There are a number of reasons why the Pirates are hanging on to their playoff hopes by a thread. Their starting pitchers and bullpen have both been too inconsistent. Their best hitters have been inconsistent, too, and the lineup still lacks power options and a true leadoff hitter.
Another factor: The Pirates are not a good defensive team. It is clear, in fact, that it’s their biggest and most glaring weakness. They are a bad defensive team. Period. They aren’t average. They aren’t inconsistent. They are simply bad, and that’s a tough problem for a team with a young pitching staff to overcome. That’s especially true with a staff that doesn’t have a lot of strikeout guys, instead pitching mainly to contact.
The Pirates showed during their 11-game winning streak that their hitters can get hot enough. They have had long stretches of quality starts, and they have also had stretches where their bullpen was almost unhittable. There haven’t been many stretches, though, where the defense has been more than a liability.
That’s why the acquisition of Adeiny Hechavarria could actually be a bigger deal than it appears. The Pirates on Monday traded low-A pitcher Matt Seelinger to Tampa Bay for Hechavarria and cash. On the surface, it looks like a deal where the Pirates are taking a shot in the dark at a player off the scrap heap; the Rays had DFA’d Hechavarria last week.
The truth? It was a smart move by Neal Huntington, one that has very little risk given the cost. Tampa is paying some of Hechavarria’s salary, and he is a free agent at the end of this season.
Hechavarria won’t help solve the Pirates’ lack of power — even after their recent surge, they are still 11th in the NL in home runs — but he is considered one of the top defensive players in baseball. Hechavarria will primarily play second base and shortstop, and he instantly makes the Pirates a better team up the middle.
Read More
“Top three gloves I’ve ever witnessed playing behind,” Pirates left fielder Corey Dickerson said when asked about Hechavarria, who was his teammate in Tampa.
“[Colorado Rockies third baseman] Nolan [Arenado] is definitely the top for me, being behind him and watching him, and then last year and a little bit the year before, watching Hechie in front of me was absolutely unbelievable. He has range, he can jump, he can throw, ball out the glove quick as anybody.”
Jordy Mercer, the player most likely to lose playing time because of Hechavarria’s arrival, added, “He’s one of the best defenders that I’ve seen. I think that speaks for itself. He’s incredibly athletic, really good with the glove.”
Nobody seems certain what the plan is for Hechavarria, but let’s hope he is in the lineup a lot — and is not just a late-innings defensive replacement. It is true he doesn’t hit for big numbers (.258/.289/.332), but he isn’t totally incompetent, either. The Pirates have a few players who can’t hit a lick that still seem to get plenty of starts, so there is no reason Hechavarria shouldn’t get his fair share, too.
The key isn’t how many runs he might drive in, though; it is how many he can save. Bill Brink pointed out that the Pirates’ middle infield has been as poor statistically as they appear. The Pirates are 24th in MLB in percentage of balls in play that are turned into outs. Their shortstops rank 26th in defensive runs saved.
in the last four years, Hechavarria has ranked 5th in both UZR/150 and Defensive Runs Saved out of 21 qualified shortstops. Jordy Mercer has ranked 15th and 19th respectively during the same time.
— Tim Williams (@timwilliamsP2) August 6, 2018
Hechavarria should help those numbers, and in turn help the Pirates become a better defensive club. That is obviously a good goal in and of itself, and it should also help the pitching staff achieve more consistency. That doesn’t mean Hechavarria solves all of their defensive issues, as they are still below average in both corner infield spots, but he should solve some.
The Pirates needed to improve in the field, and they at least took one small step toward achieving that goal. Hechavarria isn’t an All-Star, but he is better defensively than any middle infielder on the roster. That means he needs to play and play often.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.