Before Saturday’s game against the Cincinnati Reds, what could have been the penultimate game of Josh Harrison’s Pirates tenure, the 31-year-old second baseman kept his analysis of the Pirates’ season simple.

“To me, it’s playoffs or nothing,” Harrison said. “Finishing above [.500], it’s fine, but at the end of the day, one goal of mine is going to the postseason and getting a chance to play for something.”

The Pirates finished above .500 for the first time in three years, but they also missed the playoffs for the third consecutive year. By most measures, in most areas, they were average, to the point that the analytics and statistics website FiveThirtyEight took the time in August to calculate that the Pirates were the most average team among the four major sports in the past 50 years.

Their 82-79 record gave them a .509 winning percentage, 14th out of 30 teams. They scored one fewer run than they allowed. They were 44-36 at home, 38-43 on the road, 48-49 in the first half, 34-30 in the second. They ranked near the middle of the pack in most offensive categories, with notable exceptions.

Advertise with us

“These men together will be able to look each other in the eyes when they walk out, shake each other’s hand and say, ‘Well done. Work to do next year but well done. The season did not get away from us,’ ” manager Clint Hurdle said. “We stayed in the hunt, we kept fighting, we didn’t get to where we needed to go or where we wanted to go, but we stayed focused on getting better every day.”

What did them in? Could have been the 10-16 record in June, or the 10-17 August mark. They went 39-53 against teams better than .500, including 3-16 against the Arizona Diamondbacks, Atlanta Braves and Los Angeles Dodgers.

The following grades are based on the Pirates’ rankings within the National League and Major League Baseball:

Offense

The Pirates scored 4.3 runs per game, tied for eighth in the NL and slightly below the league average of 4.37. Their .317 on-base percentage ranked ninth, their .407 slugging percentage eighth. Advanced, weighted offensive metrics such as weighted on-base average, which attempts to calculate the run value of each offensive outcome, and weighted runs created-plus, which does a similar thing while correcting for league and park effects, the Pirates ranked ninth and seventh.

Advertise with us

“We’re talking about how we improve our game-planning, how we better individualize our game-planning, how we better prepare our hitters for what they’re going to face, how we impact their mentality and their approach and how we help them understand what type of hitters they can be,” general manager Neal Huntington said.

Their .254 average was tied for fourth-best in the league, and no NL team struck out fewer times. But they hit 157 home runs, 13th in the NL. Josh Bell and Corey Dickerson both hit 14 fewer home runs than last year. Colin Moran hit 11.

“Obviously Bell didn’t do the same thing he did last year,” former hitting coach Jeff Branson said Monday, after the Pirates let him go. “We couldn’t get him there. And when one of your young guys that the team is counting on struggles in that category as far as driving balls and, going into the season, that’s one thing that we need to rely on.”

Dickerson hit .300. Starling Marte hit 20 homers and stole 30 bases, becoming the third Pirate, along with Barry Bonds and Andy Van Slyke, to do so. Gregory Polanco led the team with 23 home runs and had a .499 slugging percentage. Francisco Cervelli had an excellent offensive year, using a swing change to hit a career-high 12 homers with a .378 on-base percentage. His counterpart, Elias Diaz, finished with a .286/.339/.452 line and 10 homers.

Adam Frazier’s father helped Frazier re-position his hands at the plate, and once Frazier returned to the majors for good on July 25, he hit .306/.357/.533 with seven homers.

Advertise with us

Grade: C-

Defense

According to Baseball Info Solutions’ calculation of Defensive Runs Saved, which tries to quantify defense in terms of runs prevented or allowed compared to average, the Pirates finished with a minus-26, 23rd in MLB. Ultimate Zone Rating, a similar stat, had the Pirates 18th, at minus-2.8.

Their defensive efficiency, or the percentage of balls in play turned into outs, was 68.6 percent, 20th in baseball. The Pirates allowed a major league-high 95 wild pitches — which is partly on the pitcher, partly on the catcher. Bell ranked last among qualified first baseman with minus-9 DRS. At third base, Moran ranked 16th out of 19, with minus-8.

“He’s been the first to acknowledge the defense is where the game was faster than he was used to and maybe ready for,” Huntington said of Moran. “He knows we have to improve our first step. He knows we have to improve our range there and that will have a significant impact.”

Advertise with us

Dickerson was the best defensive left fielder in the NL and second behind Alex Gordon in the majors, with 16 DRS.

“I think it was a combination of confidence, hard work that I put in with the way I run, the hand-eye drills I do in the offseason, catching balls, working with my trainer, and really wanting the ball to be hit to me every time,” Dickerson said.

Dickerson and Marte ranked 13th and 14th among outfielders in Statcast’s Outs Above Average, with 10.

Pirates catchers ranked sixth in caught-stealing percentage, largely thanks to Cervelli’s 19-percent improvement to 39 percent. Previously a suspect defensive second baseman, Frazier improved later in the season.

Grade: C-

Advertise with us

Starting pitching

Now to the bright spots. Jameson Taillon made 32 starts, posted a 3.20 ERA in 191 innings and did not allow more than three earned runs in his final 22 starts of the year.

“One of my biggest points of turning my season around was understanding what my strengths are,” Taillon said. “You hear it so much, what are your strengths? Or, pitch to your strengths. I actually feel like I learned statistically what my strengths were.”

Trevor Williams’ excellent second half helped him finish with a 3.11 ERA in 31 starts. Williams ranked seventh in the NL among qualified starters in ERA, Taillon ninth.

Ivan Nova finished with a 4.19 ERA. Joe Musgrove had streaks of excellence, but a season bookended by injury concluded with a 4.06 ERA in 115⅓ innings. Chad Kuhl rounded into form in mid-May (2.45 ERA through five starts) before struggling in June, and he eventually needed Tommy John ligament replacement surgery. Judging Chris Archer since his acquisition requires balancing August (6.45 ERA, 24 strikeouts in 22⅓ innings) with September (2.70 ERA, 36 strikeouts in 30 innings).

Advertise with us

The rotation’s overall ERA of 3.99 ranked eighth in the NL. Their 2.65 walks per nine ranked third.

Grade: B

Relief pitching

The back end of the Pirates’ bullpen was excellent. Closer Felipe Vazquez saved 37 games in 70 appearances and struck out 89 batters in 70 innings. Kyle Crick and Richard Rodriguez did not make the roster out of spring training but excelled upon their promotion. Crick had a 2.39 ERA in 64 appearances and Rodriguez struck out 88 batters in 69⅓ innings with a 2.47 ERA. Keone Kela excelled after his arrival from Texas, with 22 strikeouts in 15⅓ innings.

“We still had challenges in the mid-innings,” Hurdle said. “However, to finish the season, at one point in time, to have Vazquez, to have Keone, to have Crick, to have Rodriguez and [Edgar] Santana, eliminate one of them going into next year, we still have four solid arms to depend upon.”

Advertise with us

The middle innings are the issue. Dovydas Neverauskas and Michael Feliz struggled, as did Steven Brault at times.

“Our rotation was really good, our back end was really good,” Huntington said. “It just shows how much we struggled to keep a 5-2 deficit at 5-2 to give our offense a chance to chip away.”

Grade: B

Kyle Crick had a 2.39 ERA in 2018. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Coaching staff

The coaching staff and front office are ultimately judged by the record, but also by the performances of the players.

Advertise with us

The Pirates ran into 62 outs on the bases. Only four teams ran into more. Twenty-three of them came at the plate, more than only the Minnesota Twins.

The lack of production offensively already cost Branson and assistant hitting coach Jeff Livesey their jobs. The Pirates said they intend for the rest of the staff to return.

Hurdle gave 150 at-bats to Sean Rodriguez, despite a continued lack of production that resulted in a .167/.277/.313 line without the defense to make up for it. He inserted rookie Alex McRae into a tie game Aug. 4 and irked Taillon by removing him after 77 pitches and six-plus solid innings July 7, but generally managed his pitchers well. He also benched Marte after a game in which Marte displayed lack of hustle on two separate occasions, a good move.

Cervelli credited defensive improvement behind the plate to work with Heberto Andrade, and both Hurdle and the pitchers pointed to first-year strength coach Jim Malone’s program as beneficial to the staff.

Grade: C

Advertise with us

Front office

After not signing a major league free agent in the offseason, the Pirates did the opposite at the trade deadline. They traded three young, talented players for Archer, and two more prospects for Kela.

Those moves backed up Huntington’s call before the All-Star break that the next eight games would be crucial. The Pirates responded by going 7-1 and eventually won 11 in a row.

When the playoffs were out of reach, they traded David Freese and Adeiny Hechavarria and informed Harrison and Jordy Mercer of their reduced playing time, so they could see what Kevin Newman, Pablo Reyes and Kevin Kramer could do.

But while the acquisition of Dickerson worked well, it came after the subtraction of Andrew McCutchen, and the Pirates lacked the offense to back up their second-half pitching. The decision to start Clay Holmes in San Francisco after a series in Coors Field also cost the Pirates a game.

Advertise with us

Grade: C+

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.