Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bob McAdoo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

John Kuczler, @Pappajohn27: Why did the Pirates go all in with this team when they didn't with much better teams?

Starkey: You sound a little like Andrew McCutchen in his interview with USA Today’s Bob Nightengale, Mr. Pappajohn27. And it is true that the Pirates parted with tradition by sacrificing highly regarded young talent in order to acquire quality veterans. I wrote about “Why now?” as did Bill Brink, Stephen J. Nesbitt and perhaps every other sportswriter at the Post-Gazette. The simple answer has three parts:

  • The Pirates got very hot just before the deadline. If that doesn’t happen, nothing else does.
  • The club saw its fan base dwindling to the point of being declared an endangered species and clearly decided it might be time to give the people what they want.
  • The Pirates had the rare opportunity to acquire veteran pitchers— Chris Archer and Keone Kela — who were not only talented but also controllable for multiple years. That made sending young talent the other way palatable.

Having said all of that, it’s simply not true that these were the first big-time moves at a trade deadline under Neal Huntington. McCutchen should know that. He played outfield next to Marlon Byrd, who in 2013 was one of the best power hitters in the National League — his slugging percentage was better than McCutchen’s that year — when the Pirates acquired him in early August. I seem to remember a pretty big home run in the wild-card game that year, too. The Pirates also brought in a highly respected veteran in Justin Morneau.

Advertise with us

Fact is, the Pirates were good enough to win the World Series in 2013. The players didn’t get it done in the series against the Cardinals — and that would include McCutchen, who popped out to second for the last out of a 2-1 loss in Game 4. In eight postseason games with the Pirates, McCutchen had just one extra-base hit and no RBIs (though he did hit .321 with seven singles). Neil Walker (2 for 31) and Starling Marte (4 for 32) also were among those who struggled in the postseason.

It rings a bit hollow, then, when McCutchen tells USA Today of the Archer deal, “It was definitely surprising to see because they’ve never done that before, at least when I was there. Yeah, they made trades when I was there, but nothing like getting an ace starter. You either change with the times, or you get left behind. Maybe they were tired of getting left behind.’’

First of all, is Archer an ace starter? That’s a fair question. He has ace stuff, but nobody has been calling him an ace over the past few years. Secondly, the Pirates actually did acquire a pitcher who performed like an ace down the stretch in 2015. That would be J.A. Happ, who, in his final 10 starts with the Pirates, gave up nine earned runs. Archer will not match that. Few could. Who cares what the Pirates gave up to get Happ? He performed like an ace. Ivan Nova performed at near ace-like levels after the Pirates acquired him in 2016, too, with a 3.06 ERA in the final two months (that would be good for eighth in the league at the moment).

The Pirates were good enough to win the World Series in 2015, too, by the way. They gave the ball to their ace, Gerrit Cole, and he got blown up in the wild-card game. Their hitters did nothing against the Cubs’ Jake Arrieta, who was actually vulnerable that night and would get beaten around in his next two postseason starts.

“We felt we had a good team to compete,’’ McCutchen told USA Today about his three playoff years in Pittsburgh. “But then you see other teams making those moves, getting the key pieces to their team to make them stronger, and you feel like, 'Dang, we’ve got to do something, too.’ It just didn’t happen.’’

Advertise with us

Actually, it did. The Pirates did acquire some very strong pieces to bolster playoff teams. What didn't happen was anything resembling a legit playoff run. And do you know who is most responsible for that?

The players. That's who.

Today’s Twitter Poll segment brought to us by our friend @ChrisMuellerPGH of 93.7 The Fan, which by Tuesday morning had received more than 800 votes: How much longer will the Pirates be playing meaningful baseball this season?

What we learned: That rational people looked at the schedule, saw two more games in Colorado, followed by six more road games (the Pirates are not good on the road), followed by a four-game visit from the Cubs and a three-game visit by the Braves and then a road trip winding through Milwaukee, St. Louis and Atlanta, and thought to themselves, “I’ll be shocked if the season still matters by the first week of September.”

Rapid-fire questions, please …

Advertise with us

Brian Randall M.Ed, @brianrandall1: Who has a job longer, Urban Meyer or SeanRod?

Starkey: I’m going to take Urban Liar and the points here, Mr. @brianrandall1. S-Rod might be gone be the end of Tuesday, if Adeiny Hechavarria joins the club in Colorado, as expected (although, based on recent history, the Pirates could also keep S-Rod and start him at all nine positions tonight). As far as Urban Liar, him fibbing to a reporter won’t be enough to cause his termination. The question is whether he violated his contract. I’m guessing there will not be sufficient proof of that.

DJ, @DJ75986746: If there is a ghost runner on first and I hit a double, do I get an RBI?

Starkey: Absolutely not, Mr. DJ75986746. The runner moves as many bases as the hit is worth.

Christopher Luff, @christopherluff: Archer starts the last game of the regular season to get the Buccos into the WC game. Who starts in the WC?

Advertise with us

Starkey: I see we’ve entered the delusional round, Mr. Luff, but that is OK. I’m going Joe Musgrove. There is a length and a consistency to his starts that I’m really beginning to like. He might get a hit, too, which is more than I can say for most of his teammates lately. Did you know Musgrove is hitting 82 points higher than S-Rod?

Brett Gray, @Cutch_22: If you went on the (NBA-themed) road trip with the Bucs, whose jersey would you have worn?

Starkey: First, Mr. @Cutch_22, let us cite the clear winners from the actual trip to Colorado, during which many members of the club wore NBA jerseys. S-Rod as Magic Johnson (who I’m guessing could have hit better than .163 if he’d chosen baseball) was classic.

Cervelli in a Manu Ginobili jersey was beautiful, and Jameson Taillon in full Hakeem Olajuwon mode was downright legendary. Gregory Polanco as Kevin Garnett wasn’t bad, either — and David Freese was perfect as a referee (although he probably couldn’t lift his arm to call a charge).

Me? I’m going Bob McAdoo’s classic No. 11 Buffalo Braves jersey all day long.

Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).