Those of us old enough to remember the events of Sept. 11, 2001, recall it as a day in which our senses struggled to keep up with the indelible sounds and images of what felt like the world falling apart.
We remember it as a day that was mostly mediated through repeated images of the twin towers collapsing like a monstrous game of Jenga with billowing clouds of white and gray smoke providing an apocalyptic contrast to that day’s brilliant late summer blue skies.
The breaking news chyrons were locked into place on every channel whether the images were of the same people rushing in and out of the billowing dark clouds of the Pentagon or the remote shot of a field in Somerset County that provided evidence of a remarkable act of heroism in the sky that day.
We remember that day nearly two decades ago with a vividness aided and abetted by the testimony of those who were there and the painful absences of those who would never see another day.
Most Americans experienced that day without any social media besides email alerts and frantic phone calls to and from loved ones. We stood or sat in front of our TVs absorbing each unprecedented moment with a numbness we allowed to overwhelm us for the sake of our collective sanity.
It was a day in which very few noticed or cared about the absence of television commercials, the life-blood of our media industrial complex and capitalist hive mind. It was a day in which a breaking news story that featured a plane plowing into the second of the two World Trade Center towers in real time was interrupted by breaking news about the Pentagon attack.
Read More
Watching those events in the Post-Gazette newsroom with stunned colleagues that morning was probably the first and last time I remember gasps of horror bringing nearly everything to a standstill except the eternally ringing phones.
For once, there was no gallows humor among the throng of reporters who stood with crossed arms and gaping mouths around televisions scattered around the room. One young colleague whose aunt worked at the World Trade Center burst into tears the moment she walked into the newsroom and asked what was happening.
When she bolted from the newsroom to contact her family in New York, it was the permission we all needed to break away from television’s hypnotic play-by-play to write the first draft of the history of that terrible day. It was time to go from the macro of a terror-spawned apocalypse to the micro of individual tragedies laid bare by the attacks that morning.
I recall a PG reporter in Harrisburg being hurriedly dispatched to New York, though I could be shaky on the details of where he may have started from when the day began. Still, we managed to have reports from Ground Zero filed by our own people in the next edition as well as wire service reporting. We had a Washington bureau, so the Pentagon was covered.
We also covered the crash of Flight 93 better than any paper in the nation thanks to regional proximity and a tag team of superb reporters and editors with deep roots and sources in the area. It may have been the end of the world as far as any of us knew, but it needed to be covered as if it was just another frenetic day at a newspaper of record.
Most Americans and those experiencing our national tragedy with sympathetic interest or malicious fascination around the world did so through nonstop television.
You could turn on the television at any time in the days and weeks that followed and see endless loops of Sept. 11 disaster footage. This was years before the concept of trigger warnings or “disaster porn” caught on. The only images out of deference to viewer sympathies that TV refused to show after initially broadcasting them were of those poor souls falling and jumping to their deaths from the towers.
We remember the sleepless night in that first week watching endless footage of New York City firefighters hosing the rubble of what used to be the twin towers in the illuminated darkness of Ground Zero.
Even in the middle of the night, the breaking news banners were solidly affixed even as sleep-deprived anchors struggled to find something meaningful to report or interesting to say so that insomniacs wouldn’t switch to the same image on another channel.
It is interesting to note that the youngest soldiers serving in Iraq and Afghanistan were infants on Sept. 11, 2001, and some soldiers enlisting today hadn’t even been born. They have no memories of the tactile terror of that day. Odd details don’t stick out for them like they do for those of us who were prisoners of a primal need to know what was happening at every second.
These young soldiers don’t suffer from false memories triggered by our collective desire to make sense of the unthinkable. Still they are the ones who are now paying the biggest price for our collective illusions.
There is no strategic vision underlying our wars — not even “revenge.” Our wars are now justified by an inchoate desire to protect the homeland from fanatics thousands of miles away, no matter how many more of them we create while defending ourselves “over there.” Their hateful ideology has turned out to be more resistant to bombs and drones than their caliphate was.
This year, Sept. 11 falls on a Wednesday. The obsessive fascination with a day that launched two wars of choice with its disastrous trillion-dollar consequences and loss of lives, treasure and ideals has long passed. The destructive effects of these wars on “the liberated” continue to linger in those countries and across an entire destabilized region. The “peace” long prophesied by proponents of those wars has failed to materialize.
The “patriotism” that once poured accelerant on those wars has given way to routine and cynicism. Our politics, also deformed by those never-ending wars, has produced a president who, until he was double-crossed by reality, believed he could “make a deal” with the Taliban to end our longest war during the week of the 18th anniversary of 9/11. It is as if he has zero understanding of our brutal mutual history.
Even with interest fading, Sept. 11 continues to stay one or two steps ahead of our imagination in ways that would have seemed inconceivable in the awful roar of that day almost two decades ago.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.