History is written by the winners, they say, but for far too long, despite the outcome of the Civil War, large segments of America’s story continued, perplexingly, to be written by segregationists.
Even when our nation finally summoned enough moral will to begin overturning racist customs and practices, addressing the sad consequences of the past has taken decades. It isn’t over yet.
Yesterday brought a particularly sweet victory in this quest, when Major League Baseball announced that Josh Gibson, Pittsburgh legend of the Negro Leagues, is now the leading hitter in baseball history.
Scarring segregation
His career batting average of .372 surpasses Ty Cobb’s by six points. Gibson also now holds the record for single-season batting average — .466 in 1943, with the Homestead Grays.
Early that year, he’d been diagnosed with a brain tumor. He decided to endure the resulting terrible headaches, rather than risk debilitating surgery.
Segregation scarred his life. The first big effort to rectify it within baseball also hurt him deeply, when he was passed over in favor of Jackie Robinson to integrate the sport. Disappointed friends and colleagues said it broke his heart.
Read More
That was in April 1947. He died in December and was buried in Pittsburgh’s Allegheny Cemetery in an unmarked grave.
Acknowledging Black players’ achievements can’t undo injustices of the past, but I’d have thought people would express more agreement and satisfaction with MLB actions than is evident in the initial, online response to the news. Is the pushback motivated by an insistence on statistical purity or by racial resentment?
The historians and baseball stats geeks involved in the process anticipated public disagreement. “Diehards may not accept the stats, but that’s OK,” said Larry Lester, an author and researcher who served on MLB’s 16-member Negro Leagues Statistical Review Committee. “I welcome the conversations at the bar or the barbershop or the pool hall.”
What precipitated these big changes was MLB’s decision, in December 2020, to recognize the Negro Leagues as major leagues. A considerable effort then began to integrate Negro League statistics with the MLB database.
That same year, the Covid pandemic shortened the season from 162 games to only 60, yet its results were accepted. This set the stage for the MLB committee to accept statistics from the long-ago Negro Leagues’ shorter official seasons (from 1920 to 1948).
Better than MLB
Critics of the new, integrated MLB statistics seem to be zeroing in on those shorter seasons. How can you compare the batting average of someone who only played 60 to 80 games, they ask, with someone who played 160?
But the number of games played depends on the word “official.”
Mr. Lester, MLB committee member and a historian whose decades of work includes many interviews with Negro League players, long ago established that they played many more games than the official schedules reflected.
Segregation limited the financial resources of the Negro teams, so “barnstorming” games — against, say, the teams of small towns they passed through en route to big-city stadiums — brought in critical revenues.
“They played almost every day, sometimes two or three games a day and not in the same location,” Mr. Lester told the New York Times. “So they were playing probably 150 to 175 games a year, but only 60 to 80 games counted in the league standings.”
Making the historians’ work even harder is the fact that American newspapers did not consistently cover Negro League games. Official MLB historian John Thorn said that about 75% of Negro League box scores have been documented.
The effects of segregation dictated how and where Black men played baseball, reduced both their team income and their individual pay, and undermined public record-keeping of their achievements. Separate was definitely not equal.
That some would deny them recognition now due to the consequences of having been denied recognition way back then sounds like continued injustice to me. It sounds like racist bullying.
There’s one indisputable argument in favor of the Negro Leaguers’ inclusion: their prowess against the major leagues.
In researching his early 1990s documentary series “Baseball,” filmmaker and historian Ken Burns found that Negro Leaguers had competed against all-white major league teams 438 times, in offseason exhibition games. The Negro Leaguers won 309 of those games.
The greatest of them
The Negro Leaguers athletic achievements were great. Josh Gibson was arguably the greatest of them. People called him “the black Babe Ruth.” But he died so poor that he was buried in an unmarked grave.
In 1972, after a period of widespread racial unrest in America, Josh Gibson was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame solely on the strength of his Negro Leagues record. Not long afterward, MLB also made sure that a proper tombstone was placed on his grave here in Pittsburgh.
Now he is getting his rightful place in newly desegregated sports history. That history is being painstakingly rewritten to reflect athletic realities as they unfolded in a messed up world. This is the best we can do, so we should.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Payment or passion: What's really driving Palestine protests?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.