All the talk and all the push from some school superintendents, principals and coaches can stop. They have wanted the PIAA to create separate playoff tournaments for public and private/Catholic/charter schools.
But the PIAA has pretty much made a declaration and said forget it. Separate tournaments are not going to happen.
Unless the state legislature forces it.
At a meeting last week, the PIAA board of directors crafted a statement that says it has no interest in separate tournaments for public schools with geographic boundaries, and schools with no geographic boundaries that can draw students from anywhere.
The “position statement” from the PIAA says: “The PIAA board of directors, at the recommendation of counsel, concludes and therefore reaffirms that the separation of playoffs with regard to public, charter and private schools is contrary to the publicly documented legislative intent Act 219 of 1972.”
Bob Lombardi, executive director of the PIAA, put the statement into layman’s terms.
Read More
“It basically says the board believes the legislative intent of the law in 1972 has both the private and public schools playing together in the [PIAA] membership, and they’re not going to do anything that would violate the legislative intent of the law,” said Lombardi.
The 1972 act that the PIAA brings up is the law that forced the PIAA to accept Catholic schools into membership. Critics contend the law only says the PIAA must accept Catholic schools. It does not say there can’t be separate postseason tournaments. Critics also contend the PIAA is hiding behind an antiquated law that was formulated when the landscape of high school sports was drastically different. There were no charter schools back then, and the Catholic schools that joined the WPIAL (part of the PIAA) actually had geographic boundaries that no longer exist.
The critics of private/Catholic/charter schools claim those schools have an unfair advantage in sports because they can draw students from anywhere. An example: St. Joseph’s Prep won the PIAA Class 6A championship this season and beat WPIAL champ Pine-Richland in the semifinals. St. Joseph’s had star sophomore quarterback Kyle McCord, who lives in New Jersey. Yet he can attend St. Joseph’s because it is a Catholic school that can take students from anywhere.
More and more non-public schools, especially from Philadelphia, have won PIAA championships in the past decade, and the public vs. private debate has become more heated in the past year or so, as groups of superintendents and school principals have gotten together and called for the PIAA to change. The PIAA has met with representatives of superintendents, principals and even state legislators to discuss the situation.
The PIAA adopted some new student-athlete transfer rules this summer in what the organization hopes will stop the many transfers of student-athletes, especially in Philadelphia, to Catholic, private or charter schools. Lombardi said he believes the new transfer rule is having an effect on things. Under the new rule, a transfer student is ineligible for the postseason in any sport they have participated in after the start of 10th grade.
The PIAA also has created a “competition success formula” for football and basketball only, where teams could be bumped up in classification, but only if they do two things: advance far into the postseason in two consecutive seasons and exceed the maximum number of student-athlete transfers allowed in that sport.
But as for the idea of separate tournaments for public and non-public schools, Lombardi was asked if the issue is pretty much now dead, unless the state legislature intervenes.
His answer: “Yes, I think that’s the feeling of our board.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.