There is no convincing me that Catholic high schools — and also charter schools — don’t enjoy a competitive advantage in sports because they don’t have geographic boundaries to take students.

But that doesn’t mean I’m all in for separate postseason tournaments for public and private/Catholic schools. I’m still on the fence about the subject, mainly because I have yet to see a system that makes sense for separate tournaments.

But I am absolutely sure how I feel about the new proposed legislation that would force the PIAA to create separate PIAA tournaments for public and Catholic/private schools. It’s called House Bill 1600. Here’s to hoping the bill goes under house arrest.

This bill has more questions about it than Jeopardy, and more holes than Oakmont Country Club. I’m still scratching my head on how, if the idea is to have separate tournaments, why do public schools still have to play Catholic/private schools in all district playoffs, including the WPIAL? The separate tournaments start in the PIAA playoffs.

Advertise with us

How is this supposed to appease complaining public schools? What happens when a public school gets knocked out of the WPIAL playoffs by a Catholic school?

I’ve tried to look at the new bill objectively, but there are too many flaws in it. And now we have this matter: The legislator who is proposing the new bill has pretty much accused the WPIAL board of directors of making rulings based on racism. And Rep. Aaron Bernstine, R-Beaver/Butler/Lawrence County, doubled down on his accusation earlier this week.

Oh, and he also said sports reporters are “despicable and disgusting” when they write about student-athletes transferring for athletic reasons, even if the WPIAL and PIAA rule them ineligible for transferring for athletic reasons.

When asked why is it wrong to report if a student-athlete has been ruled ineligible by the WPIAL and PIAA for transferring for athletic reasons, Bernstine said, “You can talk bad about Pittsburgh college and professional players, but as soon as you start writing things about children, it’s disgusting and despicable.”

That stinkin’ media.

Advertise with us

As for the racism charges against the PIAA, Bernstine recently tweeted #WPIAL hearings today … 5 African American children (student-athletes) are the targets. Interesting data when African Americans make up only 11.6% of PA population.

But Bernstine didn’t even know the facts of the five cases or the WPIAL or PIAA rules concerning reasons for hearings. He was told that two of the hearings were because a school contested the transfers, claiming the moves were for athletic reasons. When a school contests a transfer or doesn’t “sign off” on it, the WPIAL follows PIAA rules and has a hearing with parties involved. When told that, Bernstine said, “Well, they were still 3 for 3 on the others.”

Bernstine was then told the other three hearings had nothing to do with transferring for athletic intent. They were three student-athletes who were appealing postseason ineligibility because of a new PIAA rule enacted last summer. All three, by the way, were granted postseason eligibility by the WPIAL.

“What I can tell you is facts are facts,” Bernstine said. “It seems to be if you have money and power to afford a high-end attorney to get yourself out of a situation from the WPIAL and PIAA, you’ll be able to walk away scot-free. If you’re an inner city kid who doesn’t have the money and is trying to find a better school, you’re held to a different standard.”

He went on to say the WPIAL and PIAA “hurt children.”

Advertise with us

The truth is, the WPIAL generally rules 250-300 transfers eligible every year, mostly on paperwork. According to WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley, about 5% are brought in for hearings. When Bernstine was asked if he had any statistics on how many WPIAL transfers are ruled eligible or ineligible, or if he had any facts on how many black student-athletes are ruled ineligible, Bernstine said, “We’re working on that.”

But now back to explaining some parts of the new bill — and its shortfalls. Under the bill, the PIAA must have separate postseason tournaments for eight sports — football, boys and girls basketball, baseball, softball, boys and girls soccer and girls volleyball. Try making sense of some facts:

• The bill says the PIAA must have the same number of championships for public schools as Catholic/private schools. But there are currently 524 public schools playing football in the PIAA and only 43 Catholic/private. So there will be six state titles for 43 schools? Wow.

• There are only five Class 6A Catholic/private schools in the state and Central Catholic is one. The other four are in the Philadelphia Catholic League. So, will there be a state championship for five schools? And get this: There are two Class 5A Catholic schools in the entire state.

• Bernstine says he believes the PIAA will go back to four classifications instead of six in a number of sports but PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi has said there are no thoughts of going back to four classes.

Advertise with us

• Who will be playing Central Catholic in state playoffs and will they get an automatic bid to all state playoffs because no Catholic school in the West is close to Central’s size?

• Let’s look at qualifiers in basketball and just use the WPIAL as an example. In Class 3A boys basketball, seven teams from the WPIAL will qualify for the PIAA playoffs this season. There are only three Catholic/private schools in all of WPIAL Class 3A basketball this season. So in the future, do all three of those qualify for the PIAA Catholic/private school playoffs?

Bernstine said he believes one of the biggest things being overlooked in the bill is that the make-up of district board of directors will have to meet new parameters. Thirteen percent of a board must be made up of Catholic/private school representatives and those reps will decide how many Catholic/private schools will go to the PIAA playoffs and how they will qualify.

Catholic schools around the state are in favor of the bill. That might seem shocking to many. But there is one major reason. The new bill eliminates the PIAA transfer rule. Of course, Catholic schools would love that. I’m not here to say any Catholic school recruits. Some are often unfairly accused of recruiting. Talented players often come to them. But Catholic schools will never again have to answer questions about student-athletes transferring for athletic reasons. That’s great for them.

But if I’m, say, a basketball coach at a public school in Western Pa., I’m going out recruiting right away. Maybe get a talented player from the Philadelphia area, become his guardian and have him move in with me. That’s legal under the new bill. Have a 7-footer move in with the booster president. That’s legal. Have a star from Congo move in with a neighbor. That’s legal.

Advertise with us

And Bernstine said this would be legal under the new bill: A kid could live in, say, Peters Township and play football for Central Catholic. He could then enroll at Peters Township for basketball season and play. He then could transfer to Seton LaSalle in the spring to run track.

Bernstine contends that too many people are picking apart the new bill piece by piece instead of looking at the big picture. But you have to look at the minor details and the many questions because those are the things that also matter.

I believe maybe there could be a system with four public school classifications and two Catholic/private school classifications. That might work. Catholic/privates and public schools would play in the regular season, but there would be separate playoffs even for the WPIAL. Central Catholic might not have anyone to play in the WPIAL playoffs, but they could go into a Western region playoff with Erie Cathedral Prep and a few schools from Harrisburg.

Of course, that doesn’t address the complaints about charter schools, which are technically public schools, even though they don’t have geographical boundaries.

The bottom line is student-athlete transfers are controversial in every state. States have different rules. I’m beginning to think that maybe kids should be allowed to transfer for athletic reasons. Try it. See how it works.

Advertise with us

But may I think outside the box and propose this: What about two Pennsylvania associations for high school athletics — the PIAA and the PIAAA. The Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association stays as is. If your school opts in, you have to follow the rules. It’s your choice whether public, Catholic, private or charter.

Then there is the Pennsylvania I’ll Allow Anything Association (PIAAA). It’s like the AAU league that has no rules on transfers, recruiting, or pretty much anything. Seriously. You just can’t pay players, but you can give them scholarships.

It would be like the European model. And there are plenty of schools around the U.S. like this now (IMG Academy in Florida). There are some prep schools like this. Other schools are basically basketball factories. Even public schools can opt into the PIAAA. It’s perfect for the really serious athlete.

But House Bill 1600 is not right for Pennsylvania athletics at this time.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh