Pastor Jonathan Shuttlesworth of the Revival Today TV ministry of Washington County refuses to be a “sissy” — even for Jesus. The Rev. Shuttlesworth has his priorities, and none of them involve turning the other cheek or loving his neighbor as himself if it requires taking social distancing seriously.

According to the minister, who hasn’t taken the Apostle Peter’s admonition to guard one’s tongue particularly seriously either, there’s something emasculating about washing one’s hands repeatedly during a pandemic while refraining from honest, godly physical contact with others just because you’re worried about coming into contact with a demonic virus.

“Shame on every European full gospel church, bunch of sissies, that shut down during this thing [pandemic],” Rev. Shuttlesworth growled in a widely posted rant on social media last month.

“If you’re putting out pamphlets and telling everybody to use Purell before they come into the sanctuary and don’t greet anyone, you should just turn in your ministry credentials and burn your church down — turn it into a casino of something,” he said. “You’re a loser. Bunch of pansies. No balls. Got neutered somewhere along the line and don’t realize it.”

Advertise with us

That, dear reader, is what the gospel according to Conan the Barbarian sounds like. If Rev. Shuttlesworth were just another backwoods snake-handler, such rantings would make for hilarious YouTube viewing assuming the inevitable Darwin Award-winning snakebite didn’t tarry too long.

But Rev. Shuttlesworth isn’t a solitary nut with a handful of followers content to sit in a bunker waiting for the Rapture. He’s the top dog and co-founder of a fairly sophisticated and popular multiracial, multigenerational, multimedia ministry that has national, if not global, ambitions.

Media-savvy and blessed with the good looks of a Bradley Cooper gone to seed or Police-era Sting when he’s sneering, Rev. Shuttlesworth doesn’t hide his “manly” authoritarian tendencies behind mawkish platitudes about loving strangers. Though thuggish at times, he’s as captivating and charismatic a personality as has ever paced a stage and has mastered the mechanics of preaching better than most.

“I’m going to announce it,” he said on Twitter recently. “We’re gonna hold an outdoor Easter blowout service. Not online. A national gathering. You come from all over, like Woodstock. And we’re gonna gather and lift up Jesus Christ.”

Like his “best friend in the world” Pastor Rodney Howard-Browne, who was arrested and charged for unlawful assembly and endangering public health at his Tampa, Fla., megachurch, Rev. Shuttlesworth isn’t inclined to observe the protocols of a pandemic if he considers them inconvenient in any way.

Advertise with us

The fact that even President Donald Trump has backed off from his aspiration to have churches filled on Easter doesn’t faze him. Rev. Shuttlesworth encourages his congregation to do as he does — tempt God by continuing to gather on Sunday mornings. After all, COVID-19 kills and sickens only unbelievers.

“Let me tell you — if the devil doesn’t want there to be mass gatherings — it’s time to hold mass gatherings,” Rev. Shuttlesworth told KDKA’s Paul Martino. “If I lived in Italy, I would call an open-air crusade to pray for the sick. If you have to go to jail, go to jail.”

So is Rev. Shuttlesworth evil or stupid? It doesn’t matter. If he follows through on his promise to have a Woodstock-like gathering on Easter in Washington County — then he’s as much a threat to public safety as the pastor arrested in Florida and the Louisiana megachurch pastor who was recently fined for conducting live services for hundreds.

Perhaps anticipating national finger-pointing in his direction regarding his threat to expose hundreds, if not thousands, of believers to asymptomatic carriers of the coronavirus, Rev. Shuttlesworth introduced caveats about the Easter gathering during his interview with Mr. Martino.

“When I said a Woodstock-style gathering,” he said referring to his recent tweet, “I meant because people will drive from all over the country that want to celebrate Easter. I didn’t mean we were going to roll around in the mud and do LSD.”

Advertise with us

Of course Rev. Shuttlesworth knows no one really had visions of naked Christians frolicking in the mud behind his church or a “saved” Jimi Hendrix shredding “The Star-Spangled Banner” at the early morning Easter service. He merely wants to deflect from his absurd contention that a non-wimpy brand of social distance can be practiced by hundreds or even thousands at that Resurrection morning service.

Meanwhile, those who aren’t gullible have only to think about recent news reports of 45 of 60 members of one choir in Washington state who became infected after a single choir practice. Two members of that choir have died. Those with a memory longer than a gnat’s will also recall that the epicenter of the coronavirus in South Korea was a secretive, cult-like megachurch. Churches are not supernaturally immune. Any preacher who says otherwise has blood on his or her hands.

Meanwhile, the federal government has almost depleted its current supply of body bags and the morgues of New York are filled past capacity. Florida and Louisiana are starting to see sharp rises in their infection rates, which is why the governors of those states are cracking down on incubators of the disease. They’re not sparing churches.

If Rev. Shuttlesworth is serious about exposing scores of citizens to a church gathering where a highly contagious disease is statistically likely to be present, then the service simply can’t be allowed to happen. Social distancing is not possible under those circumstances.

My suspicion is that the good reverend enjoys being provocative and perhaps fantasizes about being a First Amendment martyr for Christ, but would back down if the possibility of jail time and not just a fine were part of the deal. Depraved indifference to the health and safety of his congregation seems like it should warrant more than a misdemeanor and a rap on the knuckles. If congregants leave his Easter service infected, it will be a death sentence for someone, whether for the carrier or someone they infect down the line.

Advertise with us

We can already picture his legal defense once he’s sued for contributing to the deaths of many who went to his “outdoor Easter blowout service” despite the state’s warning against attending such gatherings. He’ll claim God laid it on his heart to celebrate that day and that anyone who may have been sickened and died is now “dancing in Glory with the Lord” even if it is as “pansy” an image as one can imagine of heaven. If that doesn’t work, he’ll blame the “free will” that God gave them. It was up to them to stay home or turn out to be infected. What he won’t do is blame himself.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.