Sean Gentille: What's going on, everyone? Nesbitt is parking or something. Notoriously unreliable, that one. I see some questions already, but we're ready for more.

Sean Gentille: There's like ... four hours to kill. Maybe more. This should be something.

Sean Gentille: The non-Kela news of the day, via Brink, is that the Pirates are in on Chris Archer in "significant fashion." Pretty weird!

Tim: If the Pirates were to get Chris Archer, how much better do you think the team is, with him and Kela onboard?

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Hey, I'm here.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Let me tell you, Bill Brink knows a thing or two about fashion.

Sean Gentille: I think the question is kind of "Can Chris Archer pitch up to his peripherals?" Because if he can, they're better by a good margin. A 3.62 xFIP is better than any starter, other than Taillon.

Sean Gentille: But that's been the book on him for years now. Even if he can't, he still makes them better. Immediately.

Sean Gentille: Archer, even post 2015-Cy run, has a 4.00-ish ERA with very obvious potential for more. You take that.

Advertise with us

JJ: Jon Heyman says Pirates definitely still in mix for Archer. U think that’s a real possibility of bringing him to Pittsburgh?

Sean Gentille: Who is Jon Heyman? I'm a Bill Brink man.

john rambo: guess the still unnamed player to complete Kela deal.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Bligh Madris.

Sean Gentille: "William Brink."

Advertise with us

Jim NYC: Is Mitch Keller for sure in the Archer package? Is that something you are in favor of? I'm not sure, afterall Archer is not a #1 SP

Stephen J. Nesbitt: As far as I've seen, no such package has been made public. If I'm the Rays, I'm demanding the offer start with one of the Pirates' top pitching prospects. That's Keller territory, but maybe Shane Baz. The Pirates aren't going to part with Keller unless they're certain this pitcher is going to be the difference this year. I'm not convinced Archer is the difference for them this year, and I doubt they are too. I think they'd be much more likely to give up a prized position-player prospect than Keller.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Archer is a No. 1 pitcher, but maybe in the way Gerrit Cole was a No. 1 pitcher and nobody here liked to say that.

Jim NYC: Do you think we can get any value for Cervelli? Do you think he's the Pirates' best catcher or has Diaz surpassed him?

Sean Gentille: Who actually needs Cervelli, at this point? The thing about catchers is that if you're good, you probably have one already. No contender needs a catcher, let alone one dealing with concussions. Might as well just keep him.

Advertise with us

Sean Gentille: Also, I think the bulk of all middle-aged moms in the fanbase would revolt at a Cervelli trade.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think anyone is giving up the farm for a catcher who had four concussions in the past year. He's best served staying with the Pirates and being an insurance policy paired with Elias Diaz while he gets things sorted out. He should test out first base.

JJ: U know exactly who Heyman is. And that’s no disrespect towards Bill Brink

Sean Gentille: More like Jon Who-man!!!

Sean Gentille: (Yes, I know who he is, that was a joke.)

Advertise with us

Chris Vegas: Archer can basically knock off an earned run and add a few strikeouts to his k/9 by going to the NL.

Sean Gentille: That's a good point. People are making the same one about Gausman, etc. You hear it so much that it gets kind of annoying, but it's grounded in reality.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Archer was a strikeout machine the past few years. The Pirates could use one of those. He's been quite a bit better away from the Trop recently too.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The latest on Chris Archer and the Pirates: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2018/07/31/chris-archer-pir...

Jim: Archer and Schoop. Couldn't get better than that.

Advertise with us

Sean Gentille: ^^Everyone asking about Archer, read that link. There are a lot of you.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Schoop was batting .197 on July 1!

Bobby: Archer is obviously the big name, but if they don’t get him, is there another SP you could see them adding before today’s deadline?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'm pretty firmly in the camp today of thinking the Pirates are going to add a starting pitcher today, but only one at least another year remaining under contract. Bringing on a rental doesn't make much sense — unless it's a reliever. I think Archer and Gausman make a lot of sense.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Really good Archer info here too: https://www.tampabay.com/data/2018/07/31/two-simple-charts-show-why-th...

Advertise with us

Sean Gentille: And that's directly in line with Kela, obviously. It lets them have their cake and eat it too. They're fortunate that the best guys on the market have years of control left, and it seems like that could pay off in a real way.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Here's the problem with the Pirates: Next year always looks great. It's the same this year. If they're willing to add a little payroll and people stay healthy, it's a promising roster next year, and the next year, and the next year. So how do they keep that intact while giving this year's team an extra boost?

Sean Gentille: And while we're talking about other reports, Joel Sherman said Archer was a 7 on a 1-10 scale of likeliness to get moved today. This was a couple hours ago.

Tony H: Any talk on Sonny Gray to the Pirates now that NYY has added more SP

Sean Gentille: Gray has one year of arb left, then is a UFA after 2019. Seems like an issue.

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Another interesting one. The Yankees clearly are going for it, and their team is loaded. But they picked up Lance Lynn yesterday, and Sonny is a little expendable. He has one year of arbitration left, so there's a chance the Yankees could sell low on him today. But, again, starting pitching never comes cheap, and you need protection in case of injuries. I think it's worth the Pirates asking. I don't know that they'll like what they hear.

Mason: I’d like to see Liriano back pitching in middle relief/lefty specialist. Only making around $1M this year and I think he is what the Pirates still need in the bullpen.

Sean Gentille: PROTECT STEVEN BRAULT AT ALL COSTS.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: He'd come pretty cheap. A swing-and-miss lefty out of the bullpen isn't something the Pirates have in the early innings — they have Felipe Vazquez for the back end, obviously. But Liriano still is missing the strike zone far too often. Trustworthy?

Guest: What are the Pirates chances of getting Chris Archer???

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: They're in the mix. What more can you ask.

Sean Gentille: 100 percent. Obviously.

Aron M: Do you get the sense that Huntington seems more likely, than in past years, to part with a top-prospect (Meadows, Keller, etc..) to get a SP who is under control for a couple of years?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: In my most humble opinion, I think yes. And here's why. After making the wild card game three years in a row, it's real easy to think, 'You know what, maybe shooting for a wild card isn't such a good idea. We should wait to go for the division.' But then two years pass — sad years, losing years — and maybe the wild card doesn't sound so bad? How many times can this front office afford to (sort of) punt on this year to wait for next? And we've seen plenty of times that prospects are promising, but they're no sure thing. I think they'll be very wary of parting with Keller, but the others may be more likely to go this year.

Ligma Bullpen: Anything at all suggesting the Pirates could add a 3rd baseman?

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think so. Between Colin Moran and David Freese, they're set.

Mike: Sup boys. Thinking the Yankees are out on Arch after their moves and sounds like Padres are fading. If it comes down to a bidding war with the Braves for Archer do you think the Pirates can/and would be willing to go toe-to-toe prospect wise? I know ATL is stacked.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: This front office isn't one to win bidding wars. But who knows.

Milkbutt: I would love for some middle IF help but haven't heard anything whatsoever about the Bucs pursuing that...

Sean Gentille: You know what, Adam Bittner wrote something good about that last week. And Milkbutt, I must say, I agree with you. Mercer and Harrison, statistically, have been brutal. That's a tough spot for the team, given what those guys mean and what they've done in the past, but in a vacuum ... that'd be an upgrade area. Read this from Bittner: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2018/07/26/pirates-trade-ru...

Advertise with us

Sean Gentille: And again, Milkbutt, I thank you for your question.

Wayward: Other than Kela and the potential SP acquisition, do you see the Bucs looking at any position players? Utility mostly as Sean Rod has still been bad.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Depending on whether Austin Meadows is moved today, there could be need for another outfielder. But let's say he isn't. I think there's room for one more bench bat, someone experienced (a rental is fine) to go with Sean Rodriguez, David Freese and the backup catcher on the bench.

Peter: Is the Melancon trade officially GMNH's best during his Pirates tenure?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It looks pretty dang good, doesn't it? Turned two months of Melancon (and a long line of previous reliever trades) to multiple years of Felipe Rivero-turned-Vazquez and now Keone Kela.

Advertise with us

Milkbutt: You are welcome *Tips fedora made out of milk carton*

Hunter Muro: Sean, there were a few rumors on a Twin's starter? Maybe Gibson? Are you hearing anything?

Hunter: Are you hearing anything on Kyl Gibson?

Sean Gentille: Which starter would the Twins sell, beyond Lynn? Cuz he's gone.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Gibson has bounced back nicely this season (3.42 ERA, 3.77 FIP) after 5-plus ERAs the past two years. He has swing-and-miss stuff but hasn't panned out quick as expected in Minnesota. I don't think he's someone I'd bet would end up far better than Kuhl/Williams/Musgrove/other back-end arms.

Advertise with us

DJ: What are your thoughts on the Cutch trade talks?

Texas Steeler: What do you think of the McCutchen rumors of being on the move

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Makes sense. He and Neil Walker can reunite in New York.

Wayward: Keller the only "untouchable"? I was thinking that he, Meadows and maybe Newman (or whomever they believe could be next years SS).

Sean Gentille: I'm still not sure why Meadows should be untouchable, but that's another story.

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I think Kevin Newman is pretty safe because it's unlikely the Pirates hold on to Jordy Mercer as their starter beyond this year. Newman will be an important component for them next year. But it's not like he's Manny Machado coming down the pike. He's trade-able, but you just have to have a plan for how to replace him.

Sean Gentille: People overreacted to some rough patches in AAA, then overreacted to a nice stretch here. I think the end result of that is that you move him for the right player.

Peter: Are you a bit surprised that Neal's pursuing such a big name like Archer? It might be confirmation bias, but he seemed to target smaller names (e.g., Happ) to incrementally improve the roster.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The big names are the ones that you hear about being pursued. When J.A. Happ came over, *nobody* reported any rumors. The news broke when the trade was announced. They've surely touched base on a number of off-the-radar starters, but we just haven't heard about them yet.

Rob: I think at this point Newman and Keller are staying put but why is nobody is talking about moving O'neil Cruz? His bat definitely has some trade value alone. Do you think he could be involved in a trade for Archer?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Cruz is one of those low-minors prospects who a trading team would covet. I'd think there's a good chance the Rays would want him if they indeed are putting together an Archer package.

JunJie: Plz, not Meadows

Sean Gentille: Something to think about here -- if they're trying for a plug-and-play starter like Archer or Gausman, someone would have to go from the rotation. And Nick Kingham is a) fungible b) with value. That doesn't mean anything, necessarily, but like ... Nova is what he is.

Mark C.: How much of this information is legitimate? You see all this information about the Pirates and Archer, and I wonder if these sources use the media to pump up the costs for these guys?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I can say from experience that this information rarely comes directly from team officials and general managers. And they're the ones who would want to over-inflate the market. It's more through-the-grapevine stuff, and reliable as long as you're trusting the right people. And, trust me, reporters aren't just firing off some tidbit their buddy at the bar told them. You're on the hook when you report something. You want to be right.

Mason : Any chance the Bucs would look to acquire 2 controllable SP and try to move Nova?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think it's likely, but I think there's some logic to it. Swing Nova back to the Yankees and pick up Gray.

morgan: Where does front office see Glasnow's future? Do they give him another shot as SP or just hope he can develop enough control to develop more than long reliever?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: With his talent — raw as it may be — you don't just stick that guy in a long-relief role for his career. As I said since last September, they needed to put him in a low-leverage situation in the majors (because he clearly wasn't picking up the necessary experience in the minors) so he could build confidence and build trust in his stuff. It has seemed to work this season, to some extent, but I think you have to try him again in the rotation next spring and beyond.

Morty: PTBNL isn't going to be a Moises Alou type is it?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It was reported this morning it was a lesser prospect than Taylor Hearn, but maybe it is Moises Alou. I cannot say.

Sean Gentille: It is literally Moises Alou. Can't say what the Rangers want with a 52-year-old guy, but who knows.

Tim: Would you be surprised if the Pirates did not acquire a starter before today's deadline? If Archer doesn't work out, who would be some back-up options? Thanks!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I would not be surprised, because the Pirates doing nothing major at the trade deadline is not a new thing, but I suspect they'll target starters and try to close a deal on one. Their depth is OK, with Kuhl, Glasnow, Brault, Holmes, but it's not depth you take into a September playoff push and feel good about. If there's a controllable starter you feel you can get at a decent value, I think you do it.

Stevie Janowski: Who is the “big name” traded today that makes us say, “Wow, I didn’t know he was available! That’s crazy.”

Sean Gentille: Kenny Powers.

Tim: If a starter is acquired, who gets bumped out of the starting rotation?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Probably Nick Kingham.

Chris Archer: What would it take for the Pirates to acquire my services?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Hi, Chris. Text me.

Wayward: What kind of deal do you think it would take to get Archer?

Sean Gentille: Is this whole day gonna go by without anybody making actual "Archer" jokes or what?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Rays GM won't call me back to find out, but let's say one of Pirates' top prospects (Meadows?), another from the next tier down (Cruz) and two more lottery-ticket ones. Just a guess.

Scott: Do you think the package that seems would include Keller, would also include a guy like O'Neil Cruz or Cole Tucker along with another prospect? Or would you lean towards a major league player going back with Keller?

Andy P, NYC: LAAAAAAAAAAAAAANAAAAAAAAAAAA

Sean Gentille: There we go.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I think you're talking about for Archer. I don't think the Rays want one of the Pirates' major leaguers unless it's a young starter (Kingham?), and the Pirates don't want to give up any major leaguers they're going to need for a playoff push. Not many players they can afford to part with.

Greg : If the Pirates get a starting pitcher, any one, would that move any of their current starters to the bullpen?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I've long thought Chad Kuhl would be a blast to watch tossing gas out of the bullpen for an inning or two.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Joe Musgrove has bullpen experience too.

Ferdinand: Doesn't Keone Kela sound like some sort of summer beer from Fat Heads?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It does indeed.

David Borne : Am I the only one completely uncomfortable with trading Keller for Archer?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: No.

Tim: With the Pirates seemingly focused on adding pitching, do you think they are right to be content with the offense as it is?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Eh, they kind of have to trust that the offense will hold up. Did you expect Elias Diaz to hit this well? Me either! But he is. You hope that Josh Bell and Josh Harrison hit, you hope the outfield stays healthy, and then you add at the edges (bench bat).

Ben: Now that the Yankees have traded for Lynn and are still going after Archer, is it possible that (if the Yankees get Archer) the Pirates would trade Meadows for Sonny Gray and Happ?

Sean Gentille: That'd be hilarious. Still -- Meadows for one sorta meh guy with one year of control + a rental seems impossible.

Sean Gentille: Aside from the fact that it just doesn't seem likely, at all, from the Yankees standpoint.

simon: With Dickerson down do Pirates look at another OF? ... McCutchen?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Simon, you joker!

Sean Gentille: Wrong Giants OF, dawg. Go get Gorkys.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Oh, you're serious. No, I don't think they'll bring back McCutchen. I think that marriage had its good days and its bad days, and now it's over and it's never coming back.

Tim: Non-deadline question; will Dickerson and Bell be back soon?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Yes.

Morty: Any word on interest in Gray? He looks to be odd man out in NYY and a better fit with Pirates approach. He's affordable and only 28 with a good track record (if not in NY)

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Affordable is an illusion in this city.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Actually the internet says this is an affordable city, so what I mean is with this team it's difficult to decipher what is affordable.

Sean Gentille: Back to Gorkys, if I may.

Ryan : I doubt we give up Keller

JD: Are the talks for Gausman pretty much dead?

Sean Gentille: He is 30 years old with a .770 OPS in 309(!) PAs with the Giants. GORKYS HERNANDEZ.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I heard yesterday that they were alive, with the Orioles doing background work on a number of minor leaguers. Haven't heard anything new since.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Wrong Giant. Bring back Alen Hanson.

David Borne : Obviously I like Chris Archer, but I don’t know if I’d be willing to move Keller for him just given the team’s current place in the stadings.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I agree.

Skip: Gausmann controllable or rental?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Controllable.

Chow: Don't get your hopes up boys lol

Andy: I was thinking Luplow, Stallings, Feliz, and Holmes for Archer. Something like that possible?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'll ask.

Sean Gentille: Aren't we all controllable?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: For the right price, yes.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The answer I got back was "abso-bleepin'-lutely not," Andy. Those are four non-top-level prospects.

MG: How do you see Glasnow fitting in Pirates plans in the future? Backend of pen now seems locked up next few seasons. Do you see a move back to rotation next season, rather than middle relief? Or could he be part of a package deal here in the next few hours?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: We discussed his future role earlier, MG, but as for your last question, I think you'd still be selling low on Glasnow now. Two years ago, you could have gotten the whole Rays team for him. Now he needs to show teams he can be a bonafide starter down the road, not just a long reliever. Those don't bring such a haul as starters.

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Morty: all the rumors have been around pitchers. Any word on Huntington seeking positional players? Middle IF and defensive/baserunning help could be a plus

Stephen J. Nesbitt: That's Alen Hanson's music.

Sean Gentille: MMMBop

Chris: Isn’t it more likely Meadows is the headliner going to Rays for Archer ? With Dickerson for 2019 and possible extend. Or how it is much easier to get an outfielder vs a good solid affordable starting pitcher.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I think so, yes.

Chow: My opinion, Archer won't happen. Don't get your hopes up boys

Stephen J. Nesbitt: OK, Chow.

Mark C.: Am I the only one who looks at Sonny Gray, and thinks AJ Burnett 2.0? A former top pitcher who needs a change of scenery and thrives?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: They look nothing alike.

Sean Gentille: I'd have to look farther in that to have an actual answer, but Sonny Gray is somehow only 28. He's been around forever.

Sean Gentille: Also he has the name of, like, a bootlegger or something. That makes him sound older.

Nick: The Kela trade is good, stabilizes the bullpen for a few more years, strengthens the team while only giving up a wildcard prospect. But is there a thought that throwing out names like Keller and Hayes as trade bait is selling the future for so-so chances at the wild card this year? Even if that future is just as trade bait next year when the playoffs odds could be better?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Yes, trading those guys damages your outlook three and four years down the road. But taking on new guys who are already big league arms and who will be around for two years isn't a bad move. It might not work out in your favor, but winning teams have to take a chance here and there. With that said, I'm pretty much sure I don't think Keller should be traded.

Sean Gentille: Also, re: Sonny Gray -- even though he's only 2018, he hasn't been good since 2015. That is alarming.

Sean Gentille: And granted, he was great that year.

Tony: Realize though Archer’s 4 ish ERA is in the incredibly powerful AL East. Yankees and Red Sox rule that division, and they both have powerhouse players on either team. A new division would do him wonders

Sean Gentille: But he has stunk with the Yankees and wasn't good at the end in Oakland either.

Bambi: While adding a quality SP would be nice with the addition of Kela our starters really only need to go 5-6 IP

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Counterpoint: Teams can still score a lot of runs in 5-6 innings.

Chow: Sherman says Pit, Mil, or Atl.

Sean Gentille: Sorry y'all, I just figured out how mediocre Sonny Gray has been with the Yankees.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Imagine hearing two years ago that the Pirates, Brewers and Braves were frontrunners for a real major league baseball pitcher.

Chris Vegas: Any interest in Dozier? I feel like the twins could sell a rental for cheap and Dozier would add a ton of pop.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Could be a great add to the bench, or to play behind Harrison. He's been rather sub-par this year, but great in the past. If you can buy low, that's worth asking about.

Rob: Pirates HAVE to trade for an front of the rotation starter. We've shown over the years that they are unable to develop their own. Why are we to believe it would be any different with Keller?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Keller has more polish than most every young pitcher they've brought up except for Taillon.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: And Cole.

Sean Gentille: A crazy idea would be to bring up Keller and let him do what he's actually good at.

Sean Gentille: It's a wild approach, but worth a shot.

LT: I don't understand the obsession with these strikeout pitchers. I understand K's are sexy and get everyone excited, but these guys are at 100+ pitches by the 6th inning. Give me the strikeout machine as a reliever, not as a starter.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It's a good trick to have up your sleeve.

Sean Gentille: Development is less the issue than what actually happens to guys once they are here.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: But, yes, pitch efficiency and low pitch counts are important. What I like about strikeout pitchers is not that they'll strike out everyone, but they have pitches that can miss bats. If you're relying only on ground balls, that's a scary life.

Andy P, NYC: Let's pretend the Pirates strikeout on today and get nada extra. They're *Probably* not making the playoffs, right? Are there any offseason adds they could make now that aren't available now? Because tbh, an Archer move feels like more help for next year than this year.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Bryce Harper will be a free agent. People forget that.

Sean Gentille: I can't believe people want Chris Archer this badly, a year after Gerrit Cole was run out of town on a rail.

Sean Gentille: Like, I've been thinking about it for almost 24 hours now.

Where's Liz?: So, do you think if all the Bucs do is acquire Kela, is that enough to keep the clubhouse satisfied? (Like "hey, at least they did something!") Or are they demanding more this year from management?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I think the clubhouse will be fine. The players I spoke with recently all said basically the same thing. It would be nice if they added, but I get why they wouldn't. I think there will be a couple moves today to add to the edges — middle relief, bench — and anything more than that is a bonus.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The fact we're talking about them adding would have *shocked* all of us earlier this month.

Chris: Yes or no prediction. Meadows goes in the next 3.5 hours

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Again, I'll always air on the side of no with the Pirates.

Rob: Pirates trade for Tony Watson. What do ya think?!?

Sean Gentille: They should pick up Juan Nicasio.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Watty's back. I think a package deal of him, McCutchen, Gorkys and Hanson is in the offing.

Wayward: Do guys Holmes, Eppler, Brubaker have value? Obviously not the kind to center a deal around but the kind that kind that could be included with a Top 5-10 guy to get a deal done?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Value, yes. But they're not the conversation starters.

Morty: Is Brault untradable, undemotable, or just too firmly planted in the circle of trust for mop up detail?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: He's demote-able, but not a real asset on the trade market. He is what he is right now — a long reliever.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Not gonna win you games. They're probably already lost anyway.

Rob: Do you think Luplow would be in the talks for a SP, considering we have our 4 OFs

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think teams are licking their chops to add Jordan Luplow.

bababooey: What if the pirates are really in line for Dri Archer?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: If it brings this chat Steelers-level clicks, I'm all for it.

Nephen Stesbitt: If the Pirates were to trade Meadows, what are the chances of them trying to extend Dickerson?

Sean Gentille: It'd be really funny to see Dri Archer play baseball. I'd expect a lot of drag bunts, then trips four steps down the line.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Decent. They don't have a ton of outfield depth in the minors.

Creme Brule: Do you think the Pirates should sign Dickerson long term if he is interested?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: If they trade Austin Meadows, sure. But Dickerson has been a pretty up-and-down ballplayer in his day, so you might not want to extend him during a hot streak and overpay.

Jake : Even with adding Kela and possibly Archer, is that enough to make the Pirates serious contenders?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: They're not the Cubs, but they're closer.

Mark C.: Sean, the difference is, the fans were given the impression that Cole didn't want to be here, that is why people soured on him.

Sean Gentille: Respectfully, who cares? Cole is better than Archer now, and he was better last year. People were lined up to drive him to the airport. It was excessive.

Sean Gentille: And the ad hoc justification of the trade by loyalists was almost as bad. Musgrove is fine. Everything else? Eh.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: People soured on Cole long before word bubbled up that he was unhappy. Fans thought he was a hothead, lost his cool in big moments, gave up too many dingers and wasn't living up to his potential.

Sean Gentille: And now it feels like half of those same people are ready to sell the farm to, again, get a guy whose ceiling is "almost as good as Gerrit Cole." It's bizarre.

Sean Gentille: Fans were not rational about Gerrit Cole. At all.

Mike: Indians need a centerfielder if we gave them meadows do they have a controllable starter that would interest NH?

Mark C.: When are fans ever rational?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Indians have starting pitching, but not enough to give one of them (Shane Bieber?) away, I don't think. And I'm not sure they'd want to ride into the playoffs trusting a rookie with scattered experience in center field.

Sean Gentille: I mean, some are. I shouldn't generalize that much. But there a large, vocal group that seemed to hate Cole's guts, and I always found it strange. Anywho.

MDB: Do you think Jung Ho has any value right now?

Sean Gentille: No.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I actually laughed out loud.

Sean Gentille: He did, it was loud as hell.

Sean Gentille: Most restraint I've showed in my career, maybe.

bababooey: If the pirates trade for Gorkys they will once again lead the league in "guys named Gorkys"

bababooey: Will this be another "we offered what we thought was fair" type situation like with Price? Because I am really tired of getting my hopes up.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: But isn't it more fun this way?

Beaver: Any Dozier talk?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: About 200 comments ago, yeah.

Sean Gentille: Remember Lastings Milledge?

Creme Brule: Do you think the Pirates should sign Dickerson long-term if he is interested? I understand we have Meadows but Corey is a proven player already and Austin had cooled down a lot. I think having Dickerson on our team for the forseeable future is key to us getting back to the playoffs. You agree Stephen?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It depends on how much it'll cost, but, yeah, there's something enticing about locking up a left fielder for a handful of years. The man hits. But how much of your self-inflicted low payroll do you want to push in that direction?

Dave: and Stammen

Sean Gentille: Someday, the Pirates will actually acquire Craig Stammen.

Sean Gentille: Fun question -- can you ever remember a more random player continually linked to a team in trade rumors WITHOUT actually winding up there?

Bill: Any chance Colin Moran would have any trade value in an Archer/controllable SP trade? I'd be fine going with Freese as the every day 3B then hopefully spell him with Kang if he can get back to playing time.

Sean Gentille: Like, I remember the Penguins getting linked to Dainus Zubrus for years, but he was a better player than Craig Stammen.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Pirates have specifically said David Freese won't be an everyday player — he's past that part of his career, and what he's doing now is working. And Jung Ho Kang is not an option right now. Going two months counting on Kang and Freese day in and day out sounds like a disastrous plan.

DuqDuke: Do you remember for the entire 2000s that the Pirates were always *so close* to trading for Jeff Francis?

Sean Gentille: YES!

Greg : Do you think the Pirates are too focused on Archer right now? Would they make a deal for someone else if it’s getting close to deadline time and they still don’t know who landed Archer

Stephen J. Nesbitt: No, I think we're too focused on Archer right now.

Ethan: Do you think Gausman could be a repeat of Arrieta if traded?

Sean Gentille: Jung Ho Kang is currently on the DL with a .572 OPS in 34 AAA at-bats. Just FYI.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: He's a different sort of pitcher. Probably not smart to expect it to happen with every pitcher who is traded by the O's.

Tom: Is it reasonable to ask for a percentage chance that Pirates land Archer at this point? Or is it really a complete toss-up?

Sean Gentille: I don't think either of us is comfortable or capable of putting an accurate percentage on it.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Developing story: I'm looking to acquire lunch.

DC Yinzer: Ended up getting Ron Francis.

Sean Gentille: It's clear that the teams have talked. It's clear that other teams want him, too. It's clear that the Pirates never make the big move, and that's what this would be.

Sean Gentille: So I dunno, 50/50 seems reasonable. It's lame but it feels right.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Ken Rosenthal: "Sources: #Brewers, #Braves, #Pirates all strongly in mix for Archer, with #Dodgers and others potentially lurking. If bidding is indeed as furious as it sounds, the #Rays have played this exactly right, taking it to the last day, trying to extract maximum value."

Sean Gentille: Is Rosenthal implying that the Brewers are the leader? Because that'd sure be funny!

Chris: Nesbitt save some money for dessert or dinner and call it “meal budget flexibility”

Sean Gentille: I like not eating lunch in anticipation of beers, then calling it "calorie budget flexibility."

Stanimal: Non-trade related question here. When do you think we'll actually see Kela suited up in black and gold? And are Dickerson and Bell both eligible to come back from the DL on Saturday? They won't need minors stints, will they?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Players get a few days to report after trades. He'll probably be here for Friday's opener vs. St. Louis. There's a chance he's here tomorrow. I doubt Dickerson and Bell will need minor league stints unless their injuries drag on longer than expected.

Tom: The more I hear about Rays extracting maximum value the more concerned I get that Pirates bow out of the race and don't end up getting anyone today

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Again, bidding wars aren't the Pirates' cup of tea.

DC Yinzer: No do-overs on Gorkys!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Hater.

Sean Gentille: Neither is winning playoff series.

Sean Gentille: I'M SORRY, I'M TRYING TO REMOVE IT

DC Yinzer: Tribe got Martin from Det. And have Zimmer on the shelf. Bieber isn’t being moved.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Good points. Meadows' only future with the Indians is in Indianapolis.

Guessed: Does anything really matter?

Sean Gentille: No way.

Sean Gentille: To live is to suffer. To survive is to find some meaning in the suffering.

Dave: What about Kirby Yates?

Dave: why not a Stammen/Yates deal? Ross?

Dave: wasting time on Archer as a long shot, should be focused on Padres

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Dave.

Ray: Are the talks with Padres over now that Pirates got Kela?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I have heard nothing about the Padres in recent hours. The Pirates' bullpen is in a pretty good place. They could add one reliever, maybe. Yates and Stammen are options.

Sean Gentille: Stephen just went to get lunch. Word is he's efforting to acquire a bowl of chili.

Chris: Indians center field may be the biggest hole on a supposed World Series contender. Tyler naguin is a joke and Martin really sucks.

Sean Gentille: Hasn't Kipnis been awful, too? Is this just an Indians chat now?

Chris: I think Nightengale already tweeted he had chili but then had to retract it. Then Bowden tweeted that chili will not be served until the offseason

Robert A: what bargain bin player will the pirates announce they got 30 minutes after the deadline? A catcher? Will they trade Vasquez now they got another closer and try to get 3-4 prospects?

Sean Gentille: Have some optimism, Robert. They got the best bullpen piece on the market. It doesn't erase the utter failure of previous years, but it's something.

Sean Gentille: Also, they won't get a catcher.

Stanimal: If Frazier stays (kinda) hot, you think they finally cut ties with SRod when Bell/Dickerson return from DL?

Sean Gentille: You know, you'd think so, but SRod has stuck it out on this roster through a lot more. Honestly, I'd bet on them finding some way to keep him around until rosters expand.

Sean Gentille: Defensive versatility and the endless affection of a manager are valuable skills.

Dave: I say give Harrison his request.

Sean Gentille: Josh Harrison has not had a good season of baseball.

Stephen on the Street: Chili acquired. Will report back to my seat shortly.

Jim : OFF BASEBALL - DO YOU LIKE BEANS IN YOUR CHILI?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The sign said no beans in this chili. But normally, yes.

Sean Gentille: Absolutely, when it's a bowl. If you're talking about on a hot dog or something, keep the beans away.

Sean Gentille: AWAY!

Ray: Thoughts on Cincinatti chili?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Never tried it. Been there a million times.

Sean Gentille: It's butt.

Miami Manvan: The Pirates have been way to inconsistent this year to make any sort of run if they would luck out into the playoffs. I'm hoping they don't sell the farm just because the team got hot for two weeks.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I like a skeptic. I think you can trust, Miami Manvan, that if this front office is going to trade valuable prospects, it's going to be for players who will help make 2018 and 2019 teams better.

Chris: How about chili Davis. Underrated?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Loved him.

Sean Gentille: Chili Davis definitely led the league in "baseball cards printed." Every third card was Chili Davis.

KimJongIll: Is it a sure thing that the Bucs aren't sellers right now? Kela deal helps now and in the future, but 3.5 back of the second wild card and barely over .500 takes a leap of faith to push in chips. Would they move a Dickerson, Nova, or even Marte if someone came knocking to build for the future and punt this year?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: No, they could definitely add a little and sell a little. They almost always do.

Sean Gentille: You can always trade guys in August.

Jeremy: Will the Pirates stick with Hurdle after this season if they drop off the standings these next two months?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The contract extension says yes.

Guest: If you had to trade one ballpark food from PNC for another from another stadium, what do you do?

Sean Gentille: These are the questions I crave.

Sean Gentille: I'm trading PNC burgers for Shake Shack.

Sean Gentille: No close second place.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'd take a Chick fil A.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: From Atlanta.

Operation Shutdown: I hear a rumor that Steven also has include a hotdog to be named later.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Lies. I'd never name a hot dog.

Sean Gentille: I know Citi and Nats Park have Shake Shacks. Either/or.

Sean Gentille: Also, PNC's beer selection has improved drastically in the last 3-4 years.

DC Yinzer: Shake Shack is impossibly overrated.

Sean Gentille: A) it isn't

Sean Gentille: B) The PNC burgers ain't good.

Shake Crap: Shake Shack is overrated. Overpriced and small portions, disappointed in you Steven.

Sean Gentille: Yes ... Steven

shake shaq: why does steven love shake shack so much?

Sean Gentille: I don't know. He won't stop talking about it.

Operation Shutdown: Wait, if there is a stadium with Chic fil A, is it closed on Sunday?

Sean Gentille: Yes. The Falcons' new place has one, and it's literally closed for Sunday games.

Sean Gentille: It's there for other events, UGA games, MNF, whatever. Not kidding.

PhillyJake: Has it been asked how much better Archer's numbers will be not facing the Yankees and the Red Sox on a regular basis?

Sean Gentille: We're literally sitting here talking about stuff like this -- he's gotten better as the game has progressed, this season.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: In all likelihood, they'll be better. He started only once against the Yankees this year and got beat up pretty good. The Orioles have really killed him. Their stadium is made for that.

Sean Gentille: Better OPS third time through than both first and second, I mean.

Sean Gentille: We are doing our Chris Archer homework. Take that as you will.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Yeah. Check this out. Archer's opponent OPS first time through order: .747. Second time thru: .804. Third time thru: .694.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: By pitch count: Pitch 1-25 (.678 OPS), Pitch 26-50 (.919), Pitch 51-75 (.775), Pitch 76-100 (.541).

Jim : Does it really matter what pitcher we get when we can't actually score in the 1 game playoff? It can't be 0-0 forever, can it?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Not with that attitude.

Sean Gentille: Theoretically, yes.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I am here for a 0-0 game.

Sean Gentille: There's been more existentialism here than I'd expected.

Redbeard: Better beard: Adam LaRoche or Colin Moran?

Sean Gentille: I can't believe I'm saying this, but it's Moran, by a good margin.

Sean Gentille: I'm not even sure what to compare him to, at this point. He's cruised past all the hipster analogies.

Jim: Are the Pirates just looking for pitching help? Or do you think they will bring in a big bat to help more with the offense?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Would you take a little bat? That might be more likely.

DC Yinzer: Primantis for a crab cake sandwich at Camden Yards. And a Natty Boh to be named later.

PhillyJake: Shake Shack is good!

Edward: Atlanta has a Waffle House. Should PNC?

Greg : PNC has the crab fries though. Those things are great

Stephen J. Nesbitt: These are all welcomed takes.

dahnie: would matt harvey be an upgrade for this team? a UFA after the season. maybe wouldn't have to give up *much*.

Sean Gentille: Fry hack -- carry Old Bay around.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I wouldn't consider him a sure upgrade.

Sean Gentille: Then all your fries are crab fries.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: ^ life pro tip

Evan: If we can't get Chris Archer, which archer is next on your list? Cartoon Archer? Men in Tights Robin Hood? Catniss Everdean? Kevin Coster Robin Hood?

Sean Gentille: Mallory Archer. She runs the show.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: MiT Robin Hood is my pick.

Sean Gentille: Hawkeye from Avengers, maybe?

PhillyJake: Crab Fries is a phila thing. The line at Cit Bank Park for them can last two innings.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Classic Philly stan.

Sean Gentille: crab jawns

Chris: Seems most of the pundit chatter is on archer. Hardly a mention of Gausman in several hours.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Jerry Crasnick: "Dan Duquette continues to work the trade deadline. The #Orioles are closing in on another deal, source says."

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Warm up that trade machine, Dan.

Sean Gentille: Dan Duquette -- Gausman's Bossman

Greg : PhillyJake is right, they’re also pretty huge in ocean city, New Jersey

Sean Gentille: i was thrilled to see them at PNC but again, those things are just crinkle cut fries with Old Bay on them. I'm not waiting hours.

Miami Manvan: Considering Harrison's struggles this year and the lack of contending teams with the need for a 2B, I feel Brian Dozier could be had at a comfortable price. Even as a rental, that could move Harrison back into a utility role and not have to depend on Sean Rodriguez. A power hitter that plays solid defense could bolster a push towards playoffs.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: You just wonder what Dozier would cost. Despite his struggles this year, he's an attractive add. Big power from the right side.

Sean Gentille: Is "beter" the same as "better?" who knows!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: AJ Cassavell: "Craig Stammen, clearly on edge about the possibility of being dealt, has set up an impromptu putting green and is putting in the clubhouse. He's handled the Deadline rumors as well as you possibly could."

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I only hope all of us are handling this so well.

Sean Gentille: There are definitely better ways to handle it.

old bae: given that it’s 100 percent we’re getting archer, what else do we include to flip him for harper?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Why not keep them both?

Sean Gentille: J.A. Happ

Evan: Ballpark nachos are usually bad. But Houston has a Torchy's Tacos with the best chips and queso money can buy.

Sean Gentille: Torchy's is the rare local spot like that to live up to the rep.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Someone on Twitter suggested flipping Jordy Mercer for Bryce Harper. To me, that's a steal. So do that, ask the Rays politely for Archer, and then call it a day.

Mark C.: So which one of the following quotes to do we get this afternoon: A. "We did all we could", B. "We were willing to go crazy, weren't willing to go insane", or C. "We gave what we felt was our best offer, it wasn't enough to push it over the line"?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: C

Anonymous Scout: I think we see Kevin Gausman heading to Pittsburgh for three minor leaguers. Is this a good get, or does it really depend on the package?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Thing is, minor leaguers aren't created equal. It depends entirely on what their names and their skills are.

Sean Gentille: Every minor leaguer is the same!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Whoa there, Mack.

Paul M. : Prospects are prospects.

DC Yinzer: Sean, I think we can all agree that every minor leaguer is a minor leaguer.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: They're not wrong, Sean.

Sean Gentille: When is a door not a door?

bababooey: how can you run someone out of town who doesn't want to be here?

Sean Gentille: If you think the overall fan valuation of Gerrit Cole was correct, we disagree.

Jim: Is there a chance that McCutchen comes back to Pittsburgh??? Probably zero, but it would be a hell of a story

Stephen J. Nesbitt: This will not happen.

Steelmike58: Who is going to replace Mercer and Harrison next year and will the replacements be an appreciable upgrade?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Ideally, Kevin Newman will replace Mercer. They could pick up Josh Harrison's option or use Adam Frazier, Max Moroff, etc.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Crasnick: "If the #Orioles trade Kevin Gausman by 4 p.m., it will not be to the #Pirates. They're out on him."

Chris: Why would it even make sense to bring cutch back? As a baseball

shake shaq: if steven is wrong about mccutchen, he can't eat shake shack for a year

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I agree to those terms.

Sean Gentille: Mercer is a 0.8 WAR player this season. Harrison is 0.4. Going by that standard, replacing them won't be hard.

Sean Gentille: Now, replacing the 2017 version of Harrison would be tough. But so far, this year, neither has been good.

dean: Please rank in terms of trade value: Mellamo Trevor, Kingham, Kuhl, Brault, and Glasnow. Would any team take one or two of these guys on? What would happen to the IMHO podcast??

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Williams, Kuhl, Kingham, Glasnow, Brault. Teams would take one or two of them, though I'm not sure why the Pirates would trade them.

Sean Gentille: I dunno if Kevin Newman profiles to be, like, a 1.2-win player as a rookie, but he's not gonna be much worse.

Paul M. : Not surprised by being out on Gausman.

Texas Steeler: No gausman....does that increase the urgency for ARcher

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Not really. The Pirates probably knew this a while ago.

Sean Gentille: Maybe it means they're close!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: They're the reason they're out on Gausman, know what I mean? So this isn't surprising news to them.

dean: Because they are all mediocre Stephen. What does having 7 c/c+ starters do for a team other than depth?

Sean Gentille: It gives them fodder for chat questions.

Greg : What are the chances of getting Wheeler?

Sean Gentille: I'm going to bravely state "zero" on that.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: In a year or two they might become B/B+ starters.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Bill Brink walked past and said hi to all of yinz.

Chris: Wheeler isn’t going anywhere.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I agree.

PhillyJake: Glad we're out on Gausman . Didn't see him as an upgrade.

bababooey: what is this team's fixation with max moroff? if we could get a washing machine for him I'd take it.

Sean Gentille: Finding out that he has at least some value elsewhere has been the weirdest part of my week.

PhillyJake: Did Cole ask for a trade?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I have not heard that he requested a trade. Once they decided they wanted to cash in on Cole and McCutchen's value last offseason, that decision was done.

Hunter: What prospects would we trade for archer?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Good ones, Hunter. It's hard to say who.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Jon Heyman: "a trade for zack wheeler seems to be increasingly unlikely. mets not hearing what they want to hear. market limited for joey bats, nonexistent for mesoraco. #mets"

PhillyJake: For Archer: Hayes, Glasnow, Kramer, Clay

Hunter: Omg

Sean Gentille: Pretty cool that I got up from my computer for 30 seconds, then sat down to see that.

Sean Gentille: Thought it was the real trade. Thanks losers!!!

Texas Steeler: Trade Bonds, Parker, Burnett, and Van Slyke, all their prime for Archer

JunJie: Out on Gausman , Jesus

Sean Gentille: It's actually Gausman, Kevin

Gino: I would love to land Archer without giving up either of Keller or Hayes. Don't think Moran is the long term solution at 3rd

Sean Gentille: It is exceedingly hard to see that happening.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Keller isn't either.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think they're going to give up Moran. They like him, and for good reason.

Buck: Chances that Harrison or Dickerson get moved today? or during the waiver period in August?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The winning streak made that unlikely to happen today. Maybe Harrison is traded next month, but Dickerson stays until they decide they're not in the running for the wild card, at least.

dean: Is this really happening for the next 90-120min?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Brother, it's been happening since noon.

Sean Gentille: Personally, I am not at all sure that Colin Moran is good.

Sean Gentille: I lean toward him being not-very-good. But we'll see.

Gary Tokyo: I was told Ron Cook would be here

Sean Gentille: MAYBE HE IS.

Nate: Any chance being out on Gausman portends a deal for Archer?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't like to be a portender, but it could mean something is in the works. The Pirates could have decided a deal was close elsewhere and told the Orioles to move on.

Gibmente: Interesting story here in the Tampa Bay Times about why Archer has slipped back to mediocrity. The upshot: He lost the bite on his slider:

Sean Gentille: I'm generally fascinated by guys who, year after year, underperform their peripherals.

Jeremy: The pirates need to get another bullpen arm and call it a day

Sean Gentille: There are plenty of hockey guys that fit the bill. Sometimes it's just who they are. I dunno if that's the the case with Archer or what, but still.

Gibmente: Here's that link to the Archer story:

Gibmente: https://www.tampabay.com/data/2018/07/31/two-simple-charts-show-why-th...

dahnie: Reese Mcguire currently ranked #21 jays prospect. Slashing 235/323/331 in AAA. Harold Ramirez not even listed among jays top 30. There was some outrage at the time of that trade in terms of throwing those 2 "prospects" in. The trade seems not too terrible now considering that they rid themselves of the liriano contract. I can't think of a better example of the volatility(?) of prospects and how we tend to over value them. I believe Mcguire and Ramirez were ranked 8,9 in the system, at the time. agree/disagree?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Sure.

Sean Gentille: That was a bad trade because it was a contender using assets to dump a salary.

Sean Gentille: McGuire and Ramirez's performance since is irrelevant. The point was, and is, that they could've been used to buy a baseball asset, not dump a financial one.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Dan Connolly: "Orioles are close enough along with another trade that medicals are being reviewed. You know how that goes. Don't know names. I just know it isn't Jones."

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Gausman to the Brewers is my guess.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Andrew McCutchen is in the Giants lineup today. So is Gorkys Hernandez. KNOW WHO ISN'T? Alen Hanson. #hugwatch

Sean Gentille: BRING HIM HOME!

Other DC Yinzer : This chat is mobirdly fascinating

Alex Lehew: Brewers or Braves I bet.

Sean Gentille: The reviews are in!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: This chat has been called a throwback to the old AOL chat rooms. I am not proud.

Morty: On Liriano trade -- Hutchison being such a big miss also contributed to the poor quality of this trade. Pirates claimed it wasn't salary relief but it really was

Sean Gentille: If it were a throwback to AOL chat rooms, I'd already be fired.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Neal Huntington claiming the trade was done to bring aboard a guy who could be a starting pitcher next year ... and then never using that guy as a major league starting pitcher ... was bad.

Sean Gentille: IMHO

Mad Moose: Shocked there are not more people asking for Cutch to come to the Pirates

Sean Gentille: People realize that it's over.

Kevin: Who is untouchable in the Pirates farm system right now?

Chris Hansen: Why don't you have a seat right over there, Sean?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Untouchable probably doesn't exist.

Sean Gentille: I WAS JUST BEIN' STUPID I GUESS

Morty: Poor Cutch -- free agency is NOT going to be kind to him

Stephen J. Nesbitt: How kind will it be to Bryce Harper?

Nemo: The absolutely last thing the Bucs need is another OF. Cutch ain't coming back.

ben: i'm shocked that in a 4-hour chat on the pg sports page that no one has yet suggested signing Jarvis Jones and converting him to 1B because he played there in high school.

Sean Gentille: prettttty goooooood.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: We're a baseball town now.

@grizzlyblair: The name Gausman reminds me of how Harry and Lloyd leave a note in Dumb and Dumber for "Gas Man", and then Mental thinks the note is for him because he has gastrointestinal issues.

I guess this isn't baseball related. Time for me to delete this before accidentally hitting send and

Sean Gentille: "How do they know I have Gaus?"

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Sean is laughing his tail off.

Raymond: Will Cervelli ever be converted to 1B?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: For his own sake, he probably should be. But it will be done with much kicking and screaming.

Dawn: Any update on Archer?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Not recently, Dawn.

Sean Gentille: And also, good luck if you're a contender and trying to play Cervelli's bat at first.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Hey, he's hitting dingers this year.

Sean Gentille: The guy has been a good player, but that is not the offensive profile of a starting 1B.

RioDavo: What percentage would you give that the Pirates make another move before deadline?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: 98%

Sean Gentille: May was so very long ago, Stephen.

Dave: He's a slightly above average catcher with his bat considered. At first base, he's double A.

Dan: How long is Bell supposed to be out?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Not long.

Sean Gentille: Yeah Dave, I said that out loud here to Stephen -- "where is he gonna play first base, Japan?"

ray: Does the pirates mini win streak change the outlook for more than just 2018... are they thinking differently about 19-20? Crazy it could have all been broken up if that did not happen??

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think it changes the forecast much. If anything, it might alter how they feel about Meadows vs. Dickerson.

Marty: Have the Pirates looked in to adding another bullpen arm? I think a lefty is much needed..

DJT: What's the talk on Gio Gonzalez?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: That's the type of move we could hear about riiiiight at 4 p.m.

Sean Gentille: Nats seem open to moving Gio, because he's not that good and won't seem like them giving up on the season. So.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Eduardo Encina: "#Orioles are currently involved in late-deadline discussions to trade Schoop and possibly Gausman, according to source."

Dawn: Any chatter on Dozier? I think we could use some middle infield help

Sean Gentille: We talked about this earlier -- they absolutely could, because Harrison and Mercer are just not producing, but it's hard to imagine that working out. Good luck selling a Harrison/Mercer deal. It'd take flipping them, then bringing in someone else as a rental, and that just seems ... weird.

Patrick: We have plenty of Catching depth. Trading Cervelli could give us probably cause to get ownership to spend more $$.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't agree. The catching depth is Elias Diaz, oft-concussed Francisco Cervelli and then ... Jacob Stallings. And not a whole lot behind him.

Croganolez: How long is Dickerson signed for?

Frederick Warren: I feel strongly they should extend Dickerson

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Through next year.

Sean Gentille: If they need a catcher, they should ask the Jays about Reese McGuire.

Dave: I hate to be a downer about tonight's game, but has anyone looked outside lately?

Sean Gentille: Ha, we're on the North Shore, and it's apocalyptic.

Cat Tahn : Who would be odd man out in rotation if Archer comes thru

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Joel Sherman: "Archer trade remains likely. #Braves #PIrates #Brewers the main contenders. #Rays"

Sean Gentille: Stephen guessed that Kingham would be out, and that makes sense to me.

Patrick: Buccos fan in Was. Gio is not good. Please no.

Other DC Yinzer : Cervelli is hitting better than Rizzo and Berlinger this year, his bat could play at 1B.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: He does not possess their upside.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Jon Morosi: "#Pirates have remained involved in Chris Archer trade talks today, source says. Barely more than one hour before the deadline. @MLB @MLBNetwork"

Croganolez: Rental? Like Harper perhaps??

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Absolutely not him.

dean: Who are the top 6 or 7 untouchables in Pirates org? From major league level and minors? Make it 10 if you have the hutzpah gentille

Sean Gentille: there are not that many.

Gaz: What's john holdzkom up to

Sean Gentille: ...there might be none.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Pitching in New Zealand.

Gibmente: Since we're talking catching depth, I'd have liked to have seen us in on Wilson Ramos of the Rays. He's a gamer...and likely headed to the Phils.

Patrick: The catching market is never expensive and the Pirates have shown that they will invest in FA for that position.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Yep, Ramos to the Phillies. They don't need a Ramos-caliber guy, but someone between Diaz and Stallings would help.

Doog: Shouldn't the Pirates be trading with the Yankees again....seems like it has been a while after being almost bi-yearly. We will take their crumbs.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'm telling you, it's the right day for a Sonny swap.

Dawn: SONNY! SONNY! SONNY!

PhillyJake: Keller should be untouchable. Unless the Angels call offering Trout.

Sean Gentille: Keller is close, I guess.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Trout + Ohtani + prospects

SBR: It's the NORTH SIDE, not North Shore, Sean

Sean Gentille: Buddy, the North Side starts once you make it to Allegheny Ave.

Sean Gentille: Any respecting North Sider isn't treating Tequila Cowboy like it's their neighborhood.

dean: what about meadows in a deal for Archer. we've seen what he's got and basically he's a tad better than Luplow

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I don't think 150 at-bats is really seeing what he's got.

Sean Gentille: You know who deserves credit for the season he's having? Starling Marte.

Griffondo: Considering that it is very dark outside right now, some Sonny would be nice

Sean Gentille: .288/.334/.494

Dave: I have to give the Pirates credit, I never would have guessed I'd be talking baseball on July 31st outside of whose jersey yinzers will complain about buying after they got shipped out of town.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Baseball is a good game, Dave, and more fun when you're winning.

Sean Gentille: Top 30 in fWAR. Playing center again and playing it well. Bounced back from a steroid suspension (which seemed sort of impossible). He's been great.

Sean Gentille: And he kind of gets slept on. Not totally sure why -- maybe the suspension, maybe because a lot of his value comes from defense ... but he's really, really good.

Corey: Chris Archer earns around $8mm for the next three years. If he continues to perform like he has this year, would that be a good deal?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: In this day and age, yes. And expect an NL bump.

Jim: Tell that to Nutting, Stephen

Sean Gentille: Just wanted to include this, because Jim implied that we were censoring Nutting criticism.

Sean Gentille: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/sean-gentille/2018/01/15/andrew-mcc...

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I will let Bob Nutting know that winning baseball is fun.

Dave: Agreed, Marte is the team's best player by far in 2018.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Marc Topkin: "Hearing #Rays trade of Archer is becoming very, very likely, as high as “90 percent.” Only question now is where - #Braves, #Brewers, #Pirates have been most speculated. And there are always the #Dodgers"

ray: if you could upgrade one position, which would it be?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Dodgers are going to swoop in and crush everyone.

Sean Gentille: Either 2B or SS.

Jason : No one should be untouchable. It is a joke how much the Pirates overvalue lots of Pirates prospects. Adam Hyzdu anyone? Just once, they need to go for it, right?

Sean Gentille: In college, my friend told me they were building a Hyzdu statue in Altoona, and I 100 percent believed him.

Dawn: But can Archer swing the bat? #BanTheDH

Stephen J. Nesbitt: He is 2 for 28 in his career ... with a caught stealing! So, at least there's confidence on the bases.

RioDavo: Archer will be like Liriano. His swing and miss stuff will be effective in NL for a few years and his ERA will consistently be in the 3 range.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Pirates will take "effective in NL for a few years" with an ERA in the 3 range. Dear lord, my man, that's a good pitcher!

Sean Gentille: If they're sure he can be that, they should make the trade last year.

Big Will: He is already better than Nova at the plate.

Matt: This calls for lots of speculation, but if they did trade for Archer, would he be the guy that would start in a possible wild card play in game?

Sean Gentille: Whenever Nova is gone, I'll miss him taking ABs from the on-deck circle.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'd think so. But Musgrove, Taillon have big-game genes too.

Patrick: I agree with Sean. SS has been a big hole in this organization since . Jack Wilson, and he only hit well for like 4 months one season.

Sam: If only they had gone all in this deadline and gotten guys like Happ and Soria

Sean Gentille: Did anyone else kind of ... not know that Soria was still around?

Sgt Shultz: They aren't going to do a thing to improve that club

Sean Gentille: Already did!

Dean: People must also consider if they get those kind of stats from Archer they can flip him in a couple of years for more prospects than what they gave up

Chris: I forgot all about him [Soria] till he went to the Brewers

Sean Gentille: That's part of why getting him makes sense. Same goes for Kela. They'll have value if the team stinks and needs rebuilt next year.

Chaz: If the Rays trade Archer and have already moved on from Eovaldi, the only starter I can name on their squad is Blake Snell. Perhaps they are going to pitch their ace once a week and then have 12 relievers to take their "bullpenning" to a new level.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: They rebuild for real over there.

Sam: Buster Olney: "Industry sources say Pirates remain deep in talks with Rays about right-hander Chris Archer."

Sean Gentille: "Phrasing."

Sean Gentille: I feel great about that one.

PhillyJake: To me, Mercer was perfect for a low payroll team. Just good enough to make it, which kept his price down. A position they were able to save money and get steady, if not spectacular performance.

Gibmente: Before you go dissin' my man Jordy, try hitting No. 8 in the NL your whole career. His range is limited, but I still think he's an underrated player.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Joel Sherman: "#Pirates are in front for Archer with 52 minutes to go to deadline. Told that is way #Rays are leaning."

RioDavo: Getting nervous thinking what we are doing to close the deal.

Sean Gentille: No matter how this ends now, it'll be funny.

Dave: Funny? Why?

Sean Gentille: Because people's hopes are up. It's going to be a mess.

bababooey: I am here for more Adam Hyzdu stories on how he we some kind of folk hero in Altoona. Not much going on in those parts I guess?

Sean Gentille: It's one of my favorite things. We were talking about it for a while here. Dude got his number retired, has a bobblehead, etc. The Legend.

Chuck From Uniontown: Lawd help me lawd!!!! Archer, do it!!!!

Sean Gentille: Oh, how I wish this were the real Chuck.

Corey: Did anyone else's heart start racing when they read " #Pirates are in front for Archer with 52 minutes to go to deadline. Told that is way #Rays are leaning."? This is fun.

Sean Gentille: Yeah, I yelled that at Stephen and then he started writing. That felt real.

dane: In a decade, say you have 20 blue chip can't-miss prospects. How many you think pan out? I would say 10-15%

Sean Gentille: See, I think that implies an optimistic view of blue-chip guys. It's less than that.

MDB: Meadows has to be in Archer trade-right?

Sean Gentille: We sincerely don't know that. You'd think, but it depends on the Rays' planned next window. If it's down the line a bit, they should get someone else. Meadows is like 24.

Sean Gentille: Heyman says the Pirates lead on Archer now, also.

Scott Smith: If Pirates get Archer, who does he replace in rotation?

Sean Gentille: Big money on Kingham.

RioDavo: If it is Meadows in Archer trade, hypothetically, thoughts?

Sean Gentille: If it's Meadows sans Keller, I'd sign off. People are overreacting to his start here, I think. Gotta give to get.

Sean Gentille: Heyman -- "sources: pirates are moving closer to a deal for Chris Archer"

Sean Gentille: This is all happening a little too fast for me.

Sean Gentille: Here's what I'll say -- if the Rays want to reload quickly, Meadows and Kingham makes a lot of sense for both sides.

Sean Gentille: Stephen is reporting that the Pirates have a deal in place.

Sean Gentille: He is sitting across from me.

Sean Gentille: Might be Meadows and Glasnow, per Jim Bowden.

Jim: Would Archer be our starter for the one game wild card game?

Sean Gentille: Crawl before you walk, big fella.

Carolina Larry: Chris Archer, a star for the Clayton High Comets outside of Raleigh, would be a great addition to the ball club. Go Chris!

Sean Gentille: NESBITT NESBITT NESBITT

Griffondo: I think i'm going to cry.

BIB: would love to get Hechavarria also.

Sean Gentille: CRAWL BEFORE YOU WALK, BIG FELLA.

Sean Gentille: Gausman to the Braves

Sean Gentille: If they pull this off without including Keller, not sure how anyone isn't at least superficially happy.

@grizzlyblair: Now that the Pirates have a deal in place for Archer, does this mean that they are out on landing Mike Trout? I will hang up and listen. Thanks for taking my call.

Other DC Yinzer : This is the greatest day in Pirates history don’t @ me

Sean Gentille: Alright, we still do not have a firm report that there's a done deal.

Cat Tahn : Imagine alienating a fan base and bringing them all together in one year

Matt S: If Meadows is included, hoping Searage sees something fixable with Archer

Sean Gentille: Archer is already fairly fixed. The signs are there.

RioDavo: You have to give up something but a little uneasy about Meadows. It does fix the 4 OF problem.

Sean Gentille: You either want 1/2 or you don't.

Sean Gentille: If you guys have links that you're seeing, do me a solid and send them.

Sean Gentille: Because it's cats and dogs living together right now.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I'm back. I'm told the Chris Archer deal is in place. Others are reporting the deal is done.

Sean Gentille: Anyways, what else is up?

Sean Gentille: Here is a link to Stephen's story. http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2018/07/31/chris-archer-pir...

Greg : Is the lack of actual chatting right now due to shock?

Sean Gentille: It's due to us working, actually.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Sorry for the silence. Was writing the story.

JamesinNYC: Any idea who the third piece is?

Sean Gentille: Not seeing reports of that just yet.

PhillyJake: What do we know about the third guy? Top 30? Not ranked? Erich Weiss or Eric Woods?

Sean Gentille: We know nothing at this moment.

MDB: If NH extends Dickerson today this will be the best 24hrs of his reign as GM...

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I think he's got plenty on his plate right now.

Dan Miller: CBS Sports and mlb.com reporting deal in place for Archer.

Sean Gentille: Ol' Stevey had that quite a bit ago.

dane: Is deal done?

Sean Gentille: what we know is in the story right now -- http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2018/07/31/chris-archer-pir...

Another Dave: Can NH do an additional deal for Givens or another RP and really drop the mic, especially with Glasnow out of the picture?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I wouldn't be shocked to see another trade in the next 15-20 minutes (they aren't always announced by 4 p.m.). Another bat, another bullpen arm ...

Patrick: Yes the lack of chatting is due to shock. I'm literally trying to 10x fact check this.

Sean Gentille: Part of my brain says "more is always possible," the other part says "have a 7-up and chill out for like 10 seconds."

RioDavo: This opens up a roster spot? Who comes up?

Sean Gentille: Dickerson and Bell are on the DL, so that doesn't settle much.

Blackjack: quick question, we added two pitchers and lost a of and pitcher, as it stands now what do we do about the lack of a fielder?

Sean Gentille: Moroff is in Indy, for a short fix.

Texas Steeler: Is Sean Rodriguez the third piece? Please!!!!!

PhillyJake: Chris Bostick will come up!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Doooooon't think so, Texas.

Patrick: It'll be Moroff. Worst case Stallings and that one guy gets his wish to see Cervelli in an emergency 1B scenario.

Sean Gentille: Maybe Pat Bostick, or Jon Bostic.

Sean Gentille: Third player TBNL, per bob nightengale

Cassidy: Is the Archer deal actual done? Or is it still in the air? Just trying not to get too excited at the moment....

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Pirates have not yet announced it.

Sean Gentille: If it doesn't go down, it'll be the most widely reported move that I've ever seen not happen.

Sean Gentille: It'd beat out Iginla for the all-time deadline okey-doke.

Sean Gentille: Heyman reports it as done.

RioDavo: Pretty big two-game series with Cubs starting tonight. Oh by the way.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Archer was in line to start Thursday. Could be Friday?

Blackjack: what pure rental hitter is a option out there that left

Stephen J. Nesbitt: I was going to say Dozier, but I missed his trade in the madness.

Bob: Wheres Marlon Byrd when we need him?

Sean Gentille: I've got some ideas.

Gift Ngoepe: Any chance the Pirates are sending Jung Ho Kang to Tampa as the 3 piece?

Sean Gentille: Nope!

Wayward: Did the Bucs front office need this trade just as much if not more that the team on the field did? Big public relations coo!

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It sure doesn't hurt.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Brewers got Schoop.

Hope: Tallion, Archer, Musgrave, Keller, Nova next year for a starting rotation? Doesn't seem to bad does it?

Texas Steeler: If Archer flops, the public will still complain. It’s part of the job

Bob: Archer + healthy Dickerson + healthy Bell + sober Jung Ho + mediocre everyone else. Bucs cookin with gas y'all

Stephen J. Nesbitt: The Pirates are taking a chance. That's worth something.

Chris: Nova be gone Williams in rotation

Patrick: Folks we can get the hitter for cheap in August, not a priority.

Patrick: Neal finally gets his moment in the sun / rain at 5:00.

Chris: Finally

Bob: On a semi serious note, I would feel way better giving Archer the ball in the one game playoff (ahead of myself) than any of the other scrubs.

Vinny: When would the official announcement for Archer have to be made?

Sean Gentille: Huntington speaking at 5, so no later than that.

Jake in DC: You know what, I'm actually amazed the Pirats FO made a move. I was stunned that they traded for Kela. Then I realized they gave up a good prospect but not a back breaking one, and Kela has control so it makes sense.

Robert: I dunno. Meadows for Archer? I know they have extra years, but Dickerson's key to all this. Don't screw it up, B.N.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: It's true. This move is good, but it must lead to more. That's how the baseball transaction wheel works.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: We'll see whether that means an extension for Corey Dickerson. He has proven himself worthy this season.

Jake in DC: Trading Meadows and Glasnow though? That is downright Real-Major-League-Team-Like

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Scarily so.

Sean Gentille: Rays manager is talking about trading Archer to the Pirates. Sounds very done.

Eric A. Payne: All day, even with the trade for the relief pitcher from Texas, I was hoping that somehow we could still make the trade for Archer. I am VERY happy now.

Blackjack: Kingham to the pen or minors?

Stephen J. Nesbitt: Probably to the 'pen to take Glasnow's spot.

Sean Gentille: Official via the Pirates' account.

Sean Gentille: Meadows, Glasnow and a PTBL.

Sean Gentille: I think that'll do it for us.

Sean Gentille: Nez has to go write an A1 story.

Sean Gentille: Thank you guys for hanging out this long. It was a ton of fun with the most interesting outcome possible. That's all you can ask for.

Bob: Great job boys! Buying World Series tix now

Dawn: Thanks guys!!