The optimist in me can’t wait for the start of the 2019 baseball season. I like the Pirates’ chances of being successful because I really like their pitchers — starters and relievers. I think the staff could be among the best in the game.
The pessimist in me hopes the Penguins’ season lasts until July because I’m afraid of what baseball season here might bring. I think it will be hard for the Pirates to compete because of their lineup. Making it better will involve spending money. When has that happened with Bob Nutting in charge?
I must be crazy, but I’m feeling a little more optimistic than pessimistic today.
I know I’m old-school — just old, actually — but I still believe good pitching is the best way to win a championship. Give Neal Huntington credit for building a formidable staff. It is strong from top to bottom.
Begin with the starters. I haven’t liked the Pirates’ top of the rotation this much since the days of Doug Drabek and John Smiley. Trevor Williams might have been the best pitcher in baseball after the All-Star break. His 1.38 ERA was second-best behind Tampa Bay’s Blake Snell. Jameson Taillon was nearly as effective. He allowed three or fewer earned runs in his final 22 starts. That is a heck of a one-two punch.
Ivan Nova had a 3.71 ERA in his final 12 starts. Chris Archer, after a rough start with the Pirates after joining the team at the trade deadline, went 2-1 with a 2.70 ERA in September. Joe Musgrove showed an A.J. Burnett-like passion, taking out the Cubs’ Javy Baez with a slide into second base in May and hitting Arizona’s Chris Owings with a pitch in June for retaliation for Josh Harrison being hit. “He’s probably our second-best athlete on the club overall after [Starling] Marte,” Clint Hurdle said after Musgrove made a spectacular play on a bunt in Cleveland in July. If Musgrove is your No. 5 starter, you’re in pretty good shape. Nick Kingham and perhaps prized prospect Mitch Keller will provide depth. It’s a shame Chad Kuhl won’t be able to help after Tommy John surgery.
Read More
But the key is Archer. The Pirates gave up a ton — Tyler Glasnow, Austin Meadows and Shane Baz — to get him from Tampa Bay. He needs to pitch like he did in September, not August.
“I’m excited that he’s here,” Hurdle said late in the season. “I feel the same excitement I did on the day we traded for him, probably a little more …
“I’m excited what this rotation has a chance to develop into next year. He’s going to be a big part of it. It’s a big get for us. It’s a good get for us in a lot of different ways.”

The bullpen also is good enough to win a lot of games, although Edgar Santana’s Tommy John surgery is hurtful. Richard Rodriguez, Kyle Crick and Keone Kela should be able to get a ninth-inning lead to Felipe Vazquez in many games. Vazquez was nearly perfect after blowing four saves in five chances in late-May. He finished 37 of 42.
The pitching was good enough for the Pirates to finish 82-79, just their fourth winning season in the past 26 years. It was good enough to carry a lineup that had a lot of holes and lacked power.
Josh Bell has to be an in-house answer. It was baffling that he hit just 12 home runs after he hit 26 in 2017. The power is there. It’s important Bell unleashes it, especially with Gregory Polanco expected to miss as much as half of next season after maybe the worst slide in baseball history. The Pirates also need to get more home runs from another power position, third base. Colin Moran hit just 11 this season.
I’m holding out hope that Nutting will allow Huntington to spend a little money to bring in a big bat. I’m not talking about Bryce Harper or Manny Machado. I’m talking about a guy who will make the lineup more threatening and ease the burden on the pitching staff.
No chance, you say?
I said the same thing about Huntington giving up prized prospects to bring in a proven player, then he traded for Archer.
Maybe things are changing at 115 Federal Street. Maybe Nutting noticed the drop in attendance to 1.465 million this season, down from 2.498 million in 2015. Maybe he finally realizes he has to spend a little money to make money.
I admit it.
I really must be crazy.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.