It’s not unusual for NHL franchises to be put on the market.
At least eight have had controlling interest change hands since 2010.
Seldom, though, does a team as successful on the ice and solid off it as the Penguins become available.
They have qualified for the Stanley Cup playoffs nine years in a row, the second-longest active streak in the NHL, sold out 377 consecutive regular-season and playoff games at Consol Energy Center, and recorded the highest local TV ratings of any U.S.-based club each of the past six years.
They’ve had some major playoff disappointments since winning the Stanley Cup in 2009, but are far from distressed, financially or otherwise.
“[In general], if you own a team, you want to keep it,” said Ilhan Geckil, Chicago-based director of strategy and evaluation for the Anderson Economic Group. “Especially a successful team, like Pittsburgh.”
Read More
Nonetheless, co-owners Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle announced Wednesday they are considering selling at least a portion of the team.
There appears to be no firm time frame for them to complete — or decide against — a sale.
Although some preliminary inquiries apparently have been made, the identities of the parties expressing interest are not known. More are expected now that word is out that Lemieux and Burkle have retained a financial services firm, Morgan Stanley, to investigate their options.
Despite the joint nature of the owners’ announcement, Lemieux appears to be the more interested of the two in cashing out at least some of his equity. Both, however, have said that they want to remain involved with the franchise, even if they end up owning a smaller piece of it.
The desire of Lemieux and Burkle to continue as part of the ownership group is just one on a long list of factors that mitigates against the franchise relocating if there is a new majority owner.
The most daunting hurdle to a move is the 29½-year lease on Consol Energy Center the Penguins negotiated with the Sports & Exhibition Authority; it took effect in 2010 and has 24½ years remaining.
The Penguins signed a non-relocation agreement in conjunction with their lease, and, while the requirements of any potential buyout are not known, the cost of buying out two dozen years likely would be prohibitive.
What’s more, the NHL Board of Governors has to approve any franchise relocation, and it is not likely to endorse moving a team out of what has become one of the league’s strongest U.S. markets.
Doing so not only would remove a club from a place where it is thriving, but would strike the city in which it lands from the list of potential expansion sites. That would cost the league a hefty expansion fee.
Although the Penguins’ future here is secure, there is much uncertainty surrounding their possible sale. Not only about what portion of the team might end up in new hands, but about what the price will be.
Forbes valued the Penguins at $565 million last fall, but pro franchises frequently go for more than their projected worth.
Geckil said that when a conventional cash-flow model is used to assess the value of a franchise, the result often is far lower than an actual sale price proves to be.
“There are not many sports franchises available,” he said. “Many people want to own a sports franchise, so they need to pay accordingly.
“The demand to have a sports franchise is way above the supply of available sports teams.”
Dave Molinari: dmolinari@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.