FORWARDS

Grade: C-

Evgeni Malkin, who missed his third game in a row, was something of a surprise scratch and several other forwards should have taken the day off, too. That includes Dominik Simon who, after failing to capitalize on a couple of quality scoring chances in Game 1, was guilty of a turnover that led to Washington’s third goal. Phil Kessel, who hasn’t looked like himself for several weeks, might have been most visible when he gave away the puck to set up a short-handed, odd-man break by the Capitals. The importance of getting traffic in front of Washington goalie Braden Holtby was shown when Jake Guentzel screened him on Kris Letang’s goal, but the Penguins didn’t interfere with his view of the puck nearly enough. And will any forward who’s not on the top line ever score a goal again?

DEFENSEMEN

Advertise with us

Grade: C

Forget the outcome of Game 2 — if the Penguins are without Brian Dumoulin, who adjourned to the locker room in the second period after absorbing a shoulder to the head from Capitals winger Tom Wilson, for any significant period of time, that easily will be their most significant loss of this series. Jamie Oleksiak played well while filling in for Dumoulin alongside Kris Letang on the No. 1 pairing, logging 20:51 of ice time, easily his playoff high. Letang was an offensive force, recording a game-high five shots while scoring a goal and coming within inches of getting another.

GOALIE

Grade: B-

Matt Murray kept the Penguins in the game in the first period, when they were outshot, 20-10, and is the primary reason they had a chance to steal another victory as it moved along. He might like a do-over on the Alex Ovechkin goal that sailed over his glove to give Washington a 1-0 lead 106 seconds into the game, but finished with 28 saves and hardly was responsible for this defeat.

Advertise with us

SPECIAL TEAMS

Grade: D-

The special-teams tone for the game was set in the first of the Penguins’ three power plays, when they gave up more scoring chances than they generated. They would finish the game 0 for 3, running their streak without a man-advantage goal to four games. The penalty-killers, again operating without injured winger Carl Hagelin, fared only slightly better, giving up one goal in three short-handed situations. They made neutralizing Ovechkin a priority when Washington had the extra man, and executed that task effectively. But they gave up a Jakub Vrana goal with just five seconds left on Washington’s first power play, giving the Capitals a 2-0 lead.

COACHING

Grade: C

Advertise with us

Mike Sullivan had the kind of game that makes coaches rethink their choice of professions. It started when he learned before the game that Malkin would not be available, continued when he lost a coach’s challenge that Brett Connolly had interfered with Murray by shoving his right pad shortly before Vrana scored and was capped when, midway through the third period, an apparent goal by Patric Hornqvist was waved off because neither of the on-ice officials nor those at the league’s war room in Toronto saw the puck cross the goal line.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.