Five months before the Pirates acquired Chris Archer, Chairman Bob Nutting said the following: “As you talk about the teams that embrace the cycling up and down, and embrace building on the peak, and when they tank, they tank. … We believe that we can have a more steady window of performance.”
On Sunday, two days before the Pirates acquired Chris Archer, general manager Neal Huntington said this: “The challenge becomes, history continues to show us the best way to win a World Series is to get to the postseason as consistently and as frequently as possible, because that’s the key, is getting there. Billy Beane got ripped for saying there’s randomness in October, but history tells us the wild-card team has nearly as good a chance to win the World Series as the [team with the] best record.”
Beane, the Oakland Athletics’ executive vice president of baseball operations, used more colorful language when describing to “Moneyball” author Michael Lewis the shortcomings of using analytics to find inefficiencies in the market.
“My [expletive] doesn’t work in the playoffs,” Beane said. “My job is to get us to the playoffs. What happens after that is [expletive] luck.”
The year-in, year-out approach is akin to playing the percentages in blackjack: methodical, rational, aimed at long-term sustainability. Given the sample size of several 162-game seasons, refraining from gutting the farm system via trade and avoiding the fallow periods that sometimes follow big trades provides a path to continuous contention. A five-game National League Division Series is not as forgiving.
Another challenge is facing teams who did it another way, who sold off assets, reaped the reward of the prospects who came back, lost a lot of games in the process and benefited from the high draft picks — and corresponding bonus pools — that came with all the losing.
Read More
When he traded Tyler Glasnow, Austin Meadows and a player to be named to the Tampa Bay Rays for Archer, Huntington introduced some Danny Ocean into the equation.
“The house always wins,” Ocean tells Rusty in “Ocean’s Eleven.” “You play long enough, you never change the stakes. The house takes you. Unless, when that perfect hand comes along, you bet big, and then you take the house.”
For several years now, Huntington has said some version of the following: “Teams that win the trade deadline rarely win the World Series. Teams that win the offseason rarely win the World Series.”
Neal Huntington on Pirates' trade deadline deals
Since contention became realistic for the Pirates in 2011, they have generally added at the trade deadline in some form. They traded for Derrek Lee and Ryan Ludwick in 2011, and Wandy Rodriguez, Gaby Sanchez and Travis Snider in 2012. The non-waiver deadline came and went without a deal in 2013, but Huntington made August waiver trades for Justin Morneau and Marlon Byrd.
The 2014 deadline, the year the Pirates reportedly made a strong offer for David Price and considered Jon Lester, came and went without a move. (Beane’s A’s acquired Lester, and his quote became prophetic when the A’s lost the wild-card game in the first of many examples of the Kansas City Royals’ come-from-behind devil magic.) The 2015 deadline was the closest the Pirates came to what fans consider going for it: J.A. Happ, Aramis Ramirez, Joakim Soria and Joe Blanton all joined the playoff push.
In 2016 they bought and sold, dumping Francisco Liriano’s salary, turning two months of Mark Melancon into, we now know, Felipe Vazquez and Keone Kela, and adding Ivan Nova, whom they would re-sign. Last year they spun their wheels at the major league level, swapping out relievers on expiring contracts, but they brought back a good-looking young shortstop, Oneil Cruz, in the Tony Watson trade.
So why now? Why bet big this year?
“It ultimately comes back to our belief in this core,” Huntington said.
The acquisitions of Archer and reliever Kela were not rentals. If they choose, they have Archer through 2021, Kela through 2020. Despite the prospect pedigree, Glasnow was a middle reliever without much of a path back to starting. While losing Meadows hurts, Gregory Polanco and Starling Marte are on long-term deals, they have Corey Dickerson through 2019, and the acquisitions of outfield prospects Bryan Reynolds and Jason Martin in the Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole trades provide depth.
“I wouldn’t say ‘departure’ because we want to build an organization that can consistently field a team that can compete for championships,” Pirates President Frank Coonelly said regarding the juxtaposition of this deadline with previous years. “That’s extremely hard to do, but that is what we want to do. Therefore we have been reluctant to, as we say, ‘mortgage the future.’ This is a clear statement that we have an opportunity we can seize and we have to take an aggressive position. And we’ve taken a position that is probably more aggressive than we have in the past in that regard, in part because we think we have better depth than we’ve had in the past.”
So perhaps the best way to view the Pirates’ acquisitions of Archer and Kela is that they finally fit a big trade for an established player into the framework of how they operate. They didn’t give up five players for two months of Manny Machado like the Los Angeles Dodgers did. They likely never will. They had better records in 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015 at the deadline than they did at this year’s deadline, and were closer in the standings — atop the division in 2013 — in each year.
You play long enough, you never change the stakes. The house takes you. But this time, Huntington felt he had a hand worth a big bet.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.