The Penguins have zero chance of coming back against the New York Islanders, NBC hockey analyst Keith Jones was saying.

This was Tuesday afternoon, a few hours before the Islanders completed their first-round playoff sweep with a 3-1 win at PPG Paints Arena.

“Letang does not look like himself to me,” Jones said on 93.7 The Fan. “The Penguins aren’t good enough to beat this Islanders team built the way they are without Letang being 100 percent.”

I hope Jones is right.

Advertise with us

I would hate to think a healthy Kris Letang could play this poorly.

There are many reasons the stunned Penguins were embarrassed by a team that doesn’t have anything close to their high-end talent. None of their stars had a good series, not one. Erik Gudbranson and Garrett Wilson finished with as many goals — one — as Evgeni Malkin, Phil Kessel and Jake Guentzel and more than Sidney Crosby, Patric Hornqvist and Letang, who had none. The power play went 1 for 11. The Penguins scored the first goal in each of the final three games and lost all three. The Islanders needed just 2:49, 28 seconds and 1:34 to wipe out each of their 1-0 leads. The Penguins never scored consecutive goals. They led for a total of 4:51 in the four games.

But this was a tough series for Letang, a brutal series, actually. His giveaway in overtime in Game 1 led to the winning goal by the Islanders’ Josh Bailey off a 2-on-1. His turnover Tuesday night led to another 2-on-1 goal, this one by Jordan Eberle, just 1:34 after Guentzel had the Uptown arena rocking with a goal for a 1-0 lead.

Letang’s timing couldn’t have been worse.

It was an awful time to make a critical mistake and get caught a little too deep in the Islanders’ end.

Advertise with us

It was hard to watch because it happened to a terrific player who had a terrific season.

“I tried to put it deep and get in there,” Letang said. “I don’t know what really happened. I was at the blue line and I got whacked … “

Letang didn’t appreciate being told he was a little deeper than the blue line when defenseman Scott Mayfield knocked the puck from him to teammate Mathew Barzal to start the 2-on-1 the other way.

“You want to talk about the first goal? It’s over,” Letang growled.

So was the series soon after.

Advertise with us

Mike Sullivan preached all series to the Penguins about playing smart with the puck. They did anything but against an Islanders team that capitalized on every mistake. It wasn’t just Letang, although he was the prominent offender. Just about all of their defensemen made at least one poor, costly decision. One by the normally steady Justin Schultz in Game 3 comes to mind. He got caught up ice leading to the winning Islanders goal by Brock Nelson.

“It boils down to critical moments and making sure we make the right plays at the right time,” Sullivan said after the Penguins’ earliest exit from the playoffs since 2015, Mike Johnston’s final full season as coach.

“It’s hard to win in the playoffs if you don’t defend and you don’t take care of the puck. We’ve got to be committed to playing a team game. When we do that, I think we’re a whole lot more difficult to play against because we don’t give teams easy opportunities …

“We talked about having patience with our game and taking what the game gives us and making better decisions with the puck so we don’t put ourselves in some difficult circumstances. Unfortunately, we put ourselves in some difficult circumstances.”

Sullivan wasn’t speaking specifically about Letang, but he could have been.

Advertise with us

If Letang was less than completely healthy, he didn’t use that as an excuse. His strong season was interrupted by a neck injury in the outdoor game Feb. 23 in Philadelphia. He missed the next 11 games, returned to play in three, then sat out four more because he said he didn’t feel right. He played in the final two games before the playoffs.

“That didn’t affect me at all,” Letang said, answering with a curt, “Yeah,” when asked if he were healthy.

It doesn’t matter now.

The Penguins are finished much sooner than anyone in the organization thought possible. An offseason of change looms.

It will be a very long offseason.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.