Unless Jeffrey Epstein’s body has been swapped with a surgically altered clone, we can all agree that the 66-year-old accused millionaire pedophile is dead. Whether he died of an “apparent suicide” or by more nefarious means will be determined by the New York Medical Examiner’s pending autopsy report.
Meanwhile, everyone in the world already has a theory about what happened to a man who died in federal custody three weeks after another alleged suicide attempt failed. Assorted domestic and international terrorists (and El Chapo) aside, Epstein was the highest profile federal defendant/witness in custody. By all rights, he should not be dead.
I have a confession. I believe Jeffrey Epstein committed suicide of his own volition. That doesn’t mean he didn’t have the tacit approval of the powerful men he could’ve — and most likely would’ve — implicated in his trial for sexually assaulting and trafficking minors.
Jeffrey Epstein committed suicide while in federal custody in Manhattan’s Metropolitan Correctional Center. It is a site with a fearsome reputation, but it is run by officials who haven’t figured out how to prevent inmates inclined toward suicide from doing themselves in if they’re determined enough.
The MCC is reportedly operating with 70% of the staffing recommended to make the patrols necessary to ensure that a pair of eyes falls on each inmate regularly. Epstein was taken off 24-hour suicide watch days earlier because authorities and a psychologist somehow reached the conclusion that he was not a danger to himself.
We can legitimately question how that conclusion was reached and whether those who determined Epstein wasn’t a danger to himself had nefarious reasons or were simply incompetent, but this appears to be the way the system was set up to operate. It is ad hoc and unresponsive to extraordinary circumstances. The bureaucrats in charge appear ill-equipped to imagine a worst-case scenario like Epstein succeeding in killing himself on their watch.
Read More
Epstein had no roommate, as is usually mandated after a suicide attempt. His two guards were on forced overtime and didn’t make the mandated patrols or check in on him once every 30 minutes. The guards discovered his body at 6:30 a.m. after, presumably, sleeping through the night — or at least not patrolling.
Every conspiracy needs a fall guy and these poor working stiffs are probably it. They couldn’t do their jobs properly because their supervisors made it impossible for sleep-deprived men to earn their pay honestly by not staffing Epstein’s wing properly. These guards should lose their jobs, but so should their immediate supervisors and their bosses, too.
Speaking of the authorities, every bureaucrat in the chain of command who had responsibility for maintaining Epstein’s safety until his trial should be sanctioned and/or fired once every irregularity that compromised the prisoner’s safety is accounted for. If Epstein bribed guards to look the other way or had an “inside man” greasing the bureaucratic wheels with higher-ups, that needs to be revealed.
Because Epstein was a master manipulator, I give him most of the credit for his own death. I don’t find most of the conspiracy theories persuasive because we know from countless exposes of how most jail facilities are run that the folks in charge are usually incompetent and are usually only good at exacerbating the worst of an already bad system.
As headlines about our own Allegheny County Jail confirm, suicides in prisons and in jails happen with a sickening regularity. Unless someone is strapped down 24/7, it is nearly impossible to stop an inmate from killing him or herself if the person is that determined.
Epstein realized he had very little to live for once he was dragged into custody after arriving back in the U.S. from his French villa. The indifference of the criminal justice system toward his young victims more than a decade ago has been replaced by a hyper-vigilant and morally outraged public opinion determined to nail accused pedophiles. In a way, Epstein’s suicide was a confession that he was, indeed, guilty as charged. The evidence was irrefutable and none of his friends in high places was inclined to save him this time.
Still, his many accusers deserved closure and a measure of justice that only a conviction, not death, could provide. The criminal case against Epstein may be moot, but the investigations should continue, and the lawsuits by his victims against his estate. There are powerful men out there who may have been initially relieved when Epstein killed himself, but they will be quaking in their very expensive boots again soon.
Unlike President Donald Trump and a few loud voices in media and entertainment who speculate wildly about a cabal of sinister rich people and a former president putting a “hit” on Jeffrey Epstein, I think the truth is far more banal than these elaborate conspiracies allow.
If evidence to the contrary eventually presents itself, I’ll listen to it and change my mind accordingly. For now, it looks as if Jeffrey Epstein became the center of a perfect storm of bureaucratic incompetence, a failure of proper federal oversight and his own despair knowing that he would likely spend the rest of his life in prison branded a child molester. For a millionaire libertine, that was an unthinkable proposition.
Killing himself to evade justice and the tyranny of his own conscience is the only theory among the conspiracies surrounding the death of Jeffrey Epstein that makes any sense to me.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.