A few years ago, the Penguins were undoubtedly the NHL’s fastest team, the ability to move their skates and the puck quicker than their opponents delivering a decided advantage pretty much every night.

That’s not the case anymore.

In the process of getting swept out of the playoffs by the New York Islanders, the Penguins proved they have plenty of work to do to get back to where they were in 2016 and 2017, when they were the league’s trend-setter.

“I think no,” Evgeni Malkin said after Tuesday’s 3-1 loss in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals at PPG Paints Arena, answering a question on whether he thought the Penguins were fast enough.

Advertise with us

“If we’re fast enough, we win game. They scored two-on-one every game. We need to be faster, for sure. We’re not slow, but if you want to win, you need to be one step forward.”

With a longer summer than anybody around here is accustomed to — players, coaches and management — the Penguins have a ton to tackle. Addressing the team-speed issue one thing, but it’s hardly the only one.

Evgeni Malkin talks about losing to the Islanders in Game 4

General manager Jim Rutherford will have to make a couple of shrewd decisions on his roster, potentially trading away a fan favorite or two in order to skew younger and extend his team’s current championship window.

The morning after arguably the worst playoff performance of the Crosby/Malkin Era, here’s a preview of what the Penguins will face over the summer.

Roster turnover

Advertise with us

It’s bound to happen. The only question is who’s involved.

Malkin, when asked about the potential for change, lobbied to bring mostly the same group back.

“You can’t change the whole team,” Malkin said. “You can’t change 10 players. Of course we change a couple [players]. We have great players here. We’ll see what’s going on this summer.

“We need to understand every year we try to win, you can’t change the whole team. We need to change one or two, maybe more.”

The most likely to go are Phil Kessel and a defenseman — either Olli Maatta or Erik Gudbranson; it’ll be very tough for the Penguins to keep both of those guys, who each make $4 million or more.

Advertise with us

While the Kessel deal won’t be personal, the Penguins will likely want to get younger and cheaper, and the current situation clearly isn’t working.

Before Kessel’s production declines — he’ll be 32 at the start of the 2019-20 season — it could be smart business for the Penguins to try and get something for one of the game’s top snipers.

“I’ve never worried about it,” Kessel said when asked about the potential of getting traded. “Two years in a row it didn’t go the way we wanted it to. We’ll see.”

As for Maatta, the Penguins can likely save — and repurpose — some dollars there, too.

Maatta spent the final three games of the season as a healthy scratch. If the Penguins are intent on getting faster, as they should be, Maatta does not help them much there; his skating is hardly a strong suit.

Advertise with us

Given Maatta's age (24) and experience, having helped the Penguins win the Stanley Cup twice, one would imagine other teams might find that attractive.

Meanwhile, Juuso Riikola plays a similar game and could do it on the cheap, perhaps under $1 million.

Gudbranson could be tricky. He’s a right-handed shot, which the Penguins love. And he’s handled himself well here — far better than anyone expected. It could make sense to keep that third pairing with him and Marcus Pettersson intact.

The bigger question could become whether the Penguins deem this entire defense corps — which struggled against the Islanders — to be good/fast enough.

At times, the Penguins struggled moving the puck out of their own zone, a strong suit a couple of years ago. The problem, though, is what to do.

Advertise with us

Kris Letang is a franchise pillar with a lengthy injury history. Jack Johnson has four more years left on his contract. Moving Brian Dumoulin or Justin Schultz might do more harm than good.

The Hornqvist factor

There’s absolutely no way you can question his effort, but the Penguins will need to find out what exactly happened to Patric Hornqvist and if it’s fixable.

After scoring 15 goals in his first 34 games — better than a 30-goal pace — Hornqvist scored just three in his final 39 (including playoffs). Was it the result of a second concussion he suffered, the fifth for him since December 2014? His production certainly dropped after it happened.

Hornqvist is signed for $5.3 million through 2023, but he was most frequently deployed in a third-line role and had a tough time scoring goals after that second concussion.

Advertise with us

Doing anything with Hornqvist is unlikely given the leadership, the intensity he provides and his concussion history, but they certainly need more out of him than they got over the final couple months of the season.

What about the coach?

Many have wondered whether coach Mike Sullivan’s message has fallen on deaf ears. It has certainly seemed that way at times this season.

But even if it has, it’s highly unlikely any sort of summer shuffling involves the coach. Sullivan remains one of the NHL’s best at his job, and the Penguins are well-aware of that.

While the Penguins might try to play a different way under Sullivan, it’s hard to see this early exit costing the coach his job.

Advertise with us

“Same system, same coaches, same players, too. Just play better,” Malkin said of the approach for next year. “We have long summer. I think everyone — coaches — we think maybe we change system a little bit, maybe we change the power play, too.”

For Sullivan, it was too soon to process any potential changes to his roster and what a first-round flameout might mean moving forward.

“That’s a tough question to answer right now 15 minutes after we just lost,” Sullivan said. “I’ve got to try and assess the whole thing over the next little while.

“What I will say is I have so much respect for the players we have. We have great people. They’re character guys. They’re good players. Our coaching staff has a lot of respect for this group. It’s a privilege to coach this team.

“Having said that, we have high expectations as well. When you don’t meet those expectations, everybody has to take a step back and soul-search and find out what do we learn from it, what are the takeaways, and how do we get better? What those answers are, it’s hard for me to say right now.”

Advertise with us

The contract talk

The biggest contract situation could involve Matt Murray, who will be a restricted free agent after next season.

The Penguins, of course, don’t have to extend him, but if he’s determined to be their franchise goaltender — there are zero signs indicating he’s not — then it’s probably getting very close to that time.

Murray currently makes $3.75 million per season. With two Stanley Cups on his resume, that will obviously increase. But by how much? That’s where things get interesting.

There have obviously been plenty of injuries with Murray and some inconsistency to his performance, but he did find his game late in the year and was arguably the Penguins’ best player over the final six weeks of the regular season.

Advertise with us

That’s also when he showed he could stay healthy and carry a heavy workload, really for the first time in his career.

Where that number falls should be fascinating, although it’s unlikely anything will be contentious for a few reasons: How much Murray wants to be in Pittsburgh, the fact that he’s not an overly material person anyway and the respect Rutherford — a former goalie — has for Murray.

The UFAs

The Penguins don’t have many unrestricted free agents: Matt Cullen, Garrett Wilson, Zach Trotman and Chad Ruhwedel.

It’s entirely possible none of the four will be back.

Advertise with us

Cullen is 42 and has been the NHL’s oldest player. He hasn’t determined his future plans, but he’s said all along that he's approaching this year as if it would be his last.

With Teddy Blueger’s emergence as a potential fourth-line center, Blueger could stand to inherit that role full-time.

Wilson could try and find regular work elsewhere, the same for the defensemen. The Penguins like them, but they have younger guys who do similar stuff. Given their NHL experience, they could have priced themselves out of Pittsburgh, the Penguins again wanting to get younger and faster.

“I still believe the future is bright for the organization,” Cullen said. “There’s some pretty special players here. This particular group, we weren’t able to get it done. It’s tough.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.