Monday afternoon was a nice litmus test for NHL fans. Department of player safety decisions usually are — they give you a sense of who, in the face of years of evidence and against better judgment, is still capable of being angry, surprised or disappointed by the league.
That, of course, is because safety decisions are usually bad, and Monday was no exception. Capitals winger Tom Wilson will not have a hearing for shouldering Brian Dumoulin in the head. Dumoulin, half of the Penguins top defensive pair, left the game and didn’t return. No penalty was called.
No Dept. of Player Safety hearing for Tom Wilson, per NHL. @Capitals @penguins
— Greg Wyshynski (@wyshynski) April 30, 2018
The Tom Wilson check to the head that sent Dumoulin to the room pic.twitter.com/cbRVMLBURo
— Pete Blackburn (@PeteBlackburn) April 29, 2018
And now, no suspension has been given out. If Wilson doesn’t play in Tuesday’s Game 3 — the series is tied 1-1 after the Caps’ 4-1 Game 2 win — it’ll be because he wakes up with a stomach virus, or turns his ankle on a curb, or gets his head stuck in a railing. That’d bring some level of cosmic fairness to the process, but the NHL will have had nothing to do with that.
In one way or another, that’s a shame. It seemed, in a vacuum, that the league had a shot at getting this one right; Wilson is a repeat offender, and Dumoulin was injured on the play. History and outcome are already too big a part of the disciplinary process, but they were both in play. That only matters if you deem the hit illegal in the first place, though, and that was a level the NHL — shocker! — couldn’t drag itself to.
This isn’t to say the league is biased against the Penguins or more interested in giving Wilson the benefit of the doubt than other players. It’s just another example of them doing the wrong thing. We got plenty of those Sunday; Patric Hornqvist’s goal was overturned, and the officials missed as blatant a trip on Devante Smith-Pelly as you could imagine. Neither will have the ripple effect of blowing the Wilson/Dumoulin sequence, but there were mistakes nonetheless, because it’s the NHL.
And as for that hit, Dumoulin moved his head at the last second, part of the logic goes; forget that he pulled up to avoid another hit to the head by Alex Ovechkin. Not a great choice. One attempted headshot and one actual headshot, uh, cancel each other out, or something? It’s tough to track. Next time, Dumoulin should just take the elbow to the dome and say “thanks.” It’s the NHL’s version of the NFL’s catch rule. Nobody knows what’s good and what’s not, and that extends to the top of the food chain. It’s not malevolence. It’s incompetence.
Read More
“I’m at no point trying to target the head at all,” Wilson said after the game. “I’m skating, backchecking, trying to do my job, and unfortunately there’s a collision there. I’ve watched it briefly, and I don’t realize what I can really do any different.
“I’m not going to say that I didn’t get him in the head. It wasn’t a body check to the head. I think I grazed his head as I’m skating by, as he’s getting hit by Ovi.”
Maybe Dumoulin plays Tuesday, maybe he doesn’t. He practiced in a non-contact jersey on Monday morning, which is good news for him and his team; he’s more important to the Penguins than Wilson is to Washington, though Wilson has turned into a good 5-on-5 player, if not a true top-line winger. The odds are quite good that he’s out there, doing his thing again.
Meantime, the rest of us can just wait for the latest “borderline” play in a career that’s already had more than its share. Wilson has an impressive knack for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. If and when bad luck strikes him again, the odds are equally good that we find ourselves having a similar conversation. It’ll be just as unsurprising and obnoxious as this one. Stop expecting the NHL to do the right thing, and you’ll never be disappointed.
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter @seangentille.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.