Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:

Ron Huntsmoore: Is the best approach to fixing the Penguins blowing the whole thing up and starting over?

Zeise: No, I don’t think blowing the roster up and starting over is the right approach. I do think, however, that everything in terms of trades and free agent signings and front office changes needs to be on the table. I am not saying the team has tuned out Mike Sullivan, but I think a few of the stars have. I would say it is time to move on from Phil Kessel, and I think Kris Letang and Evgeni Malkin have to be at least shopped. Malkin has a no-trade clause, but if there is a good deal to be made, maybe he is ready for a change of scenery. Sullivan wants to play a game based on speed, and the Penguins’ defensive pairings are loaded with slow, plodding players. Sullivan didn’t have a good season, but there is no way they should move on from him. He is a good coach, but he needs to find his edge again and ease up on his micromanaging ways. The Penguins have a long offseason and a lot of soul-searching to do as an organization, that’s for sure.

Gary Bailey, Johnstown: Is this the end for the Penguins’ run with Crosby and Malkin?

Advertise with us

Zeise: I don’t think so. I think they may have one more Stanley Cup run in them. The two seem to still be playing at a high level, and that will always put them in the game. And the Penguins organization has been committed to trying to win in the past, so I am not sure why that philosophy would end now.

J.D. Haltigan, @JDHaltigan: How do we evaluate the Chris Archer deal now that Meadows and Glasnow are lighting it up?

Zeise: I think it is way too early to evaluate the deal. Most teams haven’t even played one-tenth of the season yet. Anyone criticizing the deal now is doing so based on hindsight being 20/20. Nobody seemed to complain on the day the trade happened and for good reason; the Pirates front office finally acted like a team that wants to win now. Regardless of what happens, this is the kind of deal the Pirates had been reluctant to make, and they should be applauded for being bold enough to get it done.

Dan Labrolla, Grove City: Why does Keone Kela continue to get chances in the high-leverage spots? He has stunk so far. Is Clint Hurdle trying to lose games?

Zeise: Well, they gave up a lot in terms of prospect capital to get him, and he is supposed to be their second-best reliever. He is traditionally a slow starter, so this isn’t surprising. I think he will be fine. He is too good a pitcher to continue to not get it done. The Pirates need him to break out of this little slump, and the only way that happens is if you keep calling his number.

Advertise with us

Donna Hoffvstal, Moon: What do you think the best Pirates lineup will be once all of the players currently out with an injury return? There are a lot of good parts to this team, but I don’t think they fit well with each other.

Zeise: Kyle Crick is back, so the bullpen is for the most part complete. Lonnie Chisenhall, Corey Dickerson and Gregory Polanco will obviously add something to the equation. Melky Cabrera and even Jason Martin have been pretty good in their absence, so I am not sure how much of a bump the injured players will provide. If you look at Cabrera’s numbers, it is hard to imagine Polanco will improve on them or even match them. The Pirates are off to a good start, but it is a long, long season.

Ron Matthews, Greensburg: Do you think the Steelers will end up giving Mike Tomlin a contract extension before the season, or do you think they'll wait to see how the team does this year?

Zeise: That’s a good question, and my gut says they will do it this summer. I can’t see them allowing Tomlin to get into a situation where he is a lame-duck coach and can become a free agent. I think if they don’t get it done this year, it won’t get done and he will go somewhere else for big, big money after next season.

Greg Taylor, Turtle Creek: The Steelers are going nowhere fast and they should trade Ben Roethlisberger to get a big return and start to reload. This makes the most sense, doesn’t it? Do you agree that the Steelers’ window with Ben is closed?

Advertise with us

Zeise: Are you kidding? Absolutely not. You have a Hall of Fame quarterback to build around, and you have about three more years with that quarterback playing at a high level, so you go for it until he is done. Roethlisberger is coming off a good season. The Steelers should rebuild the roster around him and take a shot at winning a Super Bowl before he retires.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise