FORWARDS

Grade: C.

Few, if any, people predicted that the New York Islanders would sweep the Penguins, but even fewer would have dared to suggest that the Penguins would manage to score only one goal in each of the final three games of the series. The Penguins generated a total of six in the four games, and only four of those came from forwards – none of whom had more than one goal in the series. That contrasts vividly with New York’s Jordan Eberle, who had a goal in each game. Winger Jake Guentzel, a non-factor through the first three games, staked the Penguins to a 1-0 lead 35 seconds into Game 4 when he took a feed from Sidney Crosby and beat Islanders goalie Robin Lehner from above the left hash. Those proved to be the only points of the series for Crosby and Guentzel, the team’s No. 1 and No. 3 scorers during the regular season. The assist was Crosby’s 186th career playoff point, moving him into 10th place on the NHL’s all-time list. Neither Patric Hornqvist nor Bryan Rust, two wingers with histories of elevating their games when the stakes rise, had a point in the series. Fourth-line winger Garrett Wilson had a chance to prevent what proved to be New York’s series-winning goal, but failed to tie up Brock Nelson’s stick near the lip of the crease before Nelson knocked in a Josh Bailey feed at 18:06 of the opening period.

DEFENSEMEN

Advertise with us

Grade: C+.

The defense was fairly effective at both ends of the ice, but its most accomplished member, Kris Letang, capped a poor playoff performance by being victimized on the first Islanders goal. Letang, who was outstanding during the regular season, had the puck knocked away from him at the right point in the Islanders’ end about a minute and a half after Guentzel scored. That triggered a two-on-one break that culminated in Eberle beating goalie Matt Murray from the inner edge of the left circle to tie the game, 1-1. Letang led the Penguins with four blocked shots and tied for second on the team in shots (4) and hits (3).

GOALIE

Grade: B.

It wasn’t realistic to expect Murray to stop either of the Islanders’ goals, given the circumstances under which they were scored, and his 23-save effort gave the Penguins a chance to force overtime until Josh Bailey scored into an empty net at 19:22 of the third period. As was the case throughout the series, however, Murray was outplayed by his Islanders counterpart. Lehner was excellent from the earliest minutes of Game 1 until the final horn at PPG Paints Arena Tuesday night.

Advertise with us

SPECIAL TEAMS

Grade: C-.

The power play that could have – should have – been a major asset in this series. Instead, special teams sucked the life out of the Penguins on a regular basis, and Game 4 was no exception. The Penguins power play went 0 for 3 and finished the series 1 for 11, which simply cannot be excused or accepted for a group with so much skill. The Penguins’ best chance on a man-advantage came during their second power play, as Crosby hit the left post while throwing the puck toward a mostly open net. They had a final opportunity for a man-advantage goal that would have forged a tie in the third period but failed to capitalize. The penalty kill, which finished the series giving up two goals in 13 shorthanded situations, came up with several quality kills to prevent New York from building a multi-goal lead.

Mike Sullivan talks losing to the Islanders in Game 4.

COACHING

Grade: C.

Advertise with us

The Penguins won their first nine playoff series with Mike Sullivan behind their bench; they now have lost six postseason games in a row. Assuming that he didn’t suddenly forget how to coach, it’s safe to wonder if his players have begun to tune him out, as often happens with even the most successful coaches in the NHL. That would be the most obvious explanation for some of the unforced errors, poor decision-making and inconsistency that plagued the Penguins throughout the regular season and the Islanders series. Sullivan presumably reminded his players that when facing a goaltender as sharp as Lehner, it is imperative to get traffic around the net, to make it difficult to track the puck. But if that message was delivered, it wasn’t absorbed, as evidenced by the fact that the Penguins had a lead for just four minutes, 51 seconds of the 244 minutes, 39 seconds contested during this series.