Unconscionable, disgraceful, egregiously embarrassing, staggeringly inept, an affront to every blessed thing that is honorable about playoff hockey, but look, enough about the Tampa Bay Lightning.
The Penguins exited the postseason as well Tuesday night, ending a week that was just about every bit as miserable from a technical standpoint, and you could feel it comin’ in the air last night, a four-and-gone conclusion.
Foot traffic on Fifth Avenue 90 minutes before the puck dropped had little of the typical it’s-a-hockey-night-in-Pittsburgh energy, its collective decibels modulated closer to pre-funeral than pre-Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals.
Someone had parked a white Maserati on the sidewalk, and that was as good a metaphor as any for the end of this wretched Penguins postseason – a gleaming, high-priced machine going exactly nowhere.
Some of Pittsburgh’s most expensive components and most decorated performance artists turned up useless at showtime. Sidney Crosby was awful in this series, giving the puck away, missing open nets, making people realize that maybe it’s OK to stop genuflecting to his 200-foot game all of a sudden.
Tell you what, gimme a 20-foot game where the puck goes into the net now and again.
Read More
“I’ve gotta be better,” Crosby said after another no-goal effort that left him minus 4 for the playoffs. “I’ve gotta find a way to produce and contribute and find a way to help us win and I didn’t do that, so it’s disappointing.”
Despite reliably feverish regional anticipation that the Penguins would go deep in the playoffs, they went deep only in the manner of a pedestrian who steps into an open manhole.
They thus were eliminated in historically slapstick fashion, swept from the first round of the playoffs for the first time since 1972, when the powerhouse Chicago Blackhawks dismissed some uppity birds in four straight to the surprise of no one.
But this – this total Islanders implosion – was worse. It was the kind of severe beating (14 goals to six) that left absolutely no one in the mood to point out that the Penguins’ epic string of 13 consecutive playoff seasons is the longest active streak in the National Hockey League, or that since that streak began 2007 no team has more wins than Pittsburgh.
Well isn’t that special?
Instead, the ever-passionate Penguins audience is left to contemplate that a franchise with consecutive Stanley Cups on its curriculum vitae only less than two years ago just got hounded from the playoffs as quickly and decisively as possible. In a first-round series that spanned 244 minutes, 39 seconds of ice time (including that short and sour overtime in Game 1), the Penguins led for all of 4:51, which I believe is less than two percent of the hockey you watched.
The only thing that disappeared faster than a Penguins lead in this series was the Game 4 crowd streaming from the PPG Pizzeria after the Islanders slid home an empty netter with 38 seconds remaining in its hockey season.
You could have gotten 14-1 odds against the prospect of an Islanders sweep when the series started a week ago tonight, but by the end of Game 3, there was little doubt as to which of these Metropolitan Division teams was more playoff ready, more resourceful, more committed to the principles of its success.
The Islanders under Barry Trotz, who bounced these Penguins from last year’s post-season as head coach of the eventual Stanley Cup Champion Washington Capitals, embraced an overhaul that retrofitted them into the league’s most goal-stingy team from the NHL’s most generous only a season before.
“We just played the right way, night in, night out, and obviously we’re happy to get it done,” said New York forward Matt Martin, who with Casey Cizikas and Cal Clutterbuck were the primary block of Trotz’s counterprogramming for the Crosby line. “This is a (Pittsburgh) team that, you know, give them a win and they get some life, and then all of a sudden they’re top guys are feelin’ it again.”
The Islanders developed a defensive personality all the way back in the fall of 2018. The Islanders became prideful of their goal-prevention aptitudes throughout the winter. The Islanders won more games and piled up more points than the Penguins. But there is no way these Islanders, for all their gravitas, could have imagined holding this Pittsburgh Maserati to three goals in the series’ final 180 minutes.
“No,” Martin said. “But we were just focused on each shift. Obviously we got some big saves (from Robin Lehner, who stopped 130 of 136 shots) and some big blocked shots. But we rely on our structure. You saw we had some tired guys tonight, and Crosby’s coming over the boards and Malkin’s coming over the boards – you’re in trouble – but we relied on guys to do the job.
“Crosby and Malkin never really got out of the gates the way they wanted to. Obviously they’re great players and I just know from being out there with them, when you’re on the ice with them you’re thinking about it. They’re dangerous all over the ice. I know statistically (Crosby) didn’t have what people are expecting or are used to, but he had chances. He hit a post tonight. He’s the best player in the game for a reason and he’s not easy to contain.”
Not easy maybe, but this spring, not nearly hard enough.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.