America must be entering a season of Christian repentance. Recently, the owner of a Mississippi event hall who originally refused to allow an interracial couple to have their wedding reception citing prohibitions against mixed marriages she insisted were in the Bible, repented after searching in vain for them.

After a deluge of bad press and overwhelmingly negative community feedback, the owner of the event hall repented and invited the couple to use her facility after all. She blamed growing up during Mississippi’s Jim Crow era and her “sincerely held Christian beliefs” for the error.

In a similar intersection of faith and ignorance this week, the Christian owners of a winery in California’s San Joaquin Valley at first refused to allow a lesbian couple to rent the vineyard for their wedding citing their strongly held Christian beliefs. After community protests and disastrous prognostications for their economic future in such a pluralistic community, one of the owners got a revelation and issued the following mea culpa:

“Our staff, our customers and our community have helped me see that I was wrong. Our policy has been changed, effective immediately. All couples are welcome to hire our facilities for weddings and celebrations that go with them. I am sincerely sorry to have caused anyone pain at a time that should be joyous.”

Hallelujah! In keeping with the example of the Apostle Paul, the scales can fall from the eyes of any person encountering an unexpected truth, though in these cases, an economic incentive or two might’ve nudged repentance along.

Advertise with us

Sometimes, repentance is spurred by a conscience truly stricken by the knowledge of one’s overwhelming hypocrisy. The seemingly never-ending stream of “gay conversion therapy” ministers who renounce their former practice while coming out as gay themselves — attests to this. In fact, the more bellicose religious people are in their denunciation of homosexuality, the more inclined we are to believe they’re simply projecting their own self-loathing.

But who are we to begrudge the sincerity of another person’s repentance? As Jesus said as recorded in Luke 15:7: “In the same way, I tell you there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over 99 self-righteous ones who do not need to repent.”

This brings us to the latest case of high-profile repentance — that endlessly comical scoundrel, televangelist and so-called faith healer Benny Hinn.

Mr. Hinn, who is not ordained by any denomination except the Almighty Dollar, is so transparently fake that it is hard to work up the same kind of animus against him that many feel viscerally for his fellow cardsharps and religious charlatans.

Earlier this month, Mr. Hinn did something I believed was uncharacteristic of him and his brethren of the golden cloth — he repented of “selling God’s blessings” and pronounced the so-called “prosperity gospel” that he has preached since the 1980s as “offensive to God.”

Advertise with us

“I am correcting my own theology and you need to all know it,” the suave fox said to an audience of lambs and chickens who had not expected such a dramatic departure from the usual script. “The blessings of God are not for sale. And miracles are not for sale. And prosperity is not for sale.”

The mind boggles. There was something almost Jesus-like in Mr. Hinn’s pronouncements, which made the moment even more confusing. “I think giving [seed money] has become such a gimmick,” he said. “It’s making me sick to my stomach. And I’ve been sick for a while, too, I just couldn’t say it. And now the lid is off. I’ve had it. you know why? I don’t want to get to heaven and be rebuked.”

It was an interesting moment for the wily disciple of materialism and his audience. He appeared to be renouncing the very core of the message that brought them all together in the first place. But unlike Jesus, Mr. Hinn had no real intention of overturning the money tables or brandishing a metaphorical whip against himself or any of his fellow money changers.

Pacing his studio sanctuary and taking the temperature of the room like the great performer he is, Mr. Hinn indeed “renounced” the prosperity gospel by name, but he was careful not to go too far. He did not renounce his own ill-gotten gains, estimated in the tens of millions over several decades. As a sign of his repentance, Mr. Hinn did not offer to give back a single cent of a fortune extorted by fraud and bad theology.

At least he recognized the error of his ways, right? When someone repents, we’re inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt until we see how their life conforms to their words. To many, he sounded sincere, if a bit conflicted. Alas, it turns out that Benny Hinn is a bit of a serial repenter who has been down this Damascus road before.

Advertise with us

Benny Hinn did the same thing in the 1980s, according to a piece in Christianity Today before resuming the long con after the novelty of forgoing the fleecing of the sheep wore off. He also repented of the prosperity gospel in the 1990s, but couldn’t quite give it up. There’s something about the allure of millions of tax free dollars rolling in every year that tempers the conscience in the end.

A decade ago when the U.S. Senate investigated the ministries of Mr. Hinn and his fellow prosperity preachers Joyce Meyer, Kenneth Copeland, Creflo Dollar, Paula While and Eddie Long — the Sinful Six as I call them —  he once again cooperated with the congressional investigation and pretended to be over and done with the prosperity gospel. He’s believed to be currently under investigation for tax evasion following an IRS raid of his Texas headquarters, but there is no confirmation of this. Still, if his ministry is feeling heat, it could explain this latest season of repentance on his part.

Benny Hinn has been here before. He’s faced his congregation and delivered a version of the same repentant sermon many times before. He’s beat his breast and proclaimed God’s anger at the theology that has kept him neck deep in mammon and mansions for years only to return to swindling those begging to be swindled.

Two millennia ago, Jesus had a simple test for a rich young ruler who claimed to want to follow him while holding on to the world’s riches: “Sell all that you have, give to the poor, and follow me.” It was an elegantly brutal demand that separated the wheat from the chaff in the man’s soul quickly enough.

The Scripture said that the rich man “went away dejected” because he wasn’t willing to give up a single dime of his vast fortune to stand in the light. Benny Hinn is many things, but no one can accuse him of taking the words of Jesus either literally or seriously. Hell will freeze over before Benny Hinn makes a show of repenting of the prosperity gospel that goes beyond pious lip service. After all, God saw fit to give him all that intoxicating cash in the first place.

Advertise with us

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.