1917 was a very big year. It was the year the United States entered World War I, which was already a charnel house of mindless butchery. There were multiple race riots in East St. Louis.

Czar Nicholas II abdicated the largest monarchy in the world as the Russian Revolution closed in. The U.S. bought the Virgin Islands from Denmark for $25 million. The Original Dixie Jazz Band put out the first jazz record on a 78 RPM record.

Soldier and adventurer T.E. Lawrence did all the things on the Arabian Peninsula that would make him the subject of a great David Lean film many decades later. A fire in Atlanta displaced 10,000, but miraculously claimed only one casualty. It was a very strange and brutal year. What it wasn’t was the year a flu epidemic broke out and killed millions in a two-year stretch.

That would be 1918-1919. You wouldn’t know that by listening to President Donald Trump during the coronavirus daily briefings when he refers to the deadliest pandemic of the last century that killed an estimated 50 million worldwide and 675,000 in the United States alone.

Advertise with us

Still, Mr. Trump repeatedly refers to 1917 — possibly because an Oscar-winning film about WWI trench warfare planted it in his brain — as the year the Spanish influenza, which did not start in Spain, went global.

It’s a little thing, admittedly, but an annoying little thing. It speaks to the Emperor’s New Clothes culture that has sprung up around Mr. Trump at a time when attention to truth and details can have life-or-death implications. What’s the big deal about Mr. Trump consistently getting the year of the deadliest pandemic since the Black Plague wrong?

Given that Mr. Trump needs a patina of credibility now more than ever, a pointless “mistake” like misattributing the year of the Spanish flu is indistinguishable from a “pointless lie.” After all, he’s documented to have told over 16,000 lies since his inauguration.

It’s a variation of George Orwell’s “the clock struck 13” line at the beginning of “1984.” We all know there’s no 13th hour, except on military time, but Orwell was giving us insight into the totalitarian mentality that is always quick to impose a new reality over the old template without acknowledging the switch.

I find it hard to believe that when he’s surrounded by the nation’s leading experts on infectious and communicable diseases that someone hasn’t gently corrected him by saying, “Mr. President, you’re off by one year. That pandemic started in 1918 and finished in 1919.”

Advertise with us

The scientists and political figures on the White House’s Coronavirus Task Force know that they’re being scrutinized by the media, history and a terrified public. Attention to detail if you’re the president of the United States says that you take the disaster that currently engulfs us seriously.

So assuming that Dr. Anthony Fauci or Dr. Deborah Birx or someone on the Coronavirus Task Force has pointed out the error of blaming 1917 instead of 1918, why hasn’t Mr. Trump complied?

Is he stupid? I honestly don’t think Mr. Trump is stupid, though he is factually ignorant about a lot of things. He’s a creature of pure instinct and knows how to exploit the passions and resentments of disenfranchised white people better than any American politician since Huey Long or Ronald Reagan.

What’s the advantage to placing the Spanish flu pandemic a year earlier than when it actually happened? I believe Mr. Trump has a good enough memory to recall what people have told him about the actual date, but he reserves the right to go his own way when it comes to disputing all so-called “facts.”

Because no one dares correct him at the podium over a little thing like 1917 vs. 1918, it makes it that much harder to correct him over big things like the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine as a possible cure for COVID-19, a drug he has become increasingly insistent about touting at recent White House briefings to the discomfort of actual doctors on the panel.

Advertise with us

White House trade adviser Peter Navarro became confrontational with Dr. Fauci at a recent task force meeting when the scientist who has worked for every president since Reagan said the obvious about hydroxychloroquine: Evidence that it works as hyped is anecdotal and more data is needed. Mr. Navarro, who has a Ph.D. in economics from Harvard and is not a scientist and has never practiced medicine, insists he is as qualified to read and interpret medical data as the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases because he is “a social scientist.”

Only in the era of Trump is such ridiculous sophistry even possible. But there seems to be an unspoken understanding that Mr. Trump can literally say whatever he wants and get no pushback from his experts in public. Corrections, if any, happen off-stage. And there is reason to believe that it isn’t happening much these days.

On Sunday, when a reporter asked Dr. Fauci to weigh in on hydroxychloroquine, Mr. Trump wouldn’t allow him to answer the question. “Do you know how many times he’s answered that question? Maybe 15,” Mr. Trump said pulling a number from the air.

When the exasperated reporter countered with “he’s your medical expert, correct?” Mr. Trump growled “You don’t have to ask the question” — which translated into: “Dr. Fauci, doesn’t have to answer the question.” Dr. Fauci wanted to answer, but the line of questioning was shut down.

Dr. Fauci knows that pandemic or not, if Mr. Trump perceives him as trying to embarrass him, he’ll be fired. Of course, without Dr. Fauci’s expertise, thousands, if not millions, will die. So what’s a man of science supposed to do?

Advertise with us

The Spanish flu happened in 1917. It has always happened in 1917. Yes, the clock strikes 13. Why do you ask?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.