Joe Biden waded carefully into the moral quagmire Sunday at Morehouse College, Martin Luther King Jr.’s alma mater.
The president’s selection months ago as commencement speaker at the historically Black, all-male college had prompted some protests from groups unhappy with his stance on the Israel-Hamas conflict, and on Sunday a few graduates and one faculty member reportedly sat with their backs turned to him during his speech.
Contrary to Morehouse College President David Thomas’s advice against a “campaign stump speech,” Mr. Biden larded his address with plenty of “here’s what I’m doing for you” material. But in addressing the Middle East war, he summoned moral nuance and even wisdom — which is exactly what’s missing from the pro-Palestinian protests.
Sorrow, not anger
The activists demand what they view as moral purity from our government, universities and corporations, but they, their methods and their heroes are far from pure. Is it too much to hope that some were really listening to him? Probably so — especially since a sizable portion of the “college protesters” aren’t actually students.
As President Biden said, “This is one of the hardest, most complicated problems in the world.” He began his remarks boldly, describing a mother and daughter’s deaths at the hands of Hamas butchers, two deaths of 1,200, one ghastly atrocity among so many committed on Oct. 7, when Hamas chose to break the last cease-fire.
But Mr. Biden quickly pivoted to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, endorsed a two-state solution and summed up the current tragedy with: “There’s nothing easy about it. I know it angers and frustrates many of you, including my family. But most of all I know it breaks your heart. It breaks mine as well.”
He is right to speak of heartbreak. Sorrow, not anger, is the wellspring of wisdom. Mature observers will mourn both the atrocities of Oct. 7 and the loss of innocent Palestinian lives as Israel wages war against the genocidal terrorists of Hamas.
Outside agitators
By contrast, the graduate students at MIT who told classmate Talia Khan, per her testimony to Congress, that “the people at the Nova massacre deserved to die because they were partying on stolen land” are clearly not motivated by sorrow — or any other laudable human emotion.
(Such a horrific claim, by the way, springs directly from the push for “land acknowledgements.” In addition to its shocking immorality, however, the MIT students’ assertion is historically inaccurate; the Jewish people have the oldest known claim to the land.)
Over the weekend, as President Biden extolled “peaceful, nonviolent protest” at Morehouse, police broke up a pro-Palestinian encampment at the University of Michigan due to public safety violations that included “overloaded power sources and open flames.” This came a few days after the protesters targeted the university president’s home, putting fake body bags on her lawn and chanting slogans over a bullhorn.
Also over the weekend, Penn Students Against the Occupation of Palestine announced plans to occupy a campus building — is occupation okay if you believe your cause is just? — but police removed the demonstrators within hours. Public safety officials said the students had brought lock-picking tools and used zip ties and barbed wire to block building entrances.
That kind of preparation bespeaks help from experienced outsiders. And indeed, among the 19 people arrested at Penn, only six were students there.
Paid to protest
At Columbia University in New York City the protests are of such size and duration that a big chunk of last week’s New York magazine was devoted to it, with interviews, photos and polls provided by student staffers at the university’s own Daily Spectator.
But it was the New York Post that got the biggest scoop. When the pro-Palestinian throng converged on Columbia’s Hamilton Hall on April 30, a photo of maintenance worker Mario Torres pushing back at one of the masked invaders went viral. The Post quickly identified the masked man as James Carlson, the 40-year-old heir of millionaire ad execs, father to a supermodel’s child, owner of a $3.4 million Brooklyn townhouse, and a well-known, allegedly violent anarchist with a long rap sheet.
Police say that about 30% of the protesters arrested along with Carlson were “outside agitators.”
This reminds me of the Occupy Wall Street-style protest that sprang up here in 2011. When a group of activists left their Downtown encampment at Mellon Green to eat at a nearby bagel place, they could be overheard discussing how much they were getting paid — by persons or groups unknown — for each day they stayed at the protest site.
Isn’t that the defining difference between “grassroots” and “Astroturf”?
I don’t doubt that many of today’s youthful protesters are sincere in their concerns. But some more cynical force is at work here. Some activists are professionals, and others are being used, with or without their knowledge. We are right to be skeptical of those whose hearts break only for one group of people — and of those whose hearts don’t break at all.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Mayor Ed Gainey doesn't respect Pittsburgh.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.