The Pirates lacked the big hit Monday night, but they allowed one, and they made a big error as well.

The St. Louis Cardinals scored three runs in the ninth inning and beat the Pirates, 3-0, at PNC Park, reducing the Cardinals’ magic number to two. If St. Louis wins one of the next two games against the Pirates, the Cardinals clinch the National League Central Division title and cement the Pirates’ spot in the wild-card game against Jake Arrieta and the Chicago Cubs.

“We couldn’t care less what the number is,” Josh Harrison said. “Season ain’t over ’til it’s over.”

Every opportunity existed for the Pirates to score, to avoid entering the ninth inning in a scoreless tie. But they went 0 for 12 with runners in scoring position and stranded 16.

Advertise with us

“They pitched how they had to pitch and made outs,” Gregory Polanco said.

Matt Carpenter singled with one out in the ninth against Mark Melancon (3-2). Jon Jay rolled a single into right-center field, but Polanco whiffed on the scoop with his glove. Andrew McCutchen raced to pick it up, but he also mishandled it. Carpenter kept on running and broke the scoreless tie.

“Just dropped it,” Polanco said. “I thought I had it. Maybe it snuck a little bit to the right or left, but I thought I had it.”

Mark Reynolds added insurance runs with a two-run homer to right-center field.

The squadron of runners stranded on base did a disservice to the outing from J.A. Happ. His brilliance lasted for six scoreless innings, in which he faced the minimum 18 batters. He allowed one hit, but a nice double play initiated by Harrison’s diving stop erased the baserunner. Happ struck out four and did not walk a batter. His outing reduced his Pirates ERA to 2.04 in 10 starts since they acquired him at the trade deadline.

Advertise with us

“It’s good. Obviously I’m just feeling good out there,” Happ said. “ … I feel like more often than not with this lineup, with this team, good things are going to happen.”

The Cardinals had seen this Happ before, Sept. 4 at Busch Stadium. Happ allowed only three hits in seven scoreless innings and struck out eight without walking a batter.

“He’s definitely found the spots he needs to go to, to navigate his way through the lineup without any major challenges,” Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said.

Four times Monday night the Pirates loaded the bases. Four times they failed to score.

Pirates blog: Unraveling Monday’s Pirates-Cards game

Advertise with us

Jordy Mercer flied to center for the second out of the second inning with the bases loaded. Third-base coach Rick Sofield sent Starling Marte, the team’s fastest runner, with the pitcher coming to bat. But playing center field Monday night was Jason Heyward, who has one of the strongest arms in baseball. His throw crossed the plate on a line and easily retired Marte for the final out.

Marte struck out with the bases loaded in the third and Neil Walker grounded out. Steve Cishek walked three batters in the sixth, but Polanco flied out.

After a McCutchen single in the seventh, Jhonny Peralta bobbled Walker’s two-out grounder to extend the inning. Kevin Siegrist walked Francisco Cervelli, but Pedro Alvarez flied out.

“Resiliency,” Cardinals manager Mike Matheny said. “I don't know if there’s a game that would define it more than this one. We had our backs against the wall every single inning.”

Click the image above to explore our 2015 season tracker and check out how the Pirates have fared so far, game by game. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)