Go ahead. Try to find a scenario where the Pirates’ offseason plans don’t center around Andrew McCutchen.

Yeah, the Pirates face other questions as they prepare for the 2018 season after finishing with a losing record for the second year in a row. They need runs, and some power. A couple of contract options require their attention, and the struggle to acquire the paperwork to get their third baseman into the country continues.

But nothing will affect the team’s direction like their decision to retain or trade McCutchen. And as much as the decision is about asset management, it is also about money.

The center fielder dragged the Pirates out of the dark ages with more than just his four years of MVP-caliber production on the field. He is gregarious, personable, suave. He made the Pirates nationally relevant in a way Jack Wilson and Paul Maholm never could. And now he might be gone.

Advertise with us

The final year of the six-year, $51.5 million contract he signed before the 2012 season is a $14.5 million club option with a $1 million buyout. The Pirates must decide the week after the World Series whether or not to exercise the option (they have the same deadline with options on Chris Stewart and Wade LeBlanc). They almost certainly will pick up McCutchen’s option, but that does not preclude them from trading him.

They also almost certainly won’t re-sign McCutchen, who will be 32 when the 2019 season starts, because they won’t want to pay what McCutchen will no doubt receive from some other team for what are typically a player’s decline years. And if they trade him midway through next season, the acquiring team can’t tender him a qualifying offer, precluding it from receiving draft pick compensation if he leaves and thus lowering his trade value.

A trade is no fait accompli. Everything that could have gone wrong this season, from Jung Ho Kang’s DUI-related visa problems to Starling Marte’s steroid suspension to Jameson Taillon’s cancer diagnosis, did. McCutchen started slow again. Tyler Glasnow did not take the next step. Gerrit Cole allowed all the home runs. The 2018 season should be better if only because the team ascends to the mean, luck-wise.

So maybe they keep him. That $14.5 million stays on the books. What does that do to their payroll?

Depending on their decisions with the options on Stewart and LeBlanc, and whether or not the Department of State lets Kang enter the country and collect his $3 million, the Pirates have between $70 million and $75 million committed to between nine and 12 players for 2018 The four players eligible for salary arbitration — Cole, Felipe Rivero, George Kontos and Jordy Mercer — will earn between $12 and $18 million. If the Pirates acquire no one else and pay at or slightly more than the $545,000 league minimum to the remaining players on the active roster, their payroll could be $93 million to $95 million — right where it started this year.

Advertise with us

Opening day payroll vs end of the season payroll With the exception of 2012, the Pirates have added to the payroll during the season every year since 2010. The opening day payroll had also grown every year until 2017, when it droped over $7 million.

Created with Highstock 5.0.14PayrollPayroll (opening day)Payroll (final)20102011201220132014201520162017025M50M75M100M125M

Zack Tanner, Bill Brink/Post-Gazette

In-season payroll change With the exception of 2012, the Pirates have added to the payroll during the season every year since 2010.

Created with Highstock 5.0.14Season ending payroll rank2010201120122013201420152016-5M-2.5M02.5M5M7.5M10M

Advertise with us

Zack Tanner, Bill Brink/Post-Gazette

“It’s early for us to say where our payroll’s going to be, and we also don’t like to say where our payroll’s going to be because it allows people to pigeonhole us in terms of moves that they think we have to make or they think we can’t make,” general manager Neal Huntington said.

The Pirates still receive millions of dollars in revenue sharing. And Disney spent $1.58 billion in August to acquire a majority stake in BAMTech, part of MLB Advanced Media, Major League Baseball’s digital media business. According to the Sports Business Journal, that could mean $50 million for each owner.

Fans this year showed their frustration that owner Bob Nutting does not spend more of that revenue-sharing income, or income in general, on the major league roster, and they showed it at the ticket window. The Pirates finished with a total attendance of 1,916,851 in 80 games at PNC Park (they played one game in Williamsport, Pa.) for an average of 23,961. That ranks 24th in Major League Baseball and is 3,807 less than last year.

MLB payroll ranking Out of the 30 MLB teams, the Pirates ended 2016 23rd in payroll spending. That's up from 24th in 2015 and a low of 29th in 2010 and 2012.

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 5.0.14Season ending payroll rank29/3029/3027/3027/3029/3029/3024/3024/3027/3027/3024/3024/3023/3023/30201020112012201320142015201622/3023/3024/3025/3026/3027/3028/3029/3030/30

Zack Tanner, Bill Brink/Post-Gazette

So we’ve got a payroll approaching this year’s mark before any external additions and a loss of ticket revenue, but also a chicken-and-egg conundrum: Spend on the team and put a good product on the field, hoping the fans will respond, or wait until the fans come out and use that revenue for the on-field product? The question becomes even more pertinent given the consideration that the local television contract with AT&T SportsNet expires after 2019 and a good team will increase negotiating leverage.

“We recognize that when we’ve put a good team on the field, fans have come out,” Huntington said. “We need to put a good team back on the field to entice them to come back out.”

That isn’t as out of reach as their record might make it seem. Cole, Taillon and Ivan Nova should form a solid top of the rotation. Trevor Williams and Chad Kuhl both put together solid, strong second halves that bode well for the unit going forward. The offense could use attention. The 4.1 runs per game the Pirates scored this year ranks 28th out of 30 MLB teams. Their lack of power — the .387 slugging percentage and 151 homers through Thursday both ranked second-to-last in baseball — reduced their margin for error offensively.

Advertise with us

Which brings us back to McCutchen. His presence, if he can play more like he did in June and July rather than April, May and August, boosts the offense. His absence detracts from it. They could try to acquire major league-ready talent in exchange for him, but with only one year of control on his contract and the inconsistency he displayed in the past two years, they might not be able to. Or they could keep McCutchen but decide to trade Josh Harrison, whom teams have shown interest in the past and who makes $10 million next season.

Then they need a second baseman, and a part-time third baseman if Kang is still barred from the country. Sean Rodriguez? Max Moroff? Adam Frazier?

Television analyses and stories about the offseason hot-stove period frequently refer to dominoes: One free agent signs and opens the sluice for the rest. The Pirates have one domino, and their offseason trajectory depends on whether they leave him upright or knock him over.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com.