Scent, taste, color, size, position in the water — all contribute to a fish’s attraction to food. But in most cases, if the food isn’t moving the game fish is moving on.

That’s why they call it “live” bait.

As Pennsylvania anglers prepare for Saturday’s statewide opening of trout season, those who rely on live bait need a reliable process for keeping it alive. The iconic tin can will still hold dirt and worms, but with no insulation or wetness suppression, its effectiveness as a bait container is limited. New biological insights and container technologies can help to keep baits alive and active on the hook.

This year, most live baits are readily available. Canadian worm farms, Minnesotan minnow and leech suppliers and South American butter worm breeders have had no problem getting their product to retail shops. In many areas prices have risen slightly.

Advertise with us

Each live bait species has specific needs that must be met to extend their effectiveness.

Trout rarely see earthworms, but they are so attracted to the smelly, wiggly curiosities that red worms remain the most common trout bait, followed closely by nightcrawlers cut in half (the anterior section above the clitellum works best). But when worms smell sour and drift limp and lifeless, they’re far less effective as trout bait.

“Worms just need to be cool and dry,” said Dwight Yingling, owner of North Park Sports Shop near North Park Lake. “A cooler with a freezer pack is fine. Just don’t leave them out in the sun.”

If you plan to be mobile, cover a few dozen worms with cool dirt in a small insulated container with a tight lid and carry it in a shady pocket. A small freezer pack will keep worms healthy and active at 40 to 45 degrees. Don’t use ice cubes — water in the worm cup can be lethal to live bait.

Most bait shops sell red worms and crawlers packed in a dark black peat moss. If you’re digging, shocking or finding worms, carry them in cool black topsoil.

Advertise with us

Larvae baits — meal worms, wax worms, butter worms and maggots — are most comfortable packed in dry sawdust in a covered insulated container at about 50 degrees. Meal worms are the most susceptible to higher temperatures. Wax worms remain stable up to 60 degrees, but expire quickly at higher temperatures. Butter worms are the larval stage of a South American moth, sold at some fishing shops as bait and at pet shops as lizard food. In the bait box and on the hook, butter worms are the most resilient of the insect larvae baits.

“The problem with minnows in a bucket, the warmer they get the more oxygen they use and more their bowels move,” said Ed Vaccari, who has been selling live bait at Tackle Unlimited in Jefferson Hills for some 45 years. “You have to keep them in cool, non-chlorinated, aerated water and they have to be acclimated to the creek or lake. If you can do all that it’s a great bait.”

Tap water burns the gills of most freshwater fish, including fatheads and shiners. That includes the ice cubes many anglers dump into minnow buckets to keep the water cool. Use a freezer pack instead, or put the cubes in a resealable plastic bag and press out the air before submerging in the aerated minnow bucket.

Drastic change in temperature can stun or kill minnows before they have a chance to wiggle in the water.

“We tell customers, when you get to where you’re fishing pour some lake water into the minnow bucket to temper that water so it’s not as much as a shock” to the bait fish, said Vaccari.

Advertise with us

New technologies have improved the process of keeping live bait alive.

Simple small, un-insulated pill box-style bait boxes are good for carrying small quantities of worms for short periods of time. They’re best used in the cooler months of spring and fall. Bait containers designed for ice fishing — essentially insulated cups — are very good short-term live bait containers.

Among the most elaborate, and pricey at $40 to $50, is the “personal bait station,” an 8-ounce cooler with a hard-shell exterior, battery-powered aerator, sealable lid to prevent spills, lift-out net for easy access to bait and interior molded foam insulation to maintain temperature and protect live bait from smacking into hard walls.