A little over a week after Fred Rogers died in February 2003, I interviewed the Rev. Fred Phelps, his evil doppelganger, over the phone. Phelps founded the Topeka, Kan.-based Westboro Baptist Church, which was notorious for picketing funerals of those it considered “mockers of God.”
“Mr. Rogers gave aid and comfort to homosexuals,” Phelps told me, vowing to send a contingent of his tiny church to Pittsburgh to picket the Heinz Hall memorial service for Rogers then planned for May.
“He was a man who preached tolerance of all sorts of people in ways that directly contradicted the Bible,” Phelps said. “His syrupy teachings led millions astray. He was a wuss and an enabler of wusses.”
Phelps, who died in 2014, would’ve been surprised by recent headlines heralding the publication of a new memoir by Francois Clemmons, who played Officer Clemmons on “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood” from 1968 to 1993.
“Mister Rogers Encouraged Gay Costar Officer Clemmons to Stay in the Closet and Marry a Woman” was emblazoned across the headline deck of People magazine last Friday. Mr. Clemmons spoke to People exclusively, but excerpts from the interview appeared everywhere.
At some point unspecified in the excerpts I’ve seen, Mr. Clemmons was called into Rogers’ studio office at WQED, presumably in 1968 or 1969, for a heart-to-heart.
Read More
It was a time of deep, social tumult in America. Martin Luther King Jr. and Bobby Kennedy were assassinated in 1968 and the Stonewall riots occurred in the summer of 1969, signaling the beginning of the gay liberation movement and the end of passivity when it came to abusive police raids on gay bars.
President Richard Nixon was ascendant and many of his congressional allies wanted to zero out the budget for public television, the platform Rogers had used since 1966 for his “radical experiment” to teach tolerance to kids across the nation while they were still young and impressionable.
“Franc, you have talents and gifts that set you apart and above the crowd,” Mr. Clemmons writes that Rogers said to him. “Someone has informed us that you were seen at the local gay bar downtown. Now, I want you to know, Franc, that if you’re gay, it doesn’t matter to me at all. Whatever you say and do is fine with me, but if you’re going to be on the show as an important member of the Neighborhood, you can’t be out as gay.”
When Rogers said those words, Mr. Clemmons began sobbing. “I could have his friendship and fatherly love and relationship forever … but I could have the job only if I stayed in the closet.”
It’s true that Rogers was asking Mr. Clemmons to deny a major part of who he was in public for the sake of the TV show they were building together.
“‘You must do this Francois,’ he told me, ‘because it threatens my dream,’” Mr. Clemmons told People. “I was destroyed. The man who was killing me had also saved me. He was my executioner and deliverer. But, at the same time, I knew that he would know how to comfort me. I didn’t have another mother or father to comfort me. I had no one to go and be a boy with. I was just vulnerable. He got in a few slaps, some tough love, a good spanking. But I was not kicked out of the family.”
In May 1969, Rogers testified before the Senate about the PBS budget and why his show was worth it. He was supremely persuasive, but a culture war scandal would’ve sunk “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood” and torpedoed PBS funding forever.
Was Rogers’ appeal to Mr. Clemmons’ discretion at a time when civil rights was still considered a novel legal idea in much of America the right call? When you consider the times, it was the only thing Rogers could do.
Remember: Interracial marriage had become legal barely two years before and there was still pushback about that in the American South. “Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner” was not getting screened in many places below the Mason-Dixon line.
There’s no understating what a profoundly conservative and patriarchal country America was in the late ’60s. There was a deep suspicion of anything that seemed even remotely alien. It was a suspicion that Nixon exploited and rode to the White House. Rogers was determined that his children’s show would not become a victim of Silent Majority demagoguing by homophobes.
“‘The world doesn’t really want to know who you’re sleeping with — especially if it’s a man,’” Mr. Clemmons said Rogers told him. “‘You can have it all if you can keep that part out of the limelight.’”
Yes, that would be unconscionable advice today, especially coming from someone of Fred Rogers’ stature and cultural influence. Equally unforgivable would be Rogers’ advice to Mr. Clemmons to find a woman willing to “make compromises in life” that would allow her to marry a gay man to give him professional cover.
Mr. Clemmons did marry as per Rogers’ advice, but he and his wife amicably divorced in 1974. Mr. Clemmons came out of the closet and it doesn’t appear to have affected his employment on “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood” after that.
Keeping Mr. Clemmons’ queerness a secret initially made one of the most important episodes on the show possible. On May 9, 1969, eight days after his Senate testimony, Mister Rogers and Mr. Clemmons shared a child’s wading pool to cool their feet on a hot day. They also used the same towel to dry their feet in defiance of lingering white cultural revulsions about proximity between the races, especially in water.
In 1993, the duo recreated the pool scene to mark Officer Clemmons’ last appearance on the show. They used one towel, but this time Rogers dried Mr. Clemmons’ feet in imitation of Jesus drying the feet of his disciples. “I am a black gay man and Fred washed my feet,” Mr. Clemmons told a Vermont news website about the experience that moved him profoundly.
When asked if he forgives Fred Rogers for the dilemma he presented him with decades ago, Mr. Clemmons said, “Lord have mercy, yes, I forgive him. More than that, I understand.”
Somewhere, the spirit of the Rev. Fred Phelps is still raging against the dying of the dark.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.