The Penguins dropped Game 1 of their first-round playoff series against the New York Islanders by a 4-3 margin in overtime Wednesday. Here are some initial thoughts on the defeat. 

It was over when: New York’s Josh Bailey converted a two-on-one opportunity on a rush that started with a turnover by defenseman Kris Letang. The result? Sudden death for the Penguins.

Heroes: Phil Kessel came ready to play, which is more than you can say for some of his teammates. His goal at 5:34 of the first period paused an Islanders onslaught that produced two goals in the first two minutes of the game. The first by former Penguin Tom Kuhnhackl was waved off after the Penguins challenged the play as offsides. The second by Jordan Eberle counted and had the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum rocking. Credit Kessel for calmly gathering a pass from Dominik Simonn and depositing it behind goalie Robin Lehner to allow his team to catch its breath.

Speaking of that successful challenge less than a minute into the game, chalk it up as yet another clutch call from the bench and, presumably, video coach Andy Saucier. He’s been instrumental in helping Mike Sullivan’s staff use their challenges effectively to take opponents’ goals off the board, and here he gave the team a chance to bounce back from an early gaffe on the road. Mike Tomlin should take notes.

Advertise with us

Justin Schultz’s goal to tie the game with less than two minutes left in regulation was vintage.

He only played in 29 games this year, but it’s a good sign for the Penguins that he’s starting the playoffs ready to launch rifle shots like that one when the team needs them most.

Goats: Brian Dumoulin’s return from injury could have gone better. Not only was the defenseman forced to the dressing room after taking a hit from Brock Nelson. He was also late in marking the Islanders center on a New York power play late in the frame, allowing Nelson to put his team ahead.

Not a whole lot goalie Matt Murray can do with that one. As color commentator Bob Errey noted on the AT&T SportsNet broadcast, Dumoulin needs to forget about finishing his check there and get back to protect his net. The Islanders aren’t very good on the power play, and the Penguins don’t want to give their unit any momentum. Do give him credit for a clutch poke-check to thwart an Islanders rush in the third period, though.

Olli Maatta was a minus-2 despite getting less ice time than any healthy Penguins defender. Glaringly, his failure to get off the ice on a change and a subsequent turnover led to the Islanders’ third goal.

Advertise with us

Not a great look at all for a guy who, by some accounts, is going to have to perform to stay in the lineup this postseason.

Speaking of bad looks, Letang’s turnover that led to Bailey’s goal in overtime was inexplicable. There were three defenders in the area, but he decided to press the play anyway. The result was an unforgivable two-on-one the other way.

Letang made similar gaffes that cost the Penguins dearly in their playoff loss against Washington last spring. The team better hope this kind of play doesn’t become a trend again.

Power play does its job: If the Penguins are going to win this series, they’re probably going to need their unit to make the defensively stout Islanders pay when they make mistakes. Evgeni Malkin’s second-period equalizer Wednesday was a good example of why. His team was able to generate consistent pressure before and after the goal, more or less dominating play at five-on-five in the frame. It just couldn’t finish against a team that wasn’t leaving many prime openings. The Penguins needed something to show for that good effort, and that will probably be a theme for the power play unit throughout the series.

Murray weathers the storm: The Penguins goalie did not look good on the Islanders’ first goal, leaving his five hole wide open for Eberle to convert.

Advertise with us

Hard to blame him for the Islanders’ subsequent goals, though, be Nick Leddy’s go-ahead tally in the third period on which Murray was screened badly or the two-on-one conversion by Bailey in overtime. He otherwise settled in pretty well and consistently made stops that kept his team in the game. Point the finger at the guys in front of him for that not being enough.

What they’re saying

Next: Game 2 is Friday night on Long Island. Faceoff is 7:30 p.m.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.