Among the 49 million Americans who went fishing last year — up 2 million since 2016 — there must be dozens of distinct subcultures.

Deep sea captains see a different ocean from nearshore head boat crowds. Bobber-and-bait shore anglers have a different set of tools and customs from the bass boat set. Fly anglers read the water differently from the rest. And hardcore muskie guys? They’re a breed of their own.

For frequent customers of Pennsylvania’s 151 pay lakes, fishing is more than a strategic game of chance, and big hookups can lead to big payouts.

With tens of thousands of miles of fishable water throughout the commonwealth, why pay to go fishing? Cost or convenience of location lure some to fee-fishing lakes. Teaching impatient kids to fish may be easier in a pond filled with hungry fish. Joey Dziak, of Cokeburg, said the percentage of big fish can be greater at pay lakes.

Advertise with us

“All we do is carp, and trout in the winter,” Dziak said. “I think the numbers are probably better in the river, but if you want the bigger, quality fish we’re after, you can’t beat the pay lakes — not around here anyway.”

And while fishing is always a gamble, Dziak said the strategies needed to win at fee fishing contests add another dimension to the excitement.

“It takes a little more skill,” he said. “You lose a big one [in a pay lake carp contest], you may have just lost $100, $200 or more. You can’t win money fishing in the river.”

Unlike private ponds stocked exclusively for club members or registered campers, Class A fee fishing operations are open to anyone who pays the fee. No state-imposed seasons, sizes or creel limits, and no fishing license is required.

A few commercial fish hatcheries run pay-to-fish businesses on the side, and some farmers license their ponds to make a little more money off the land. But most fee-fishing lakes are former industrial ponds or impoundments run by their current owners like a business, and the business is fishing.

Advertise with us

In Pennsylvania, fish that live in the wild — stocked, feral or native — belong to the commonwealth and are managed through habitat enhancement, stocking and recreational fishing for the benefit of the state’s citizens.

At pay lakes, operators own their aquatic inventory, and stocking and site enhancement are for maximum customer satisfaction. Fees can vary based on fish size or weight. The state Department of Environmental Protection has authority over the quality of water discharges. The Fish and Boat Commission licenses the operations with permit fees based on lake acreage. Operators are required to give successful customers a receipt showing the number of fish harvested, species caught, date, and the operation’s location and license number.

“Looks like the number of lakes has been holding steady for quite some time,” said Larry Furlong, a lieutenant-colonel in Fish and Boat’s Bureau of Law Enforcement. “We also regulate what species they’re allowed to stock. … Most places follow the law — if they don’t, we close them down and they lose business.”

Several years ago an alert Fish and Boat officer noticed a social media posting showing a young man posing with an Asian carp, an invasive species he had caught at a pay lake. The business was fined, lost its operating permit for a year and the lake was drained. It has since been recertified and is back in business.

Pennsylvania rarely gets a new pay lake, but some have been run by the same family for generations. Albert Seghi was 4 years old when his father built Seghi’s Five Lakes near Smithfield in Fayette County in 1955.

Advertise with us

“The general interest [in pay lakes] has dropped a good bit — probably more clubs stocking fish and the rivers got cleaned up — but lately we’re getting more people coming in,” he said. “It’s convenient. Free tent camping where they’re fishing, a bait shop right there and a clean level area.”

Although Seghi’s fish are restocked every week, he said it’s become harder for commercial operators to get common carp. Fish and Boat has banned the capture, transport and restocking of all Lake Erie fish in an attempt to slow the spread of invasive aquatic species. Shipments of carp from Chesapeake Bay are inconsistent, Seghi said.

Sandy Lake, a 3-acre fee-fishing hotspot, is located less than a mile from the Monongahela River in Dravosburg. The former mining pit is as deep as 10 feet, fed by a stream and springs and engineered with bottom aerators and a catch basin. The site is comfortably landscaped with convenient parking and a well-equipped fishing shop. Co-owner Nancy Shirley said the urban fishing hole has earned a loyal year-round customer base.

“We make sure we’re well-stocked and move the fish in and out based on the season -- trout in the fall, big bass and catfish, and our big season is the [current] carp season,“ she said. “Our people really like the contests for biggest, smallest, quickest catch and some more. We tag trout to win up to $100 or free passes. They’re serious about it.”

Part of the way pay-lake operations compete is through the marketing of contests. They all do it differently. At Sandy Lake, 42 fishing spots are numbered. During each fishing session, players draw for initial spaces and strategically move to unclaimed spots where they believe the fishing might be better.

Advertise with us

During last week’s contest, competitors were choosy with their rigs — sinker or no sinker, barrel swivel and a bead or beaded hooks, rice or cornmeal paste baits.

Dziak prefers to string medium-action spinning rods with 6-pound-test line for himself and sons Rider, 12, and Warrik, 10. He likes No. 4 hooks and the family home cooks its own cornmeal bait.

“We try to have it as soft as possible and you want it to flake off a little,” he said. “When they come in, they feed off the little pile there and we have a little ball with a hook in it. … Getting everything just right — it’s an addiction. You want to come back for more.”

Explore the Outdoors with John Hayes!

Outdoors writer John Hayes shares tips, tricks, photos and more in his Facebook group. Join today!

Advertise with us

Fee fishing is available on these southwestern Pennsylvania pay lakes.

ALLEGHENY COUNTY

Deep Valley Lakes

7111 Steubenville Pike, Oakdale

412-494-4606, facebook.com/DeepValleyLakes2016/

Advertise with us

Sandy Lake

1500 Macarthur Drive, Dravosburg

412-466-6569, facebook.com/pg/Sandy-Lake-Kenny-Bs-271995319931955

FAYETTE COUNTY

Hi-To Lake

Advertise with us

199 Hi-To Road, Fairchance

724-564-2540, facebook.com/pg/HiToLakeBar

Paradise Lakes

275 Filbert Orient Road, New Salem

724-246-2992, paradiselakes.net

Advertise with us

Patsy's Lake 

345 Searight Herbert Road, Uniontown

724-366-2819, facebook.com/patsyslake

Rosensteel’s Restaurant, Bar and Fishing Lakes

206 Eighty Acres Road, Dunbar

Advertise with us

724-438-2030, mobile.facebook.com/rosensteels

Seghi's Five Lakes Inc.

258 Seghi Road, Smithfield

724-569-5329, Fishingmorgantownwv.com

Thirsty’s Pay Lake

Advertise with us

East Millsboro

724-317-7139, facebook.com/thirstys.paylakes

SOMERSET COUNTY

Laurel Hill Trout Farm

4283 Route 31, Jones Mills

Advertise with us

724-216-6800, laurelhilltroutfarm.com

Pioneer Park Campground

273 Trent Road, Somerset

814-445-6348, pioneerparkcampground.com

Seven Springs Mountain Resort

Advertise with us

777 Water Wheel Drive, Seven Springs

814-352-7777, 7springs.com

WASHINGTON COUNTY

84 Lakes Lounge

1937 Route 136, Eighty Four

Advertise with us

724-228-3552, 84-lakes-lounge.business.site

Bells Lake

260 Bells Lake Road, Prosperity

724-228-4698, facebook.com/Bells-Lake-Fishing-Camping-333823316686985

WESTMORELAND COUNTY

Advertise with us

Mirror Lake Campground

112 Trout Run Drive, New Florence

724-235-2115, mirrorlakervcamping.com