Ask five trout anglers to list their Top 5 live baits and you’ll get five different answers. Not because they’re all intelligent and experienced with a variety of perspectives, skills and opinions. You asked the wrong question. Or questions.
What is the best live bait for hatchery trout stocked within the last 48 hours?
What is the best live bait for trout stocked in a lake three weeks ago?
How about the best live bait in high, cloudy creek water?
When streams are low and clear?
What is the best bait for stocked trout when live bait won’t work?
Read More
The list of questions could continue based on weather, water conditions, time of year, time of day and another hundred variables. Despite the trout’s reputation as a selective feeder, hatchery trout are significantly different from wild trout and both can be opportunistic.
Four weeks before the statewide opening of trout season, bait shops are expecting deliveries of all sorts of live baits, and anglers are legally harvesting trout at pay lakes.
With movies, concerts and restaurants closed, Albert Seghi, owner of Seghi’s Five Lakes in Fayette County, said fishing is one of the safest things to do during an airborne viral pandemic.
“You’re in the open air. They want you to stand 10 feet apart — we have 15 acres,” he said.
In Pennsylvania, pay lakes are licensed by the Fish and Boat Commission but not bound by its seasons, sizes, creel limits or license requirements. Fees can vary based on fish size or weight, and catching a tagged fish can pay off in the hundreds of dollars.
Trout food preferences can change several times in a day, said Mr. Seghi, and smart anglers roll with the changes.
“Everyday is different. Weather has 100% to do with fishing,” he said.
In his lakes’ “crystal clear” filtered waters, his favorite live baits for trout, in order, are maggots, crawlers and butterworms.
“The best is to tip a jig with two or three maggots,” he said. “Sometimes they put them on a small hook and float them under a bobber, or fish them deep with a marshmallow to float them off the bottom.”
A lot of anglers pinch crawlers in half to use as trout bait, but Mr. Seghi uses the whole thing.
“They blow up nightcrawlers with a worm blower to make them float off the bottom,” he said. “Use a No. 8 hook and a sinker. The current makes them move better to attract trout.”
The larval stage of Chilecomadia moorei, the Chilean moth, is often imported as feed for aquarium reptiles and amphibians. Anglers call them butterworms and feed them to trout with a hook buried inside the wiggly dime-size bait. Mr. Seghi fishes butterworms under a bobber.
Bob Stevens of Bethel Park has taken trout at Seghi’s Five Lakes, Patsy’s Lake (Fayette County) and other regional fee-use facilities as well as North Park Lake in Allegheny County, Millers Run and Canonsburg Lake (Washington), Raccoon Lake and Traverse Creek (Beaver) and Twin Lakes (Westmoreland). In 2019, he landed 95 trout of combined species on spin and fly rods using live and artificial baits. When he chooses live bait, his go-to grub is the mealworm.
“They wiggle, they have scent and they look like little worms,” he said. “I like them because they work the same in creeks and lakes.”
Sometimes Mr. Stevens rigs the bait 2-3 feet under a bobber with a split-shot pinched 12 inches above the hook.
“Sometimes I do a tandem with two mealworms on a hook or one mealworm and half a crawler on a hook,” he said. ”I also fish them on the bottom with a split shot and sliding sinker 18 inches from the hook, and sometimes put on a white mini-marshmallow to make the mealworm float. The marshmallow also puts scent in the water -- you can see oil come out.”
There are times, however, when a trout angler can’t buy a bite on live bait and the fish won’t say why.
“Then, more are caught on spinners and jigs,” said Mr. Seghi. “Maybe they look like a fish going through the water, acting like a minnow. I don’t know, but they work when live bait won’t.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.