The Penguins were swept out of the playoffs by the Islanders, and Thursday they cleaned out their lockers and met with the media for the last time this season. Jim Rutherford and Mike Sullivan also met with the media to wrap up the season and look ahead to this offseason.

Rutherford has been an excellent general manager for the Penguins. He helped build two teams that won the Stanley Cup, he has been bold and he has been quick to correct his mistakes. He has not held back when it comes to making changes to the roster. He has always tried to give the Penguins a chance to win now, even if it has meant giving up some chips for the future.

It has been a great run for Rutherford, but the bottom line is he hasn’t done a great job the last two years. He has swung and missed on too many trades, added too many players who don’t seem to fit and been responsible for some bad contracts.

Rutherford has absolutely earned the right to get things back on track for the Penguins, but he shouldn’t get a free pass and a lifetime contract. Professional sports are a bottom-line business, and the bottom line hasn’t added up to nearly enough success the last two seasons.

Advertise with us

And if you look at this current roster, there are too many parts that just don’t seem to fit into the system that Mike Sullivan wants to run. There are too many players on the Penguins who are either too slow, too old or both for the Penguins to play the way Sullivan wants them to play.

There are some things that Rutherford can do to fix the Penguins, but if he swings and misses again this offseason, I’m not sure how ownership can allow him to continue to run the show. I’m not saying he should be fired, but there is no question his seat should be heating up at this point.

Rutherford must be bold in taking apart the Penguins roster and bringing in new blood and new energy. I’m not sure that is completely possible because the pieces that would seem to be the most logical to trade either make a lot of money, have bad contracts or have limited or full no-trade clauses.

On Thursday, Rutherford got incredibly defensive about the Penguins’ defense when asked if they are fast enough. This isn’t much different than the approach he has taken in recent weeks, by the way. He didn’t mention Jack Johnson by name but his reaction to the question suggests that is who he was mostly trying to defend.

The bottom line is Johnson hasn’t worked out. He was mediocre most of the season and he is a player that doesn’t fit into Sullivan’s system. He is slow, plodding and isn’t great at moving the puck. And he is signed for four more years.

Advertise with us

There is a reason Rutherford is so defensive of Johnson but I don’t think it is because he thinks Johnson is a great player. It is because he knows that kind of contract for that kind of player is enough for a general manager who doesn’t have the resume of Rutherford to lose his job.

Rutherford is likely stuck with Johnson unless he can find someone to take him for next to nothing. Another contract that suddenly doesn’t look so good is that of Patric Hornqvist, who is locked up through 2022-23. At the time he was given that extension, it was celebrated but he is coming off a disappointing season and he suddenly looks old. Because of his concussions and his style of play, he might be damaged goods.

Phil Kessel and Kris Letang are also two players whose contracts will make them difficult to move. Kessel will likely bring more back than Letang, but both players in some ways represented the problems the Penguins had this year. Kessel had far too many stretches where he didn’t seem engaged or interested, and Letang is talented but mistake-prone, and the latter often mitigates the former.

The Penguins need to find a way to add some speed, but that doesn’t come cheap. And given the contracts they have on the books, they will have to shed some players in order to free up the cap space to sign or trade for players to help in that area.

None of it will be easy, and none of it seems particularly realistic at this point. Rutherford has pulled rabbits out of his hat in the past, and he has been a master at wheeling and dealing to put the Penguins in position to challenge for and win championships.

He has proven he can do it, but in the past two years he has also proven he is capable of making a mess. This offseason, the stakes are too high for Rutherford to get it wrong. And if he does, it should be the end of his remarkable run as general manager.