Juan Nicasio’s frequent-flyer status in early September represented the Murphy’s-Law nature of the Pirates’ season.

He went on trade waivers near the end of a great season. The Chicago Cubs claimed him and informed the Pirates they were blocking other teams and weren’t interested in giving up much to get him. The Pirates pulled him back and put him on outright waivers. The first team that could claim him, the Philadelphia Phillies, did, meaning the Pirates gave away their second-best reliever in exchange for nothing but a savings of $600,000.

The Pirates kept him from one division rival, but he ended up with another — after going from Chicago to Pittsburgh to Miami to New York, the Phillies traded him to the St. Louis Cardinals. He joined them in San Diego, then returned with them to Busch Stadium, where he closed two Cardinals victories against the Pirates. Everything that could have gone wrong did.

The Pirates’ season felt like that, too. Jung Ho Kang did not set foot in the country. Starling Marte’s positive test for Nandrolone cost him and the Pirates half a season. Jameson Taillon missed five weeks because of cancer treatment. The two-year, $11 million investment in Daniel Hudson did not produce the return they hoped for. Neither did the decision to put Tyler Glasnow in the rotation. Andrew McCutchen started slowly. Tony Watson struggled. Gregory Polanco got hurt three times. How much time do you have?

Advertise with us

The following grades are based on the 2017 Pirates’ standings in the National League and in Major League Baseball.

Offense: F

The Pirates’ offensive performance followed a common theme: They were better than the San Diego Padres and San Francisco Giants, but nobody else. They ranked 13th out of 15 NL teams in runs per game (4.12), on-base plus slugging percentage (.704) and adjusted OPS, which adjusts for league and ballpark (84, meaning they were 16 percent worse than league average).

A lack of power plagued them. Their 151 home runs ranked 14th, as did their .386 slugging percentage. The only place they didn’t rank in the bottom third in the league was in strikeouts (third) and walks (tied for ninth).

McCutchen hit peaks and valleys on the way but finished with a .363 OBP, 28 homers and a .279 average. Josh Bell showed promise in his first full season with 26 homers, and Josh Harrison was consistent before a broken hand ended his season. Even when healthy, Polanco struggled, with a .251/.305/.391 line.

Advertise with us

Defense: C

The Pirates converted 67.9 percent of balls in play into outs, which tied for 27th in baseball, but advanced metrics had a kinder view of their defense. They saved nine runs above average, according to Baseball Info Solutions, putting them right in the middle of the pack. According to Ultimate Zone Rating, a similar statistic, they were 3.9 runs worse than average, 20th in MLB.

The main culprit was right field. McCutchen moved back to center when Marte was suspended and Polanco was hurt often, exposing John Jaso and Jose Osuna. Pirates right fielders had minus-16 defensive runs saved. Only two teams were worse.

Harrison played steady defense, tying with Marte for the team lead with eight DRS. Bell recorded six and, but for some throwing issues, looked solid in his first full year at first. McCutchen finished at minus-13 but played better defense than that number suggests.

“Our positioning has helped Andrew but Andrew’s also done a great job of working to be better,” general manager Neal Huntington said. “That’s shown up this year.”

Advertise with us
Andrew McCutchen pulls in a fly ball in September against the Orioles. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Starting pitching: C

The rotation compiled a ninth-ranked 4.47 ERA and finished in the middle of the league in most categories: eighth in strikeouts per nine innings, tied for eighth in WHIP, sixth in innings pitched, 10th in batting average allowed, fifth in walks per nine.

The good news was, they got 95 starts from Gerrit Cole, Ivan Nova and Chad Kuhl, and 390 innings from Cole and Nova. The bad news was those pitchers had ERAs of 4.26, 4.14 and 4.35, and Cole and Nova allowed a combined 60 homers.

The way Glasnow dominated after his demotion proved the Pirates right when they said his next stage of development had to happen in the majors; it just didn’t. Kuhl and Trevor Williams, who replaced Glasnow in the rotation, both pitched well in the second half, an encouraging development for next season.

“All of our young starters we can look for them to grow and get better,” Huntington said. “Chad could be a good major-league starting pitcher for years to come.”

Advertise with us

Relief pitching: B-

Star pupil Felipe Rivero made batters look silly all season, and Nicasio was great before the Pirates let him go. The unit had a 3.84 ERA, the sixth-lowest mark in the league. Their walks per nine, home runs per nine and WHIP all ranked seventh.

Watson struggled as the closer before they removed him from the role and eventually dealt him. Hudson could not extend his good stretches, helped by pitching exclusively with a slide step, and walked 4.8 batters per nine. Edgar Santana and Dovydas Neverauskas made their debuts and auditioned — with positive results — for roles in the back end of future bullpens, and the addition of George Kontos on a waiver claim looks to be a good one.

“That’s a pretty good foundation of a bullpen, relying heavily on some young relievers,” Huntington said. “We know there are ups and downs with young players, and we’ll look to continue to supplement that with some of the guys out of the rotation.”

Coaching staff: C-

Advertise with us

The Pirates’ winning percentage tied for 20th out of 30 teams. Except for the month of June, when the Pirates scored 4.96 runs per game, the offense never approached the level needed to compete, and the team finished with a minus-63 run differential. In addition to ranking near the bottom of the league in runs per game, they finished ninth in runs allowed.

Their 65 percent success rate on stolen bases was second to last in baseball (in fairness, Marte missed half the season and Polanco was hurt a lot). They took the extra base a league-average 40 percent of the time. A big improvement was made on outs made at the plate in Joey Cora’s first year as third-base coach (only 15, tied for seventh).

Front office: D

For some fans, an F would be too generous, and the drop in attendance showed their frustration. They had good reason. Marte’s suspension illustrated the lack of a true fourth outfielder. The Pirates did not upgrade the outfield after his suspension. At the trade deadline, they swapped one reliever on an expiring contract for another without helping themselves for this season or next. They did not use the money saved on Kang or Marte until August, when they acquired Sean Rodriguez, and it was too late.

To play devil’s advocate on Nicasio: The team that claimed him on trade waivers was the Cubs, who that very week played the Pirates in a series where a sweep would have moved the Pirates within four games of first. Sending him across the hall at Wrigley Field wouldn’t do. But maybe the play was to keep him — they said they wanted Neverauskas and Santana to get late-inning chances, but perhaps they could have worked something out.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com