UNIONDALE, N.Y. — History was made Wednesday night, although it probably wasn’t anything anybody was expecting.

After playing all 82 regular-season games, Jack Johnson watched Game 1 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals from the press box as a healthy scratch, the first Penguins player to do that in their history.

“It was a very difficult decision,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said after his team’s 4-3 overtime loss to the Islanders at Nassau Coliseum. “We talked about it for a week. Jack’s played a lot of great hockey for us. I told him he’s going to be a part of it here moving forward. He’s such a great teammate. He took it really well. He’s going to be ready for us. I know he’s going to help us win.”

On a night where the Penguins’ six defensemen didn’t exactly shine, it sort of begs the question: Is this going to be a one-time thing for Johnson, or will he find himself in the lineup for Game 2 on Friday night?

Advertise with us

Sullivan, of course, isn’t one to discuss such matters, even if it’s only a couple hours before a game. But there are some factors here that might point to Johnson having an impact in this series.

For one, injuries.

The Penguins will have to hope that Brian Dumoulin and Erik Gudbranson are OK. Dumoulin left for a stretch in the first period when he was hit hard in the head by Islanders center Brock Nelson.

Dumoulin, if you recall, was concussed during the Penguins’ Stadium Series game on Feb. 23.

In the third period, Erik Gudbranson went into the boards hard, as Islanders captain Anders Lee was penalized for boarding. Penguins teammates helped Gudbranson to the dressing room, although he did return.

Advertise with us

After the game, Gudbranson was unavailable to the media because he was getting treatment and was later seen chatting with the Penguins’ team physician, Dr. Dharmesh Vyas.

Even without any sort of injury concerns, it might make sense for the Penguins to bring Johnson back into the lineup at some point because of what transpired here at Nassau Coliseum.

“We knew they were going to try to come in with a heavy forecheck,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “They’re a team that has a high dump-in rate. We knew they were going to put pucks in deep and try to be physical.”

In general, the Penguins need to do a better job breaking the puck out of their zone, regardless of personnel. But it will be interesting to see if Sullivan turns back to Johnson because of his ability to dish out hits and take them — which could be necessary in this series moving forward.

Mike Sullivan talks about the Penguins' OT loss to Islanders

If this matchup was more predicated on skating, turning back to Johnson after one loss may not be the smart play, but nothing we saw Wednesday indicated it will be. It might be more about getting the puck out of their own zone as quickly as possible while under pressure, and Johnson is actually pretty good at that.

Advertise with us

Then again, one game might come off as reactionary on Sullivan’s part. Or, if another defenseman is hurt, the point could be moot. But regardless, who plays on defense should be a fascinating storyline to track.

Some quick-hit thoughts:

• Mathew Barzal was everywhere on Wednesday, finishing with seven shot attempts and four on goal. His play on Josh Bailey’s overtime goal — waiting and hitting the post — was terrific.

• Sidney Crosby’s line struggled. Scoring chances five-on-five: 1. Scoring chances allowed five-on-five: 13. Went 1-7 when it came to high-danger chances.

• Murray was seemingly annoyed Bailey’s goal was not reversed, but Kris Letang cross-checked Barzal into Murray. Hard to say it was all on Barzal.

Advertise with us

• Hated the non-call on Cal Clutterbuck’s cross-check to Jared McCann. Should’ve absolutely been a penalty. Also hated what Marcus Pettersson did to Casey Cizikas. No need there.

• Did you catch what Islanders defenseman Ryan Pulock did in the second period? Believe it was a Justin Schultz shot. Robin Lehner had no idea where the puck was. Pulock pushed the puck forward so Lehner could cover it. Smart, alert play.

• We might be seeing something here with Evgeni Malkin, Phil Kessel and Patric Hornqvist, who combined for nine of the Penguins’ 14 high-danger chances during five-on-five play. Malkin and Kessel, of course, scored goals. If those three are going, you’d like to think the Crosby line will figure it out.

• Was a little surprised Sullivan went with Garrett Wilson over Teddy Blueger. Wouldn’t be surprised if Sullivan tweaks that for Game 2.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.

Advertise with us