Jim Rutherford explains why they were swept by the Islanders
After his team erased a two-goal deficit to storm back and beat the Rangers on March 25, taking seven of eight points on a tough road trip, coach Mike Sullivan couldn’t help but gush at the progress the Penguins had made.
Despite being badly bitten by the injury bug, the Penguins ultimately went 10-3-3 in March, tied for their most productive month of the season, and Sullivan started to sense that the Penguins had found themselves.
“I really like the way our team is trending,” Sullivan said that night at Madison Square Garden. “I think we’re playing hard. I think we’re playing together. I think we’re becoming a team.”
It turned out to be nothing more than a mirage.
The Penguins might’ve done some good things during that period of time, but they’re tough to focus on now. The primary topic of locker-cleanout day on Thursday at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex was instead why the Penguins were on top of the world one minute, then on their backs the next.
“You lose 4-0, and you don’t get a win, that hurts,” Nick Bjugstad said. “We’re all bummed, just as much as the fans.”
Read More
What happened between that solid March and the postseason remains an interesting and violent swing of momentum, as swift as the Islanders erasing one of the few Penguins leads in their Eastern Conference quarterfinal series.
All throughout the final full month of the regular season, the Kris Letang-less Penguins cobbled together a defense corps — and hardly allowed anything. In the 13 games Letang missed, the Penguins gave up just 29 goals.
The Penguins also lost Evgeni Malkin for the final seven games of the month and wound up earning at least a point in six of those.
Without Letang and Malkin, the Penguins had guys such as Bjugstad and Jared McCann step up offensively, while Zach Trotman and Erik Gudbranson were huge — literally and figuratively — on defense.
But once Malkin and Letang came back, the Penguins were seemingly never the same.
“We can all speculate on why it’s evolved the way it’s evolved,” Sullivan said of the Penguins actually playing worse after Letang and Malkin came back. “The reality is that you try and understand mindsets of players and mindsets of teams, and human nature is hard to figure out sometimes. That’s one of the biggest challenges of coaching.
“But what I will say is that when key players go down, there’s a certain urgency associated with the rest of the group that everyone has to buckle down because we can’t win unless we do. I think that we’ve got to try and apply that same mindset when we have a full complement of players.”

As players talked about the Islanders and why the series was so frustrating, a couple key themes emerged. For one, you have to give credit to the Islanders, who are sure to be a tough out in the Eastern Conference semifinals.
The Penguins also did themselves no favors by allowing so many odd-man rushes.
“There’s a certain discipline and a certain diligence associated with winning at this time of year,” Sullivan said. “As a group, we all have to take responsibility because we didn’t live up to that.”
The most frustrating thing, Sidney Crosby said, was that the Islanders were exactly who the Penguins thought they would be — a comment that probably would’ve made Denny Green proud.
And it wasn’t as though the Penguins let them off the hook; they actually never got them on there in the first place.
“Give credit to them. Obviously they did a good job. They executed what they wanted to do,” Crosby said. “On the flip side, it’s disappointing that we couldn’t play better and give ourselves a chance.”
That isn’t on the coaching staff, Patric Hornqvist clarified. Sullivan has received his fair share of scrutiny for the Penguins’ inability to punch back against the Islanders, but the way Hornqvist saw things, it’s on the players to produce.
“It’s up to us in here, in this room, to find a way to score goals,” said Hornqvist, who accounted for none of the Penguins’ six in the series. “That’s what it all comes down to. We were not scoring enough goals to win.”
That’s a rarity for these Penguins, who are second only to the Tampa Bay Lightning in goals scored (1,060) since the start of the 2015-16 season.
Many Penguins players also bemoaned how, if one or two things were different, perhaps the whole series would have changed.
Like if they would have scored in overtime in Game 1. Or maybe if they could’ve just denied one of the Islanders’ response goals.
“The outside world says, ‘Oh, they got swept.’ Obviously it wasn’t good enough,” Phil Kessel said. “Winning and losing in hockey, there’s small little things that happen throughout the game. We win the overtime game, the series changes, different things like that. It is what it is.”
The 2018-19 season taught us plenty about the Penguins, including that things have changed since they were winning consecutive Cups.
Sullivan realizes the lack of offense and doesn’t deny that it was an issue but seemed to say it was bigger than that.
In addition to the odd-man rushes allowed and the high-risk game employed, Sullivan discussed his team’s identity, how it has changed and what the Penguins might need to do to get back to being the team they used to be.
“When we’ve had success as a group with the very same core players, we were a team that could score goals,” Sullivan said. “But what I think went unnoticed or not discussed as much was that we were hard to play against.

“We had back pressure on the puck. We had sticks. We defended hard. We limited opportunities at the net. There was all kinds of aspects of our game that made us difficult to play against. … Everyone has to be held accountable and everyone has to take ownership for it.”
Owning up to many reasons the Penguins faltered did not seem to be the problem. Players readily discussed how and where they can be better. The big test, though, will come next season, in more than five months, whenever they meet back in this same spot and try to prove that this whole thing was just a fluke.
“It’s always easy to point fingers and look at reasons why you lost,” Sidney Crosby said. “That’s kind of the nature of what happens when you lose. It’s a pretty fine line. That’s why I’ve learned over the years.
“Even in the series we just played, it’s pretty small, the difference between winning and losing. You have to find a way to overcome that and be on the winning side. I definitely have confidence in the group of guys we have.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.