The Penguins have done so much during the Sidney Crosby/Evgeni Malkin Era.
Three Stanley Cups won and plenty of individual accolades achieved.
Made hockey matter again in this region.
A run of 13 consecutive playoff berths, currently the longest in the NHL.
Enduring an utter no-show in the postseason, however, was something the group had managed to avoid, always winning at least one game.
That changed Tuesday, as the New York Islanders swept the Penguins out of the playoffs, winning Game 4 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals at PPG Paints Arena, 3-1, and creating the longest summer the local hockey club has experienced in quite some time.
Read More
“For how well we finished the year and the things we played through to get ourselves into this position, it’s going to be hard to sit on this one for a while,” Crosby said.
“It’s not like we didn’t try or we weren’t hungry,” Malkin added. “They were the better team.”
It was only the fourth time in franchise history the Penguins have been swept, the second in the first round (also against Chicago in 1972). The Penguins failed to win a game in a series two other times — in 1979 and 2013, both courtesy of the Boston Bruins.
This series, against the airtight Islanders, resembled that 2013 Eastern Conference final against Boston, in that the Penguins simply couldn’t buy a goal.
They finished with six in four games, which marks only the second time — 2013 was the other — they scored fewer than seven goals in a best-of-seven series.
The reasons for that were many. The biggest: the Islanders, who transformed themselves into the best defensive team in the NHL this season, a credit to their coach, Barry Trotz.
They hardly ever allow odd-man rushes, and the Penguins were forced to create offense different ways. Obviously, they did not. Even on Tuesday, while facing elimination, the Penguins made too many boneheaded plays with the puck and refused to play a simple game.
“This looked the same [as the 2013 series],” Malkin said. “They played hard in the defensive zone. We tried so hard. This was the best game we played all series. We still scored one goal.”
Mike Sullivan talks losing to the Islanders in Game 4.
Islanders goaltender Robin Lehner was terrific, adding another chapter to his bounce-back year that very likely will net him the Masterton Trophy. The Penguins, meanwhile, never found a shred of offensive cohesion.
After the Penguins thought they attained some balance down the stretch, producing the second-most points of anyone after the trade deadline, that did not translate to the postseason.
Crosby failed to score a goal. Phil Kessel, Malkin and Jake Guentzel had one apiece, which matched the number scored by Garrett Wilson, Erik Gudbranson and Justin Schultz.
“Personally, I’ve got to be better,” Crosby said. “I’ve got to find a way to produce and contribute and find a way to help us win, and I didn’t do that. It’s disappointing. “
Their other top-nine forwards — Bryan Rust, Jared McCann, Patric Hornqvist, Dominik Simon and Nick Bjugstad — combined for just one point, an assist by Simon.
Evgeni Malkin talks about losing to the Islanders in Game 4
In all, the Penguins led for 4 minutes, 51 seconds, barely able to gain a lead and rarely able to build on it or sustain any shred of momentum. As a result, the Penguins have now matched the franchise record for consecutive playoff losses with six.
What will that mean? Surely that’s something to discuss in the weeks ahead.
Expect the Penguins to use this as sort of a transition year, moving some high-dollar players for cap space and trying to get younger, a rebuild on the fly.
Expect general manager Jim Rutherford to listen to offers on Kessel and decide who should go on defense; Olli Maatta makes more than $4 million per season and should be a tradable commodity.
If the Penguins would prefer Erik Gudbranson, a righty with some size and snarl, it’s conceivable they could want to move on from Maatta.
They should also examine what to do with Hornqvist, who finished with three goals in his final 39 games — or since the second concussion he suffered this season, the fifth for him since December 2014.
The Penguins certainly had chances to score in this one, the same as the others. Crosby hit a post. Kessel hit Islanders defenseman Scott Mayfield, then Guentzel pinged one off Lehner’s paddle.
All the Penguins had to show for it was frustration.
“When you score one or no goals, you start to get frustrated,” Malkin said. “You start thinking too much.”
The Penguins took an early lead on Guentzel’s goal, but the Islanders answered just 1:34 later, Jordan Eberle finishing a two-on-one after Kris Letang’s turnover.
Brock Nelson added one late in the first period, as the Islanders again yanked the momentum back from the Penguins.
“Every time we scored, we got some momentum, and we gave it back shortly thereafter,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “It’s such a game of momentum. When you can hang onto it, it certainly helps your team.”
The Penguins will now have more time than they’d ever want to fix their team, and they have plenty of holes to plug.
In a somber dressing room afterward, players were well-aware changes — some of them significant — will certainly be coming.
“The league changes all the time,” Kessel said. “Guys move around. We’ll see what happens.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.