The Pirates’ middle infield is a paradox for Neal Huntington.
Jordy Mercer ($6.75 million) and Josh Harrison ($10.25 million) are two of the most recognizable and highest-paid members of the clubhouse. Both were parts of winning Pirates teams of the past. Thus, many fans would interpret any deals that would send them and their hefty contracts elsewhere before MLB’s trade deadline as the acts of a “seller.”
At the same time, their performances this season suggest that Huntington, amid renewed hopes of a postseason berth, may be well served by shaking things up at their positions. Regardless of their reputations, their numbers are pretty startling when compared to their peers.
Let’s start with Mercer. He’s missed very little time this season, but through Tuesday, he ranked 14th among qualified MLB shortstops in batting average (.258), 15th in on-base percentage (.319) and 16th in slugging percentage.
Mercer’s defensive metrics are even worse. For example, FanGraphs ranks him 21st in defensive runs saved, at minus-12, ahead of just the New York Mets’ Amed Rosario and the Los Angeles Dodgers’ Manny Machado. There are more complicated metrics that reach the same verdict, dragging his wins above replacement number to a paltry 0.7, which also ranks 21st.
Harrison’s situation is a bit more complicated. He’s missed a fair amount of time with injuries, so it’s probably not fair to pass judgment purely on his 0.3 WAR (27th among second basemen with at least 250 plate appearances).
Read More
That said, his other stats are also underwhelming. Through Tuesday, he was 19th in batting average (.254), 27th in on-base percentage (.295), and 25th in slugging percentage (.355). In the field, he was 17th in defensive runs saved (minus-2) among those who’ve logged at least 500 defensive innings.
None of that is good enough from two of the most expensive players on a playoff hopeful. And yet, both men would probably still have some value on the trade market because of their past performance, which is what makes this trade deadline so tricky for Huntington.
Before a 11-game winning streak that got them back into playoff contention, the plan probably would have been pretty simple.
It’s likely Harrison (with expensive option years looming), Mercer (on an expiring contract) or both would have been shipped out and replaced from within. Second base prospect Kevin Kramer is a prime candidate for promotion with 11 homers and an .843 OPS with Class AAA Indianapolis, and teammate Kevin Newman is probably close to being ready, too. His three homers and .725 OPS aren’t quite as impressive, but that’s good enough for at least a September call-up.
Now that the team is back in contention, such moves would probably be interpreted as a white flag. Given the middle infielders’ performance, though, they may be the Pirates’ best chance to meaningfully improve their team in 2018.
The reality is that the Pirates are pretty short on viable minor-league trade chips. Approaching the deadline as pure buyers and holding onto everyone at the big-league level would only compound that problem, and for what? A 17.9 percent chance to make the playoffs, as judged by FanGraphs?
Trading Mercer and/or Harrison wouldn’t solve that dilemma outright, but if they could be swapped for prospect depth that could then be dealt from to upgrade the bullpen or rotation, it could be a net positive for 2018 — and possibly beyond if Newman and Kramer post even modest numbers.
Of course, there’s always the very legitimate risk that they struggle while being thrown into the heat of a playoff race instead. But the Pirates have already proven they can be mediocre with Harrison, Mercer and their combined 1.0 WAR. It's hard to imagine them being much worse without them.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.