Fifty years ago yesterday, 28 members of the Ohio National Guard fired upon a group of anti-war protesters at Kent State University, killing four and injuring nine.

The massacre took 13 seconds. The Ohio National Guard claimed they were shooting in self-defense because of sniper fire. All bullets fired and recovered that day came from the guns of the soldiers.

It was a catalyzing moment in American history, but public opinion was split between those who were horrified that National Guard soldiers could bring themselves to fire upon citizens young enough to be their college-aged children and those who felt that the “anti-war militants” had it coming.

Eleven days later at Jackson State College in Jackson, Miss., police fired on a crowd of black protesters killing two and injuring 12. The unfocused and indiscriminate shooting took 28 seconds. The police claimed they were responding to gunfire from a sniper whose bullets were never recovered or presence verified.

Advertise with us

To be a protester a half-century ago was to offer up your life for possible martyrdom for a higher cause. What you didn’t exercise was your right to bear arms if you were demonstrating for free speech at the University of California, Berkeley, or gay liberation at the Stonewall bar or the end of police brutality in a low-income neighborhood anywhere in America.

If you carried signs that said “I Am A Man” while marching under the suspicious gaze of bayonet-wielding National Guardsmen in Memphis, that was one thing. But if there had been even a hint that the Second Amendment was an option for the protesters, it would’ve been all the provocation the government required. To a public sensitive to disruptions of the status quo, any resulting death because of the presence of guns would’ve been acceptable.

A half-century ago, Kent State University photojournalism student John Filo snapped the Pulitzer Prize-winning picture of a distraught Mary Ann Vecchio, 14 years old, wailing over the body of Jeffrey Miller, one of the slain students. It became iconic and created a symbol to rally behind for the millions of students who protested on their campuses over the next week.

Such a photo would be unimaginable in an era of COVID-19 protests when civilian protesters are just as likely to be in a position to outgun and intimidate the police.

If anything, a modern-day Mary Ann Vecchio would be yelling defiantly, her finger on the trigger of whatever gun she chose to bring to the rally, guaranteeing her right not to be a “victim” of government tyranny.

Advertise with us

These days, protesters come armed to rallies that have nothing to do with guns because they are a militia with many grievances, and because unarmed protesters are considered an unacceptable anachronism by those who once deplored anti-war/​anti-racism/​anti-police brutality protests.

These militia consider the right to arrive strapped with semi-automatics at the steps of the very buildings where lawmakers deliberate a right even more sacred than freedom of speech. If the lawmakers are “intimidated” by citizens exercising their Second Amendment rights, well, that’s on them, the militias say.

The most thoughtful among the armed protesters know that America hasn’t always tolerated what they as disgruntled white men with guns now take for granted. They are well aware of their privilege and they’re grateful for it. They would be as shocked as the students were at Kent State in 1970 if any cops or soldiers ever made a hostile move in their direction.

They know that had they been African Americans showing up armed at state capitols in the South at the height of racial segregation, the ground would still be wet with their blood. The massacres would’ve been endless and unrelenting.

The vigilante groups that are the forerunners of the protesters today would’ve joined the police in any shootout with “black agitators” because that was an American tradition stretching back centuries. There is nothing original about this observation and every American knows it is true.

Advertise with us

But as most protesters of successful revolutions and causes know, it is important to get the sympathy of the people behind you and not to alienate them with violence or threats of violence.

If protesters from Flint, Mich., were to show up armed at the same state Capitol where armed protesters tried to force their way into the rotunda last week, the presence of gun-wielding blacks and working-class whites protesting together would inspire howls of hypocritical outrage: “We know people in Flint want clean, potable water, but why is it necessary to bring guns to a protest about installing lead-free plumbing?”

Good question. One could also ask why is it necessary to bring guns to a protest about lifting restrictions on commerce and public gatherings while still in the midst of a pandemic that could kill as many as 3,000 Americans daily by the end of June.

But showing up at state houses with guns, whether in Lansing, Mich., or Harrisburg, Pa., is not about persuasion — it is about intimidation and the implicit threat of violence. If the militia feels sufficiently disrespected or threatened, it wants to be on record with a menacing presence of its own.

A half-century after the Ohio National Guard turned four students into martyrs, the likelihood of such a thing ever happening again is close to zero. These days, the protesters who have answered President Donald Trump’s call to “liberate Michigan” want everyone to know that they’re prepared to defend themselves and each other to the death, even if all they’re protesting are leash laws and mandatory vaccinations. Tyranny is tyranny, and there’s no greater tyranny than paternalism disguised as governance as far as they’re concerned.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.