Penguins GM Jim Rutherford has been helping Pittsburgh build a championship contender since before he was officially working for the team.

In 2012, Rutherford was still the Carolina Hurricanes’ general manager when he took Jordan Staal off the Penguins’ hands for, among other players and assets, defenseman Brian Dumoulin. He quickly became an integral part of the Penguins’ plans going forward and went on to win two Stanley Cups with the team. Thanks for that one, Jim!

Since officially coming to Pittsburgh in 2014, Rutherford has made multiple personnel decisions that have directly led to back-to-back Stanley Cup victories and perpetual relevance for a team that had been wasting Sidney Crosby’s prime before he showed up.

That’s not to say that every move Rutherford orchestrated was a success. Trades for guys like Daniel Winnik and Ben Lovejoy didn’t exactly pan out the way he had hoped. It’s also best not to get Penguins fans started on their feelings about Rutherford’s steadfast belief in Jack Johnson’s defensive acumen.

Advertise with us

Despite those hiccups, it’s hard to argue with the results of Rutherford’s work over the past five years. Now that he’s headed to the Hockey Hall of Fame, let’s take a look back at his most shrewd moves during his time in Pittsburgh:

5.) Signing Jake Guentzel

Due to their success, the Penguins have had to mine the draft for underrated talent in lower rounds. The third round in particular has been quite lucrative, as that’s where Matt Murray was selected in 2012 and where Jake Guentzel was taken in 2013.

Though Rutherford didn’t draft Guenztel, he did sign him to a three-year contract after the 2015-16 season. Guentzel has shown a knack for getting the puck into the net, which is a pretty good specialty for a hockey player to have. The stats show that he has gotten better every year and there’s no reason to think that growth will stop.

Guentzel’s the kind of player who as a rookie was so unafraid of the big moment that he scored a huge goal in Game 1 of the 2017 Stanley Cup Final when it looked like the team had fallen into an insurmountable malaise.

Advertise with us

The kid is an offensive stud, and we have Rutherford to thank for ensuring he wears a Penguins jersey.

4.) Acquiring Justin Schultz

It might be hard to remember now, but Rutherford has historically been good at identifying defensive talent on other teams and acquiring them. He went out and got championship-caliber defenders like Trevor Daley, Ian Cole and especially Justin Schultz.

Midway through the 2016 season, Rutherford traded a 2016 third-round pick to the Edmonton Oilers for Schultz’s services. He gave the Penguins the defensive grit the team needed, and he went on to help them win two Stanley Cups.

Like Guentzel, Schultz has a defining playoff moment: the winning goal he scored in Game 4 of the 2017 playoff series against the Washington Capitals.

Advertise with us

Again, we got this man for a third-round pick. Good stuff, Rutherford.

3.) Trading for Patric Hornqvist

Rutherford made a name for himself three weeks after starting his job as Penguins general manager by trading star winger James Neal to the Nashville Predators for Nick Spaling and Patric Hornqvist. It looked wonky at the time, but that was before Hornqvist became such an integral part of the Penguins’ offensive strategy.

The dude is physical, mentally tough and has a nose for the goal. And thanks to Rutherford’s foresight, he now has a winning goal against his old team in a Stanley Cup-deciding game on his resume as well.

There’s nothing quite like an entire hockey stadium yelling “Horny!!” at the top of its lungs. Hornqvist deserves that love, and he wouldn’t be in Pittsburgh if it wasn’t for Rutherford.

Advertise with us

2.) Hiring Mike Sullivan

It takes guts to realize when something isn’t working and do something about it. Rutherford and the Penguins’ front office showed a real commitment to excellence during the 2015-16 season when they opted to fire coach Mike Johnston and replace him with Mike Sullivan.

Just like when ex-coach Dan Bylsma replaced Michel Therrien in 2009 and immediately won a Stanley Cup, Sullivan stepped in and led the Penguins to their first of two championships in a row. Sullivan has proven to be an excellent tactician and has kept the locker room together through thick and thin.

Again, that doesn’t happen without Rutherford being willing to make the hard but ultimately necessary call. It was a ruthless decision, but the right one.

1.) Trading for Phil Kessel

Advertise with us

Rutherford’s most brilliant move came in summer 2015 when he fleeced the Toronto Maple Leafs to get Phil Kessel, a noted weirdo and goal-scorer extraordinaire. It was a risky trade at the time, as Kessel had clearly worn out his welcome in Toronto and no one was 100 percent certain how much high-level hockey he had left in him.

All questions about his ability to produce were answered when it became obvious he was the piece the Penguins had been missing all these years to elevate them from good to great. Like Chris Bosh on the Miami Heat, he was the third and most unsung cog of a Big Three that would go on to start its own mini-dynasty.

It didn’t hurt that Kessel also happened to be a character who immediately endeared himself to the Penguins faithful. His friendship with Evgeni Malkin is still one of the most complicated yet adorable relationships in Pittsburgh sports history.

It can’t be stressed enough that Pittsburgh would probably have two fewer professional sports titles without Rutherford’s championship vision. He knew Kessel was exactly what this team needed, and the entire city should be thankful to Rutherford for constantly taking risks that mostly paid off spectacularly.

Correction, posted June 25, 2019: Jake Guentzel was drafted in 2013. An earlier version of this story had an incorrect year.