The 2019-20 Penguins will look different than the group you saw take the ice this year, the result of their four-game flameout to the New York Islanders in the Eastern Conference quarterfinals.
While the precise direction of those changes is not yet known — it is less than 24 hours after their season ended — those on the roster can be separated into a few categories, ranging from locks to stay, most likely to go and a few question marks.
With that in mind, here’s a look at how the Penguins roster breaks down when analyzing the 2018-19 season and what could lie ahead.
Likely on the move
Phil Kessel — Some things just run their course. Kessel helped the Penguins win the Stanley Cup twice, and he’s one of the most popular athletes in this city. He’ll also turn 32 in October, counts $6.8 million against their salary cap, scored two even-strength goals in his final 32 regular-season games and was a career-worst minus-19. It’s nothing personal, but if the Penguins are looking for a shakeup — they should be after the worst postseason showing of this era — moving Kessel makes sense. With three more years on his contract, it might be time to cut bait a year or two early rather than a year or two late.
Olli Maatta — You won’t find a harder worker or better person. You also won’t find a more replaceable player. Between Erik Gudbranson and even Juuso Riikola, the Penguins now find themselves with a surplus of defensemen. Maatta makes $4.1 million. He’s still only 24 and has won the Cup twice. Surely the Penguins can free up some money here.
Read More
Matt Cullen — The Penguins love Cullen for his leadership and presence. Like Maatta, he’s impossible not to like. But sooner or later, they have to turn things over to the kids. Teddy Blueger is more than ready. Plus, Cullen has dropped some not-so-subtle hints that it’ll likely be retirement for him after the season.
Garrett Wilson — Hard to see the Penguins bringing back their other unrestricted free agent among the forwards, at least to the NHL club. Maybe the Penguins — who should be looking to get younger and faster and feature more skill on their wings — would want Wilson back as Wilkes-Barre/Scranton’s captain. But after playing 50 NHL games this season, Wilson will probably want to see if he can avoid the minors.
Mike Sullivan talks losing to the Islanders in Game 4.
Potentially on the move
Patric Hornqvist — It would’ve been hard to envision Hornqvist being anything other than a lock to stay when he signed his five-year contract extension in February 2018. But at this point, $5.3 million a year for a winger with a history of concussion issues who has suddenly stopped scoring should be scary. A move here would be tough to see given how much the Penguins love Hornqvist’s hard-nosed style — but if someone is interested, it’s doubtful general manager Jim Rutherford hangs up the phone.
Nick Bjugstad — When the Penguins acquired Bjugstad, they envisioned him as a potential top-six winger. Where did that go? Bjugstad got only a handful of chances there and never did much with them. At $4.1 million per season, the Penguins are paying out more than they should for 14 goals and 26 points, especially when you consider that Blueger’s ready, they have Jared McCann, and whomever plays third-line center for the Penguins should have an advantage because Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin are drawing the toughest matchups. To put it another way: It’s not worth overpaying for this spot.
Erik Gudbranson — This comes down to speed. If the Penguins feel like they can address their speed on defense another way, then Gudbranson should stay; he might’ve been their best defenseman in the playoffs, and his physical presence is something the Penguins probably would like to keep. Also, even if they thought about trading Gudbranson, it could be tough. Are other teams scared off by his $4 million cap hit and his pre-Penguins problems?
Question marks
Kris Letang — After one of the best regular seasons of his career, Letang was a disaster in the playoffs, often taking unnecessary risks that blew up in his face. If Letang was hurt, that could explain it. But it also might create deeper problems for the Penguins, especially if he was dealing with a neck-related issue. Letang is 31 and makes $7.25 million. There’s plenty of mileage on the tires, the Penguins were successful with the stripped-down style they employed without their No. 1 defenseman, and a trade could be difficult given Letang’s checkered injury history. At his best, Letang also remains one of the game’s elite players at his position. An interesting question, to be sure.
Jack Johnson — You’d think the Penguins would jump at the opportunity to move that contract — four more years at $3.25 million per season — especially if they’re looking to get faster on the back end. The problem is: Who would want to take it? Johnson was on the ice for the most goals-against (60), scoring chances (608) and high-danger chances allowed (259) among Penguins defensemen during five-on-five play. He wasn’t nearly as bad as some fans might want to believe, but he’s probably not someone other teams are going to covet, either.
Bryan Rust — Might be a pot-sweetener more than anything if the Penguins feel like they can add speed on the wings another, cheaper way. Rust showed he was capable of scoring — 15 goals in a 27-game stretch — while also going long periods of time without scoring (one goal in his first 29, two in his final 20). For $3.5 million per season, you’d probably like a little more consistency. But ultimately, Rust helped the Penguins more than he hurts them.

Staying right here
Sidney Crosby — The Penguins captain was bad against the Islanders, but he’s coming off one of the best two-way seasons of his career, for long stretches lugging this team around like a “Weekend at Bernie’s” sequel. Funnel your fury elsewhere.
Evgeni Malkin — This wouldn’t even be general manager Jim Rutherford’s call to make … not that he’d ever want to be the one who traded Malkin. Yes, Malkin struggled for a large part of this season — 21 goals, 72 points, a minus-25, the worst statistical season of his career. But this wouldn’t be pressing the panic button. It would be smashing it with a sledgehammer.
Jake Guentzel — Coming off a 40-goal season, his $6 million a year extension kicks in next season. Move along …
Matt Murray — Whether the Penguins extend Murray over the summer is worth monitoring, but there’s zero question whether he’ll be their goaltender next season. He might’ve been their best player over the final six weeks of the regular season — he was durable, too — although it didn’t seem to carry over much into the playoffs.
Brian Dumoulin — No question involving his ability. Dumoulin remains one of the NHL’s best defensive defensemen. However, they might need to keep him in bubble wrap. He became a magnet for injuries this season.
Jared McCann — Although McCann failed to score over his final nine games, he’s unquestionably an important building block given his team-friendly contract ($1.25 million through 2020) and how his speed and skill seemed to mesh with the Penguins’ system.
Dominik Simon — Given Simon’s usage, co-owners Ron Burkle and Mario Lemieux might be more likely to go. Seriously, though, he’s under contract for next season. Is there a way to get more than two goals in 42 games out of a guy you use on the top line? Better yet, maybe don’t use the guy with two goals in his final 42 games on the top line.
Zach Aston-Reese — If Dumoulin has extra bubble wrap, maybe ZAR could borrow some. Aston-Reese was fine, but he was hurt a lot. It had to disrupt his development. The focus should be Aston-Reese asserting himself more, the same as it’s been for the past two summers.
Teddy Blueger — With six goals in his first 28 NHL games, you’d think Blueger is ready for regular duty. Then again, the Penguins said he was ready last summer and showed a strange, prolonged aversion to actually using the Latvian-born center.
Marcus Pettersson — Similar to McCann, Rutherford did well to exchange Daniel Sprong for Pettersson, an important part of the Penguins’ on-the-fly rebuild. A restricted free agent, Pettersson should come relatively cheap; he made just $794,167 last season. He’ll absolutely be one of their top-six defensemen.
Justin Schultz — Next year will be no issue, as Schultz is under contract for $5.5 million. And although they could explore a potential trade, it’s hard to see how they get better with that happening. Solid defenseman. Mobile. Can produce offense and quarterback the power play. After that contract expires could provide some intrigue, although that’s not a bridge the Penguins have to cross now.
Casey DeSmith — Backup goalie signed for three more years at $1.25 million. Has a career 2.66 goals-against average and .917 save percentage. Take that every time.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.