The Pirates were flying high coming off a 5-1 road trip to Cincinnati and Cleveland last week. The road trip marked the tail end of their 11-game winning streak and they went from a dead team walking to a team that had legitimate aspirations to make the playoffs.
And it all seemed to be falling into place for them as they had a nine-game homestand that included four games against the awful New York Mets and then five games versus the Cardinals and Cubs. It was the perfect storm for them to put some space between themselves and the Cardinals and pull closer to the Cubs.
That didn’t happen as the Pirates came crashing back to reality with a 4-5 homestand. The Pirates split four games with the Mets, then split two games with the Cubs and lost two of three to the Cardinals. They began the homestand ahead of the Cardinals in the standings but now go on the road one game behind them.
I don’t know about you, but it sure feels to me like this homestand, and the series over the weekend against the Cardinals especially, amounted to a missed opportunity for the Pirates. And this is a team that is running out of time and opportunities if it is serious about making the playoffs. This wasn’t the end of the season and there is still time for the Pirates to recover, but a red-hot team is supposed to do better than 4-5 on a homestand.
And now the Pirates face the challenge of going on the road for nine games where a 4-5 record probably should be celebrated.The Pirates are going to Coors Field, which can be a tough place to win, and then play in San Francisco and Minnesota. The Giants are only one game above .500 and the Twins are under .500, but both teams are much better at home than they are on the road.
The Pirates lost some of the momentum they had during their 11-game winning streak and now they need to figure out how to get it back. Sunday’s loss to the Cardinals was especially tough to swallow because the once red-hot offense could only produce five hits and one run.
Read More
This is a team that traded like it has playoff aspirations and those additions at the trade deadline were only supposed to add to the momentum. The reality was much different, though, as the Pirates have lost three of the five games since. That being said, there are some who may judge the Pirates’ trade deadline deals by whether or not they make the playoffs. That is wrong, though, because they they have Chris Archer under team control through the 2021 season and Keone Kela under control through 2020. Those two deals strengthen the pitching staff for at least the next two seasons after this one, so they weren’t deals that necessarily were made to significantly change the outlook of this season.
We also keep hearing about how much the Pirates gave up to make them happen. That concept is extremely overrated. The Pirates gave up Tyler Glasnow, Austin Meadows and a player to be named later for Archer. Glasnow was not panning out here and needed a change of scenery. Meadows has been injury prone and though he was extremely productive his first three weeks in the major leagues, his minor league numbers don’t suggest a can’t-miss superstar. The player to be named later in that deal is still unknown, but I can’t imagine it is going to be anyone significant enough to make the deal feel like the Pirates lost much of anything.
The Kela deal cost the Pirates a strong pitching prospect, Taylor Hearn, but as we have found out far too often the past decade, prospects don’t always - or usually - pan out. In general, a prospect’s best value is in what he can bring back in a trade. Hearn may or may not become a stud pitcher, but the Pirates turned him into a pitcher who has already proven he can get it done in the major leagues.
It may have seemed like the Pirates went “all-in” at the trade deadline to win now, but when you break it down, they really didn’t. They got players who can help them for the next few years and probably didn’t give up nearly as much as it seems to get them.
That’s why, despite the trade deadline deals, this isn’t a “playoffs or bust” kind of season for the Pirates. Still, it would be a nice bonus if this team arrived a year early. That would really show they are on the right path and that they have a core of players who are going to be formidable for years to come.
In order for that to happen, though, the Pirates cannot afford to squander any more opportunities to pick up ground on the teams ahead of them. They need to take advantage of every game — especially at home — because their margin for error is shrinking by the day.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.