WASHINGTON — There were storylines galore in the Penguins’ 4-1 loss Sunday, but all of them felt secondary to Tom Wilson’s crushing hit on Brian Dumoulin.
It was a hit that could alter the series, given the Penguins’ alarming lack of depth on defense.
It also was a hit that should get Wilson suspended.
Given his predatory history, Wilson does not deserve the benefit of the doubt when he says, “I’m at no point trying to target the head at all.”
And does he not think the rest of us see replays when he claims only to have “grazed” Dumoulin’s head?
But forget about his comments. They don’t matter. Intent doesn’t matter. It shouldn’t, anyway. The NHL’s Department of Player Safety is neither equipped nor commissioned to measure intent.
Read More
Its first duty, in this case, is to answer a simple question: Was the head the principal point of contact?
If the answer is yes — and even Wilson said, “I’m not gonna say I didn’t get him in the head” — then the league must act swiftly and suspend him for a game.
The only caveat is if it determines Dumoulin put himself in such a vulnerable position that Wilson could not avoid clipping him in the skull.
Some observers felt that way, notably Sportsnet commentator and former NHL player Nick Kypreos, who called it “unavoidable contact.”
I’ll buy that contact of some sort was unavoidable. Dumoulin stopped quickly and turned as he braced for an oncoming hit from Alex Ovechkin. But contact to the head seemed avoidable.
Contact through the head — finishing Dumoulin off with the upper left arm— seemed very avoidable. Wilson went upward with his shoulder. Dumoulin dropped to the ice and did not return.
A few Penguins had a strong opinion of the play.
“We know who he is and what he does on the ice,” defenseman Kris Letang said of Wilson.
Sidney Crosby: “He made contact with [Dumoulin’s] head. That was the first point of contact. Given his history and things like that, I’m sure they’ll take a good look at it.”
Wilson somehow avoided a suspension in Round 1 after his head shot on Columbus forward Alex Wennberg. The league reportedly — and pretty unbelievably — said it could not determine if Wennberg’s head was the main point of contact there (somebody should have told them, “You see that thing under Wennberg’s helmet? That’s his head.”)
I asked Mike Sullivan if he had an opinion of Wilson’s hit.
“Yes,” he said.
Did he want to share it?
“No.”
It seems like an obvious call for the league, but then, so did awarding Patric Hornqvist a goal in the third period, and you saw how that turned out.
Meanwhile …
• Leaving D.C. with a split, considering they were without Evgeni Malkin and Carl Hagelin, is a win for the Penguins.
However, injuries are piling up fast. They need forwards not on the top line to find the scoresheet, and that brings us to Phil Kessel and Derick Brassard.
Kessel has just one playoff goal. He has only three shots on goal in this series. Granted, he easily could have had a couple of assists on pretty plays in Game 1, but he doesn’t look nearly as threatening as usual.
Brassard also has just one goal in the postseason. He had one shot and was minus-1 in just 14 minutes of ice time Sunday.
Here’s a possible solution: Put those two back together with Bryan Rust. That trio seemed to have some serious chemistry in its brief time together.
• Why have instant replay if calls aren’t corrected?
Everyone, including league officials in Toronto — shoot, maybe even Al Riveron — had to see the blown-up shot of the puck over the goal line on Hornqvist's shot.
I mean, there was white ice between the puck and the goal line.
Right?
Have I gone mad?
“My view was it was a 100 percent goal,” Sullivan said. “When you blow it up, you can see the white. It’s behind the post. … We respectfully disagree with the league and their ruling.”
• Having said all that, let’s be clear: The Penguins richly deserved this loss.
I hear Sullivan when he says how much he liked the response after his team fell behind 3-0. The problem was that his team fell behind 3-0, and literally assisted on two Washington goals.
Hornqvist can be forgiven for his misplay leading to one. Dominik Simon, on the other hand, hasn’t earned enough goodwill to get off the hook so fast.
Simon missed point-blank chances in Game 1. He was a disaster in Game 2, with no shots, a minus-1 rating and an assist on Brett Connolly’s breakway goal for the Capitals. He isn’t helping. Might be time for a lineup change. (Daniel Sprong, anyone?)
Sullivan spoke between games about correcting the bad start from Game 1. This one was worse. The Penguins played probably their worst period of the playoffs to open Game 2. They were outshot 20-10 and could have been down by four or five goals.
Things didn’t get better early in the second. At one point, Evgeny Kuznetsov was literally skating circles around the Penguins in the offensive zone. Somebody should have handed him a bouquet of flowers and awarded him a "10" after one of his forays.
I’m guessing with a rabid crowd behind them, the Penguins will change the first-period dynamic in Game 3.
They better.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.