This is not 2006 all over again.
The last time the Penguins were put up for sale, there was no new arena, no development rights to 28 acres of prime real estate, no 377-game home sellout streak.
That has all changed. The National Hockey League team now plays in 5-year-old Consol Energy Center, it already has begun redeveloping the 28-acre former Civic Arena site next to it, and it enjoys a fervent fan base and strong TV ratings.
And the strengths that have co-owners Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle “exploring their options” in terms of a possible sale of all or part of the team are the same ones that make it highly unlikely that anyone who buys it would think about moving it, experts said Thursday.
That, and what was described as an “ironclad” lease that binds the team to Pittsburgh until June 30, 2040, and prevents ownership from even talking about relocating it.
“This isn’t selling it to leave. This is selling it to stay,” said Wayne Fontana, board chairman of the Pittsburgh-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority, which owns Consol Energy Center.
Read More
Marc Ganis, president of Chicago-based Sportscorp Ltd., an industry consultant that advised the county on the Heinz Field and PNC Park deals, said Mr. Lemieux and Mr. Burkle apparently are looking to cash in on the success they’ve had in turning around the team.
“They saved the Penguins for Pittsburgh. They developed a new arena for the future of Pittsburgh and they were part of the NHL during some of its darkest times,” he said. “Both of these men have stepped up. It’s hard for anyone to ask for more or to begrudge them the opportunity to gain from years of successful effort and financial investment.”
Given the 30-year lease the Penguins signed in 2007 and the strength of the franchise, “I don’t see relocation as an option here,” he added.
“I think they’re looking for an infusion of cash. I don’t think they’re looking to leave,” noted Steve Greenberg, executive in residence for sports marketing at Duquesne University, who was involved in the PNC Park development.
Mayor Bill Peduto viewed the situation as similar to that involving the Steelers in 2009 when the Rooneys brought in new investors. The changes kept the National Football League franchise under the control of Dan Rooney and his son, Art. He hopes Mr. Lemieux and Mr. Burkle stay as majority owners even if they add other investors.
Mr. Peduto received word from Penguins CEO David Morehouse on Wednesday that Mr. Lemieux and Mr. Burkle had hired the Morgan Stanley financial services firm to “explore their options,” which could include selling all, some or none of their controlling interest in the team.
The mayor told Mr. Morehouse that moving the team “was not an option” under the Consol lease.
But he stressed that he does not believe doing so is even a consideration. “The Penguins are in Pittsburgh and that’s a given,” he said.
Likewise, he doesn’t see a potential sale having a negative impact on the redevelopment of the publicly owned arena site, where the Penguins hold the development rights.
New investors could bring in more capital to help get projects moving, he said. U.S. Steel already has reached a deal with the team to build its new headquarters at the site.
The pace of development could quicken, Mr. Ganis said, as a new owner seeks to recoup his investment in the Penguins. Buyers typically overpay for teams based on future value, he said. In the NHL, it’s hard to make that up on the hockey operations side.
“Whoever buys the team has to look at non-team opportunities to recoup the investment. The real estate investment is one of those opportunities,” he said.
In a statement, Travis Williams, the Penguins’ chief operating officer, said the team “remains committed as ever to developing” the site.
“Nothing has changed based on Wednesday’s announcement. This will be a transformational project for the region, and we are off to a great start with the U.S. Steel world headquarters and the residential development,” he said.
The sale would not affect a deal the team has with Hill District leaders on issues such as affordable housing and minority hiring related to the site. Nor would it affect the overall master plan, which calls for a mix of housing, office and retail development.
Any changes would have to be approved by the city and the Sports & Exhibition Authority, said Mary Conturo, SEA executive director.
In 2006, Canadian businessman Jim Balsillie reached a deal to buy the team for reportedly $175 million but walked away when he was required to keep it in Pittsburgh.
Mr. Lemieux and Mr. Burkle later threatened to move the franchise before the Consol deal was reached.
Mr. Peduto anticipates no such drama this time.
“The biggest change that I hope to see over all of this is a couple new wingers to be able to play next to Sid and Geno,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.