KDKA Radio’s John Shumway asked the question bluntly.
“Do you need to spend some money and bring in a big bat?”
Pirates president Frank Coonelly’s answer in an interview with the station last week was a weak analogy.
“Look at the Oakland [Athletics] this year, they started the season with the lowest payroll in all of Major League Baseball and they ended up winning 98 games,” Coonelly said. “We need to get better and personnel will be part of that solution, but it’s never just about money.”
It was a fair characterization of what transpired. Oakland won on a budget and made the playoffs, losing Wednesday in the AL wild-card game to the Yankees. It’s possible to do it in MLB. We usually see one or two teams do it every year. It hasn’t been too long since the Pirates were one of those teams.
The problem is that Coonelly’s comparison of his team to that one lacks any depth beyond pointing to Oakland’s low payroll. Here are three reasons his framing of the situation is lazy:
Read More
1) Oakland gets more value from its drafts
Third baseman Matt Chapman was awesome this season, putting up a fat triple-slash line of .278/.356/.508 to go with 24 homers. Pair that with solid defense, and he was worth a robust 6.5 wins above replacement, according to Fangraphs. He’s a former first-round pick.
Across the diamond, Matt Olson wasn’t quite as good defensively at first base. Still, he thumped 29 homers, slugged a healthy .453 and was worth 3.4 WAR. He was a top-50 pick.
And in the bullpen, closer Blake Treinen was a Cy Young candidate, striking out more than 11 batters per nine innings while posting a microscopic ERA of 0.78 and a similarly impressive WHIP of 0.83. He’s a former seventh-round pick and was worth 3.6 WAR.
The three of them made a combined $3.2 million. The only home-grown Pirates in their neighborhood were Jameson Taillon and Starling Marte, at 3.7 WAR apiece. Their combined price tag: $8.4 million.
You see the problem, right? The core of Oakland’s roster is very good and very cheap. That’s a tribute to drafting and developing much better than the Pirates have since the likes of Andrew McCutchen and Neil Walker were coming through the pipeline. And armed with the savings...
2) Oakland spent money for power
Shortstop Jed Lowrie smacked 23 homers and played solid defense. He was acquired in a trade with Houston three years ago, made $6 million this year and was worth 4.9 WAR.
Outfielder Khris Davis was one of the best power hitters in baseball. He had a whopping 48 blasts while making $10.5 million. He was added in a trade with the Brewers two years ago and was worth 2.6 WAR.
Catcher Jonathan Lucroy was arguably a mistake. He was signed to a one-year deal worth $6.5 million and contributed middling stats that added up to just 0.6 WAR. But he does have some power-hitting pedigree going back to his days in Milwaukee.
Add those three salaries up, and Oakland paid roughly the free agent market rate for the power production it received.
That’s where the substance of Coonelly’s point begins to fall apart. Yes, Oakland’s overall payroll was exceedingly low, and yes it won, but that wasn’t because the Athletics were unwilling to pay up to have some thump in their lineup. It’s because they got very cheap, very solid production in the other places that allowed them to spend elsewhere.
Worst of all, Coonelly’s argument ignores the reality that...
3) The Pirates have followed a similar script in the past
The 2013-15 playoff runs were built on the same model. McCutchen, Walker, Marte, Josh Harrison and Gerrit Cole were part of a really cheap core that put up some really solid numbers.
General manager Neal Huntington surrounded those guys with more expensive but reasonably priced veterans such as Russell Martin, A.J. Burnett and Francisco Liriano.
The 2019 Pirates will have some similarly solid, inexpensive players on their Opening Day roster — infielder Adam Frazier, catcher Elias Diaz and starters Taillon, Joe Musgrove and Trevor Williams come to mind.
What they don’t have at the moment is power. Only two players — outfielders Marte and Gregory Polanco — hit more than 15 home runs this season, and Polanco figures to miss a significant chunk of 2019 with an injury.
Unless Huntington has unforeseen plans for someone in his system to come up and hit 30 homers, the only way he can add pop to this lineup is with a trade for or signing of a player with a proven track record. That will probably cost a nice chunk of money, which the Pirates figure to have after cutting loose some expensive veterans over the past year.
Winning may not be just about the money, but if the Pirates wanted to win like the Athletics have, there are a lot of things they could and should have done better on the drafting and development side.
Now that Coonelly and Co. have put together the core of another winning team, to their credit, getting it to the next level is a matter of literally paying for its shortcomings.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.