Wait a second here. How did we get from Andrew McCutchen might be traded this offseason to Andrew McCutchen MUST be traded this offseason?

How did we get to the Pirates apparently cold-calling teams like telemarketers, desperate to deal the face of their franchise?

“Hello. This is a recorded message. Our purpose for contacting you today is to explain how our desire for financial flexibility could help your baseball team … “

I understand the rationale behind shopping McCutchen. I would think any rational person does. You have a 30-year-old outfielder whose best years are almost certainly behind him. He has two years left on his contract (including a club option). You are not going to re-sign him, so you might as well shoot for a major return now.

Advertise with us

If that return were to include a super prospect and a starting pitcher who can help the 2017 club, then by all means, go for it. There’s no harm in asking.

There is much harm in pinning yourself to the mat and settling for whatever you can get, the way general manager Neal Huntington did last winter with Neil Walker.

The Pirates are not obligated to trade McCutchen. They didn’t have to trade Walker, either, although you’d never know it by what Huntington said months later, once it became clear Jon Niese was a colossal bust.

“We felt that was our best return, and it has not played out that way, and that’s a challenge,” Huntington told 93.7 The Fan. “We own that. We accept that. In hindsight, maybe the two fringe prospects and trying to figure out where to reallocate the money [that Niese was getting] might have been a better return.”

Wait, so those were the only choices — Niese or fringe prospects? What about keeping Walker and paying him a $10.55 million arbitration award? (The sound you just heard was Bob Nutting punching himself in the face). It would not have bankrupted the franchise and, even though he eventually injured his back, Walker’s power (23 home runs, career-best .823 OPS) surely would have helped.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, as Cutch Watch wound toward 8 p.m. Thursday, the Washington Nationals were looking like a possible trade partner, albeit a reluctant one. A source told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Bill Brink the Nationals were balking at the idea of sending talented outfield prospect Victor Robles and a high-end/major league-ready pitcher such as Reynaldo Lopez back this way.

The Pirates should insist on both. Or perhaps Robles and 31-year-old pitcher Gio Gonzalez, who, like McCutchen, is coming off a down year after several outstanding ones (are you sitting down, Mr. Nutting: Gonzalez is owed $24 million over the next two years).

Another option would be to acquire Robles and immediately turn him around for a possible high-impact major league pitcher. That might appease the fan base, because the starter-poor Pirates still have the makings of a decent lineup that likely would include an outfield of Gregory Polanco, Starling Marte and Josh Bell.

Failing a significant return from Washington or anyone else, the Pirates have an excellent fall-back: Keep Cutch. Put him in right field, whether he likes it or not, and hope he recaptures the form that allowed him to finish among the top five in MVP voting four of the past five years. They could always trade him at the deadline, where the return could be richer, or after the season.

It’s too bad the Pirates got almost nothing for Walker (Antonio Bastardo by the end) and nothing for Pedro Alvarez. That couldn’t have been the plan. It’s more likely the powers-that-be, maybe back in 2013 or so, projected ahead to when they might have to trade at least two of three core pieces — McCutchen, Walker and Alvarez — and imagined major replenishments in return.

Advertise with us

Well, they blew it with Walker, and nobody could have predicted that Alvarez would wake up one day suddenly unable to catch or throw a baseball and thus render himself unmarketable. But those two misfortunes should not make the Pirates desperate to get anything they can for McCutchen.

They’re allowed to keep him.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.