This week, Ida B. Wells was posthumously awarded the Pulitzer Prize for her decadeslong work reporting lynching in America in the 19th and early 20th centuries.

When Wells published her exposes in the newspaper she owned in Memphis, Tenn., it was attacked and destroyed by white vigilantes. That didn’t stop her. Wells published her investigations in pamphlets distributed throughout the South and in newspapers across the nation.

By the time of her death in 1931, Wells had amassed the most comprehensive collection of lynching stories and statistics in the country. So it is fitting that in the same week a modern lynching has come to light thanks to a newly released video, one of America’s foremost investigative journalists is in the news again.

What would Ida B. Wells make of the case of Ahmaud Arbery, an unarmed 25-year-old black man chased by two white men in a pickup truck in a suburban south Georgia neighborhood and shot to death because they believe he fit the description of a burglar?

Advertise with us

On Feb. 23, Mr. Arbery, who lived just outside of Brunswick, Ga., was jogging in Satilla Shores, a nearby suburb, when he sprinted past the front yard of Gregory McMichael, 64, a retired investigator in the Brunswick district attorney’s office. Prior to working for the DA, Mr. McMichael worked in the Glynn County Police Department for seven years.

Mr. McMichael called out to his son Travis McMichael, 34, to join him in his attempt to chase down Mr. Arbery because he “looked” like a burglary suspect. Before hopping into their pickup truck, the McMichaels grabbed a .357 Magnum and a shotgun, both of which they are licensed to carry.

A third man joined the pursuit of Mr. Arbery. Presumably it is his dashboard camera that captures Travis McMichael struggling with Mr. Arbery before the first gunshot rings out and both move temporarily out of the frame. Mr. Arbery gets a few good punches in before a second shot goes off, causing him to turn to run. Then there is a third shot and Mr. Arbery staggers forward and falls face first in the road. It was 1 o’clock in the afternoon in broad daylight. What kind of burglar was he?

Until Thursday, neither McMichael had been arrested or charged with murder. National outrage changed that even though Georgia is a stand-your-ground state that gives citizens the right to arrest, detain and even kill someone if they believe a crime has been committed.

The fact that Mr. Arbery had not committed a crime when he was chased down is immaterial. It’s the perception of his killers that counts, not objective facts.

Advertise with us

Mr. Arbery’s willingness to fight two armed white men even though he was barehanded constituted a rationale for his pursuers to shoot him according to the twisted logic of Georgia. His rage at being ambushed couldn’t possibly have generated the adrenaline that caused him to defend himself against all odds. All he had to do was submit to their authority and all would’ve been well.

Two prosecutors recused themselves from the case citing prior working relationships with the elder McMichael, but a third prosecutor, Tom Durden of Georgia’s Atlantic Judicial Circuit, said a grand jury should look at charges and decide whether to indict. The two have now been arrested.

Because of COVID-19, a grand jury can’t be impaneled until mid-June, but the howls of community outrage are guaranteed to continue growing until then. The graphic nature of Mr. Arbery’s killing on the video is too shocking to allow the good ol’ boy network in southern Georgia to cover it up.

In the days to come, much will be made of the fact that Mr. Arbery was convicted of shoplifting and violating probation two years ago. Sure, that’s a reason to kill him! Five years earlier, he took a handgun to a high school basketball game. The folks smearing him will conveniently forget he was a star player on the high school football team. He was also obsessive about staying in shape years after he graduated, thus the jogging in midday.

What would Ida B. Wells have made of the McMichaels’ depraved disregard for Mr. Arbery’s life as they were chasing him down with the intent to kill him “if necessary”?

Advertise with us

What would a woman who was born into slavery have thought of a Georgia law that empowers vigilantes to kill when they feel threatened despite being the aggressors? What would a woman who faced down the Klan have thought of laws that favor politically connected white men standing without any concern over the mute corpse of a man they just killed?

We’re not so far removed from Wells’ time that we can’t give a fairly educated guess to what she would’ve thought. She would’ve recorded what happened to Ahmaud Arbery as a lynching. She would’ve been writing about it in an age when lynchers weren’t embarrassed about what they did. They would not have hidden behind vague laws to give their killings a patina of justice. They did it because it was a privilege they took for granted as white men in America.

Because she is being honored this week, Ida B. Wells, among the greatest of our investigative journalists, deserves to have the last word, from her 1895 pamphlet “The Red Record”: “If the Southern people in defense of their lawlessness, would tell the truth and admit that colored men and women are lynched for almost any offense, from murder to a misdemeanor, there would not now be the necessity of this defense. But when they intentionally, maliciously and constantly belie the record and bolster up these falsehoods by the words of legislators, preachers, governors and bishops, then the Negro must give to the world his side of the awful story.”

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.