We’re just a few weeks into the enforced isolation of COVID-19 and it’s already beginning to feel like that part in a sci-fi movie where a time traveler from the future comes back to warn us not to be stupid:

“If you don’t continue bending the curve, something far worse than an economic slowdown will be waiting for you on the other side of this pandemic,” the time traveler says.

Most of us are coping with the uncertainty and societal anxiety as best we can while sheltering in place. We don’t like the lack of variety and options being cooped up inside all day presents us, but we’re pretty sure the alternative would be pretty hideous and far worse than the inconvenience most of us are currently experiencing.

While I don’t personally know anyone who has died yet from COVID-19, I have friends and acquaintances who are surrounded by death because of this virus. Consequently, it feels very real and ever present to me even though I haven’t been touched by it personally.

Advertise with us

The suffering of others is a reminder to us that pain and loss are inevitable during a plague. No amount of social distancing will exempt those of us with deep familial ties or friendships from the existential cost of being alive during this point in human history. If we have any capacity for love, then we’ll have to deal with the hard lessons COVID-19 will eventually teach us.

When I saw the ugly protests erupting on the steps of state capitals in recent days, my initial reaction was anger and disgust. In Michigan, groups of mostly bearded men, a few openly brandishing weapons, held signs denouncing Gov. Gretchen Whitmer while waving American flags, pro-Trump signs and demanding an end to the lockdown.

The protesters don’t like “social distancing” and hate not being allowed to come and go as they please. They did not practice social distancing during their protest, though a minority of them wore masks just in case the disease many of them are inclined to minimize as “the flu” is as contagious and potentially fatal as the scientists and doctors in New York, New Jersey, California and other real world places say it is.

Many of the protesters denounced Ms. Whitmer as a “Nazi” and a “dictator” online, but have no problem with President Donald Trump claiming that the scope of his presidential power is “absolute” and that it is his decision alone to open the states for business in the near future if he chooses to do so.

While the level of Mr. Trump’s constitutional illiteracy is breathtaking, it isn’t surprising. He doesn’t know anything and has always been proud of his ignorance.

Advertise with us

But why would so many men with so much to lose stand on the steps of the capitol in Lansing, Mich., and demand that the governor do something that would likely result in the deaths of many they love and millions of their fellow citizens across the country?

Like the sacred right to bear semiautomatic weapons in public, they argued for their God-given right to appear in public unmasked and to be able to invade other people’s space if they chose to do so. They consider any restrictions on their liberty, even for the “public good,” an infringement of their rights as Americans.

My anger at these men soon turned to pity once I realized that for all of their armed bravado, the men who stood on the capitol steps with their guns and their flags were profoundly afraid. They had convinced themselves that their machismo, their fatalism and their “Don’t Tread On Me” contrariness would somehow forestall the death they see threatening them from the distance.

They’re not stupid. They know that the threat represented by the coronavirus is real. They hear the reports about what’s happening in Detroit on the other side of the state and it scares them. But their default mode for dealing with uncomfortable realities is to show defiance.

They would rather huddle and rage against the governor Mr. Trump dismissively referred to as “that woman” than submit to behavior that would result in a good outcome for most people in the state. They want to believe that just because they are superficially patriotic, that they are immune in their folly in a country that embraces American Exceptionalism.

Advertise with us

They don’t want to hear about the science of contagion. They don’t want to know how pathogens work and how proximity to a carrier can either kill them or make them a carrier of a virus that could kill someone they love. In that way the coronavirus reveals itself to be the ultimate selfish gene because it first occupies the bodies of those who willfully open themselves to it out of a sense of cultural spite.

They shouted that they wanted jobs and that Ms. Whitmer should be removed from office for doing what every responsible governor in the country has done to “flatten the curve” to save lives and to stop the spread of the virus.

In Frankfort, Ky., 100 demonstrators demanded that Gov. Andy Beshear also be removed from office for trying to enforce social distancing rules during a pandemic. The angry Kentuckians shouted “you are not the king” that could be heard in the studio as the governor gave a live address on TV and radio.

Some of the protesters were angry that big box retailers like Walmart and Target have been allowed to stay open, but smaller, independent retailers have been deemed “non-essential” and ordered closed.

A legitimate argument can be made that the list of essential and non-essential businesses generally discriminates against noncorporate and family-owned businesses, but that shouldn’t be used as an argument against a governor’s right to do whatever’s necessary for the public good during a pandemic.

Advertise with us

Protesters insisted that it should be up to them to decide whether their churches should open and whether they had the right to gather publicly to worship without fear that police would gather license numbers and track them down if there’s an outbreak.

The protesters other big chant — “Facts over fear” — should’ve collapsed under the weight of irony that hung over everything that came from the protesters’ mouths that day. Of course their demonstration was about fear. If it had been about facts, they wouldn’t have been there at all.

Ironically, if the protesters were able to achieve what they wanted, the mass death that would result from a lessening of social distancing rules would make them far more sympathetic to what the governors of Kentucky and Michigan were trying to accomplish. But it would be too late at that point. Once the body count approaches apocalyptic levels, even the most stubborn skeptic is capable of changing their mind. Once everyone they know and love is dead, suddenly they “get” it.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.