Since the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and the city of Pittsburgh are entertaining enough to keep the “local politics” portion of my brain thoroughly occupied, I rarely turn my attention beyond our borders.
But when a headline in a British newspaper trumpets an American city’s historical first and praises American women for “showing the world what’s possible,” well, that piques my interest.
The accompanying photo in The Guardian article was particularly eye-catching: St. Paul, Minnesota’s newly inaugurated city council members all dressed in brilliant purples, reds, pinks and even traditional Hmong clothing.
The historical first
The historical first is this: Seven female candidates (three of them incumbents) won their respective wards to become the first all-female council governing a major American city — Minnesota’s second largest, the state capital and “twin” to Minneapolis.
All seven are under the age of 40, all are progressives and six are women of color. One of them told The Guardian that she finds the group’s diversity “amazing and affirming.”
Diversity?
Again, all the winners are women, all are young, all are progressives, and all but one are people of color. How is this “diverse”?
Homogenous is diverse, and war is peace. At first glance, it seemed that wrong-headed and thus deserving of a little snark. “Diverse? Oh, you mean ‘not white, not male and not conservative, centrist or even liberal.’”
A term of high moral value to some, certainly to these candidates’ supporters, “diversity” was being used to elevate — or obscure — a simple shift in power.
But vocabulary aside, it was a shift that is, in important ways, healthy — and one that was a long time coming. The triumph, however, is not for diversity. It’s for representative democracy.
Pittsburgh and St. Paul, like many other American cities, experienced huge population shifts in the post-war era, as newly affluent white families moved from crowded industrial centers to green, more spacious suburbs. In St. Paul, from 1970 to 2020, the white population dropped steadily in each decade, from 94% to 49%. The Black population grew steadily from 3.5% to 16.5%, while the Asian population exploded, from 0.2% to 19.2%.
Population changes eventually produce political change, though the lag time varies: Like Pittsburgh, St. Paul got its first female council member in the mid-1950s. Around the same time, Pittsburgh elected its first Black council member, but St. Paul did not until about 20 years ago.
Diversity and politics
Now, one kind of diversity St. Paul’s council can truthfully boast is ethnic diversity. Its members include one Iranian-American, one Hmong, two Blacks, one Korean-American and one “transracial adoptee.”
If this group doesn’t exactly reflect the city’s ethnic make-up “by the numbers,” it’s clear that long unrepresented groups now have advocates for their needs at city hall. That’s a great thing. Ethnic diversity’s strength is in making more citizens feel enfranchised and engaged with civic life.
We are stronger if everyone has “skin in the game.” But if our way of assessing diversity is only skin-deep, then it’s pretty darn shallow.
It’s also ultimately inadequate. The vast majority of us want the same things out of life, no matter our gender or race. We want freedom, opportunity, meaningful work and a safe, healthy place to live.
An effective city government can greatly enhance our ability to enjoy those blessings, but its effectiveness depends on whether its leaders understand things like how to nurture a health economy and how to foster public safety.
Our most significant “diversity” — citizen by citizen, leader by leader — is in how we believe these goals can best be achieved. Those differences of opinion constitute varying political philosophies.
That’s where the St. Paul city council’s chances look weak. Any city where uniformly progressive ideas have really taken hold — think of formerly great and beautiful West Coast locales like Portland, San Francisco, Oakland, and large chunks of Seattle — have become dangerous, depressed and derelict.
There, the philosophical and political pushback has already begun, but the news has been slow to reach St. Paul — and Pittsburgh.
Never represented
In my 30 years here, I have never felt represented by any woman elected to local office, despite sharing with them my gender, race and even ethnic heritage. And I don’t think we’ve ever had a competent city government — witness block after block of abandoned buildings and vacant lots, owned by the city, desired by community groups and developers whose applications have been gathering dust Downtown for over a decade.
Ideas and competence in carrying those ideas out matter more than skin color and ethnicity. Congrats to St. Paul voters for electing leaders who look more like them, but real progress will be if they’ve elected leaders who can actually lead, no matter what they look like.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Haley, DeSantis, Kennedy, West, Stein, please, please keep running!.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.