting with the second wild-card spot for much of the season, I’d say, and finishing with an 83-79 record. That'll be good for third place in the division, ahead of the Reds and whichever among the other three falters.
A decent year, to be sure. But here’s the thing: It’s going to take something well beyond decent to recapture a million lost fans.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.