Penguins GM Jim Rutherford elected into the Hockey Hall of Fame

Jim Rutherford was in the car, about 10 minutes from home, when his phone buzzed Tuesday afternoon. He wasn’t necessarily expecting this call from a Toronto area code. But when he heard who was on the line, he knew what it was about.

It was Lanny McDonald and John Davidson from the Hockey Hall of Fame.

“And I said, ‘OMG,’” he said. “I knew when it was them calling because I remember a year or two ago I watched on [NHL Network] the different calls to people.”

This year, it was Rutherford who was left speechless on the phone after an 18-member selection committee elected him in the builders category Tuesday.

Advertise with us

“[The phone call] was probably the most humbling experience that I’ve had in my hockey career,” he said at a Tuesday evening press conference. “I really didn’t know what to say and I’m still at the point where I’m really not sure how to put this all in words. But it’s certainly a great honor, an exciting day for me and my family.”

Rutherford, the Penguins’ general manager since 2014, is the only GM in the NHL’s post-expansion era to win a Stanley Cup with multiple teams, having won one in Carolina in 2006 before the Penguins went back-to-back in 2016 and 2017.

After his first Cup in Pittsburgh, he was named the NHL’s GM of the year.

But when he got the news from McDonald and Davidson, the first thing he thought about was not lifting Cups or individual accolades. It wasn’t his playing days or his rise as a manager from the OHL to the NHL. The memory that flashed into his head was the first time, with his mom and dad watching, he laced up a pair of skates.

“You don’t know where it’s going. You start a journey,” the 70-year-old said. “In my case, I started a journey about 60 miles north of where the Hall of Fame’s located.”

Advertise with us

Rutherford was raised in Beeton, Ontario, and gravitated to the crease. After starring for his junior team, the Hamilton Red Wings of the Ontario Hockey Association, he was grabbed by Detroit in the first round of the 1969 draft. The 5-foot-8 goalie played for four NHL teams, including the Penguins, before retiring at 33.

Rutherford immediately pivoted into coaching, working with youth goalies.

“I didn’t know how to do anything else, so stick with the game of hockey and do what I know,” he said. “I loved the game, so I wanted to stay in the game.”

At that time, Rutherford was introduced to Peter Karmanos, the founder of the software company Compuware who also ran hockey teams at various levels. That ultimately led to a job managing the OHL’s Windsor Spitfires in 1984 and, a decade later, being GM of the Hartford Whalers when Karmanos purchased the team.

“He’s the guy that I really have to thank the most for getting me started [and] what I learned from him, the loyalty he showed me,” Rutherford said of Karmanos, who was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame four years ago.

Advertise with us

The Whalers relocated to Raleigh, N.C. in 1997. In addition to putting a team on the ice, Rutherford had to help the franchise carve out a foothold in the non-traditional hockey market. A decade later, his Hurricanes won their only Stanley Cup.

“That was a great experience and I probably would have been happy with my career ending it with that,” Rutherford said of his 20 years with the organization.

After stepping down from the Hurricanes in 2014, Rutherford had “pretty much had made up my mind that I had put enough time in the game and I was going to retire.”

Then Penguins CEO David Morehouse invited him in for an interview.

“When I came and I had that meeting with the owners, it was like, ‘Well, this is a great opportunity. I’m pretty sure I can win a championship here,’” he said.

Advertise with us

It only took a couple of years.

Rutherford acquired Patric Hornqvist, Phil Kessel, Carl Hagelin and Justin Schultz in trades and installed Mike Sullivan as his coach midway through 2015-16. Having Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang helped, too.

The Penguins won the Cup in Rutherford’s second season in Pittsburgh and a year later they became the first franchise in the salary-cap era to go back-to-back.

Rutherford is the seventh general manager since the NHL expanded in 1967 to win at least three Stanley Cups. Now he is a Hall-of-Fame team builder, too.

“We’ve always thought of Jim Rutherford as a Hall of Fame general manager and builder, and today’s announcement that he will formally be inducted into the Hall is richly deserved,” Morehouse said in a statement.

Advertise with us

“He has ties to the Penguins dating back to his playing days in the 1970s, and his impact on the franchise as our GM, in leading us to back-to-back Stanley Cups, has been exceptional. In addition to his Hall of Fame credentials, Jim is a down-to-earth, honest, straight-talking guy who does his job every day with class and dignity."

In addition to Rutherford, former Penguins defenseman Sergei Zubov was elected to the Hall of Fame. Hayley Wickenheiser, Vaclav Nedomansky and Guy Carbonneau are also in the six-person class, along with Boston College coach Jerry York, another builder.

Sergei Gonchar, a member of Pittsburgh’s 2009 championship team and a current Penguins assistant coach, was not among those elected to the Hockey Hall.

This year’s Hockey Hall of Fame induction ceremony will be held on Monday, November 18 in Toronto. The Penguins do not have a game that night.

Rutherford said that Tuesday’s call from Toronto made him reflect more on his life and his career than the three championships that helped him earn it.

Advertise with us

“Everything is happening so fast in that time when you win and so much is going on, you don’t have a lot of time to think about it,” he said. “Today, there’s not as many people around. It hits you in a different way. ... It’s so hard to put in words.”

So, now that Rutherford is a Hall-of-Fame executive, what will he do next?

The general manager, already a Hall-of-Fame character, isn’t slowing down.

“Probably back to my office to see if we can change this team, like I’ve been trying to do for two months,” he said. “I still have that drive to be successful and I still think the Penguins can win at least another championship here in the next few years. I’ll enjoy the moment. I’ll enjoy my weekend in Toronto in November.

“But I still have the drive to win. That’s what I’m going to try and do.”

Advertise with us

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel