The Penguins dropped Game 4 of their first-round playoff series against the Islanders by a 3-1 margin Tuesday at PPG Paints Arena, giving New York a series sweep. Here are some initial thoughts on the season-ending defeat.

It was over when: New York’s Josh Bailey scored an empty-net goal with 37 seconds remaining to give his team an insurmountable two-goal lead. Though you’d be forgiven for believing the Penguins were out of this game well before.

Heroes: Jake Guentzel’s first goal of the series gave the Penguins the lead less than a minute into the game.

Better late than never from the team’s leading goal scorer in the regular season. He had a tough series, but with the season on the line, he gave his team a chance to play with a rare lead. Of course, that lead didn’t end up lasting for long, as Jordan Eberle tied the game less than two minutes later. Still, the Penguins’ stars knew they had to play better for the team to have a chance in this series, so give Guentzel credit for stepping up and starting strong.

Advertise with us

Goats: On Eberle’s early equalizer, defenseman Kris Letang aggressively pinched to try to keep the puck in the offensive zone. On cue, disaster followed. The puck instead squirted past him and into the neutral zone, giving the Islanders a two-on-one rush the other way, which Eberle obviously converted into the goal.

It was almost exactly the same mistake that fellow defenseman Justin Schultz made in Game 3, and it’s the second time Letang’s aggression burned him badly in this series. The first, obviously, was his turnover that led to New York’s overtime winner in Game 1. Sensing a theme? The Penguins didn’t learn from their mistakes. They didn’t adapt. They’re continued to play right into the Islanders’ hands to the end, and it’s a particularly bad look for Letang, who’s supposed to be the leader of the defense corps.

He wasn’t the only one who failed to paint himself in glory, though. Markus Petterson got in on the embarrassment by failing to clear and Islanders’ dump-in not once, but twice. It led to Brock Nelson’s go-ahead goal toward the end of the first period.

It punctuated the long list of examples of the Islanders’ forecheck simply dominating the Penguins in their own end.

Power play’s struggles continue: The unit was 0-for-3 Tuesday and finished 1-for-11 in the series. The defensive meltdowns may provide the most vivid memories of this series in the years to come, and rightfully so. An inability to take advantage of the Islanders’ mistakes was as big a factor as any in the Penguins’ ultimate fate, though. New York was never going to be particularly vulnerable in full strengths situations. It’s proven throughout the season that it can lock opponents down, especially when holding a lead. The Penguins had to do something to disrupt that dynamic and just couldn’t.

Advertise with us

Matt Murray good, but not good enough: The Islanders’ first goal was Letang’s fault. The second was mostly on Petterson, though you’d have liked to see Murray flick the pass that crossed his crease out of danger. Ultimately, however, Murray gave his team a reasonable chance to win in every game, even amid all the defensive gaffes. This game was a microcosm of that reality. Could he have been better? Come up with the game-changing saves to help his team steal one and extend the series? Sure. Even had he done that, though, it would have done little to solve the team’s chronic problems in both ends. The Penguins were probably doomed regardless of how Murray played.

Other stars quiet: The captain had a couple of nice chances, one that rang off a post, but the pair still finished with a combined two shots on goal, both Malkin’s. Together, the dynamic duo had just one goal and four points in the series. Winger Phil Kessel, meanwhile, had another invisible game after a strong start to the series. His goal and assist in Game 1 ended up being his only scoring contributions in the series. That’s not going to be enough to win most postseason series, the defensive struggles aside. If this core returns intact next year, it has to be better. It’s that simple.

What they’re saying

Next: Golf

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.